• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The Interstellar Song Contest grade and discussion thread

How do you rate The Interstellar Song Contest?


  • Total voters
    34
My guess is that she is not this season's big bad.
From a narrative point of view, doing the reveal in episode six means episode seven has to have a twist up its sleeve.
In plot, she needs the readings from the vindicator, so maybe what has happened to Earth is as unexpected to her as to the Doctor.
I wouldn't be surprised if they became reluctant allies against a greater threat.

They’ve already said The Rani and Conrad are only two thirds of the big bad anyway. (We really all should move on from Buffy soon.)
 
I think it would be a wonderful kind of full circle moment for the season to end with Carole Ann Ford regenerating into a new Susan and then the Doctor and Susan go off on new adventures together just like it all began.

I think it’s vital to give the character a regen on screen too tbh.
 
Another blah one for me. I was hoping for something that actually played cleverly on the song contest somehow, even -especially- if it was camp, but instead that was over in a few minutes and we got a by the numbers bad guy with a ticking clock plot with a tech the tech solution worthy of Voyager.
I have no idea who that was at the end. Reveal fell completely flat. I've googled, there's no need to explain it.
 
Another blah one for me. I was hoping for something that actually played cleverly on the song contest somehow, even -especially- if it was camp, but instead that was over in a few minutes and we got a by the numbers bad guy with a ticking clock plot with a tech the tech solution worthy of Voyager.
I have no idea who that was at the end. Reveal fell completely flat. I've googled, there's no need to explain it.

The ticking clock and tech the tech was ripped directly from Ecclestone’s finale, so it was RTD2 era doing a George Lucas. It rhymes.
 
There were a triad of Gods mentioned earlier. Wish the mavity joke was gone. Never made sense to stat with.
I never read it as a joke but rather an indication that something was wrong with reality so badly that even The Doctor didn't noticed. I've always assumed it had long-term implications that may finally come to head in "The Reality War."
 
I did find the fact that The Doctor using The Vindicator to find earth is possibly leads to it's destruction a surprise. It looks like The Doctor's attempts to get back to Earth might be what leads to it's destruction or at least helps the Ranis do it, if that's what they're up to.
 
Another blah one for me. I was hoping for something that actually played cleverly on the song contest somehow, even -especially- if it was camp, but instead that was over in a few minutes and we got a by the numbers bad guy with a ticking clock plot with a tech the tech solution worthy of Voyager.
I have no idea who that was at the end. Reveal fell completely flat. I've googled, there's no need to explain it.
"tech solution worthy of Voyager" :guffaw:
 
I did find the fact that The Doctor using The Vindicator to find earth is possibly leads to it's destruction a surprise. It looks like The Doctor's attempts to get back to Earth might be what leads to it's destruction or at least helps the Ranis do it, if that's what they're up to.
That's about the level of "cleverness" I expect from RTD at this point. I hope the finale doesn't suck.
 
There were a triad of Gods mentioned earlier. Wish the mavity joke was gone. Never made sense to stat with.

It’s a clumsy way of showing how fluid the universe is to change currently. If we’re lucky. If not, it’s a shit joke that’s outstayed its welcome.
The triad/trinity is going to be the Rani, cardboard cutout bad man Conrad (who is basically the same shit as Buffys own triad) and one other. The leaks will be right I suspect.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top