It wouldn't be among the best, like Trials and Tribble-ations was. But it would be passable fan service. And a cool way for Jonathan Frakes to show up.
The Most Disliked Episode of ENT, Final Round: 2021 Edition...
- Thread starter Farscape One
- Start date
It wouldn't be among the best, like Trials and Tribble-ations was. But it would be passable fan service. And a cool way for Jonathan Frakes to show up.
I also didn´t like these are the voyages. there are worse episodes in discovery though.
V
Vale
Guest
I think the conceit of 24th-century Trek crews watching historical events or interacting with historical characters on the holodeck is an good one – after all, if they can do it for Dixon Hill or Sherlock Holmes for fun, and the EMH can do it for Crell Moset, then why not Archer, or Kirk, or whoever – but they way it was done in "These Are The Voyages..." was just flat-out disrespectful to Enterprise, especially as it made TNG characters the focus.
As a series finale, definitely. It's been called an "abomination", and that's sadly accurate. With a few tweaks to make it a midseason episode, though, it would've been Ok.
"TATV..." is a terrible idea for a series finale and incredibly disappointing. But "Precious Cargo" is absolute bottom-level garbage and almost totally irredeemable.
Similar threads
