• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers The Interstellar Song Contest grade and discussion thread

How do you rate The Interstellar Song Contest?


  • Total voters
    28
4/10 - and I'm being generous. I'd rather listen to Bang-Bang-a-Boom! than watch this again. Padded out, cliche, and turning the Doctor into a torturer? What a load of rubbish. I'm on the fence about giving it a zero for that. How many times has he faced the end of the universe and not turned into a drug cartel enforcer that hooks up jumper cables someone's nipples? :angryrazz:
 
It was a fun episode but some stuff plot conveniences let it down for me. Gave it a 6.

Rimmer would be proud of the hard light hologram!

Apparently, it's way easy to kill 3 trillion people. Just transmit delta waves and viewers will die. Seems unlikely but if that were a real risk, they'd limit their TV, holograms or whatever from passing that to the viewer. Also, the people with right skills were always right there for whatever was needed. The Doctor even jokes about it. And all those people blown into space but were revived?! They hand waved that by saying the Doctor's modification to the "mavity" "suspended" them, which made them saveable. Ok, whatever. They wanted the dramatic visual but not the consequences.

The supporting characters were nice. Belinda was great as always although her early meltdown wasn't believable. She's already seen worse.

As for the reveals, I was unspoiled for both so they totally surprised me.

Woot! Susan! I'd been hoping she'd be back. Now, the Doctor better find her for real and not make this another tease like last season!

The Rani. Well, that's interesting. But the reveal that Ms. Flood is the Rani was underwhelming. Just showing Ms. Flood randomly every episode doesn't make the reveal more interesting. But, I like the idea of the Rani returning and hope RTD has a good plan for her.

And, UGH, no more flipping bigeneration!! No more! Be done with it! It happening the first time was ok. Not needed but not bad. RTD discussing the retroactive bigeneration to all previous regenerations is just stupid and best forgotten. But going forward . . . :confused:
 
It's a cheap way of explaining why there's two incarnations for a team-up without temporal shenanigans (since Time Lords meeting themselves is SUPPOSED to be rare barring outside forces like The Moment, other Time Lords mucking about, etc) and getting around the "older self can't remember stuff from newer self until it happens" rule Moffatt established in Time Crash (a rare case of a meeting without any outside influence).
 
Think the finale will muck it up? As RTD finales usually do?
Honestly, I find finales in general to be the season's weakest offerings, regardless the showrunner, as neither Moffat nor Chibnall wrote a finale I cared that much for either. So yes, I have low expectations for the finale, though that's fine. This has been a pretty good season all the same, and a disappointing finale won't change that.
 
It's a cheap way of explaining why there's two incarnations for a team-up without temporal shenanigans (since Time Lords meeting themselves is SUPPOSED to be rare barring outside forces like The Moment, other Time Lords mucking about, etc) and getting around the "older self can't remember stuff from newer self until it happens" rule Moffatt established in Time Crash (a rare case of a meeting without any outside influence).
It was actually Day of the Doctor that was established. Time Crash is resolved because the Tenth Doctor could remember the Fifth Doctor experiencing that.
 
Honestly, I find finales in general to be the season's weakest offerings, regardless the showrunner, as neither Moffat nor Chibnall wrote a finale I cared that much for either. So yes, I have low expectations for the finale, though that's fine. This has been a pretty good season all the same, and a disappointing finale won't change that.
I'm not sure I agree. The Pandorica finale and the Cybermen finale were both pretty amazing frankly - especially the latter being the best Cybermen story in ages.
 
All I am saying is, watch the spoons.
(Ok, it’s not all I am saying in other posts, but here it is)
 
4/10 - and I'm being generous. I'd rather listen to Bang-Bang-a-Boom! than watch this again. Padded out, cliche, and turning the Doctor into a torturer? What a load of rubbish. I'm on the fence about giving it a zero for that. How many times has he faced the end of the universe and not turned into a drug cartel enforcer that hooks up jumper cables someone's nipples? :angryrazz:
The Family of Blood says “hi”.
 
Sweet Jesus, the subtlety is out of the window this season. The Eurovision parody, the genocide, it was a bit uncomfortable

Don’t worry. There was some light torture of a terrorist to help offset that. Just a smidge. And a dash of gay infidelity. You know. For colour.

(Actually I didn’t mind this ep, and rated it quite highly, but it did have some… issues.)
 
My guess is that she is not this season's big bad.
From a narrative point of view, doing the reveal in episode six means episode seven has to have a twist up its sleeve.
In plot, she needs the readings from the vindicator, so maybe what has happened to Earth is as unexpected to her as to the Doctor.
I wouldn't be surprised if they became reluctant allies against a greater threat.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top