The most disliked episode of ENT - Final Part

[BlueStuff]

Something a little different for the final round. To proceed as normal, it would be over very quickly indeed, so here we have the losers and runners up of each season:

Season One: Terra Nova
Wild Card: Rogue Planet
Season Two: Horizon
Wild Card: Dawn
Season Three: Extinction
Wild Card: Chosen Realm
Season Four: Storm Front (I)
Wild Card: Storm Front (II)

*RULES*

Give what you consider to be the best/your preferred episode ONE point, and briefly explain WHY. Be sure to copy and paste the list with your point added. When an episode reaches 4 points, it is eliminated (or saved in this case!) Then a NEW round begins (in this thread) with the numbers restored to 0. Vote ONCE per round. And enjoy!


Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Chosen Realm - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

 

[Tiberius]

I'm gonna add a point for Chosen Realm. A nice commentary on how stupid fundamentalist beliefs are.

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Chosen Realm - 1
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

 

[Seven of Five]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Chosen Realm - 2
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

Yeah I'll vote for Chosen Realm too. Best episode here, which isn't saying much! Despite the removal of what I think are some of ENT's worst in the previous rounds, there's still plenty of mediocrity to fight over here.

 

[Skywalker]

This isn't about which episodes are the worst, just those that are most disliked.

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Chosen Realm - 3
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

Voting for "Chosen Realm" for the same reasons as those before me. I dislike it less than the other episodes left.

 

[Admiral Shran]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Chosen Realm - 4
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

I'll save Chosen Realm then. I liked that it showed how religion can be distorted, but didn't go out and say that ALL religion must be abandoned (*cough* Who Watches the Watchers *cough*). It also provided us with some info. for the overall Xindi Arc, which helps it somewhat.

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

 

[Kotik]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 1
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 0

Horizon gets a point from me, because, while not award-winning, it was one of the less boring of the lot. Travis was the red-headed bastard child of the main cast, but at least he got a good episode here.

 

[Admiral Shran]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 1
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 1

I'll give a point to Storm Front (II). At least it wasn't boring, a retread of something previous or laughable. It also finally ended the Temporal War End, which is good thing.

 

[Seven of Five]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 1
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 2

I'll vote Storm Front (II) too. Like I said in round 4, by this point the Temporal Cold War made no sense, so it was good that it was put out of its misery before doing more harm. Whilst it was all very silly, the two-parter was sort of fun.

 

[KNH]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 1
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0
Storm Front (II) - 3

Thirding Storm Front (II) for the reasons stated above.

 

[TrekAlliance92]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 0

Final Save for Storm Front (II) - An exciting episode with the Enterprise fighting laser-armed alien space Nazi WWII plains in the atmosphere over America!!

 

[Seven of Five]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 1

Voting for Storm Front (I) now, for my previous reasons. I won't repeat myself.

 

[Admiral Shran]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 2

Storm Front (I) - It's bland and average, but doesn't deserve to be in this group. It's certainly not the worst of Season Four - you know of which episode I speak.

 

[Kotik]

Why did you guys remove the point that I gave to Horizon?

 

[Seven of Five]

The scores all go back to zero when an episode is eliminated.

 

[Mr Silver]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0
Storm Front (I) - 3

I don't mind "Storm Front" - it's not exactly at home with the other episodes on the list.

 

[TrekAlliance92]

Storm Front (!) is saved! Next?

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 0
Extinction - 0

 

[Seven of Five]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 0
Dawn - 1
Extinction - 0

Not sure whether to vote for Dawn or Terra Nova, as I probably like these two a scooch more than the other three.

I'll go with Dawn. Pretty average really, and TNG's Darmok was vastly superior. Probably more interesting than what's left though. Probably.

 

[ALF]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 1
Dawn - 1
Extinction - 0

I'll vote for Horizon. I watched it again the other day, and it's not so bad. Travis has so few episodes... the parts I did like were finding out about life on a slow transport ship. Very interesting. It's tough to sit through the scenes of Travis' brother being a dick, but the battles are quite exciting. B story with Trip and Tpol and Frankenstein is good.

PS. I'm glad that Terra Nova was voted earlier as worst for season one. What a gob of shale. There's nothing I like about that one. It's frustrating to watch as the characters really grate on the nerves.

 

[Skywalker]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 2
Dawn - 1
Extinction - 0

"Horizon" isn't a terrible episode, it's just boring.

 

[Supernuke]

Terra Nova - 0
Rogue Planet - 0
Horizon - 3
Dawn - 1
Extinction - 0

Voting for "Horizon" because it's the best one left!