• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Hound of the Baskervilles

Sherlock Holmes in New York (with Roger Moore as Holmes and John Huston as Moriarity).

Can't say I cared for that one. Roger Moore is the most bizarrely wrong casting choice for Holmes I've ever seen, and that's including Matt Frewer (who at least vaguely looks the part.

What about Charlton Heston in "The Crucifer in Blood"?

I guess I enjoyed "SH in NY" more than you did. I thought Huston made a great Moriarity and Moore (surprisingly) was fine as Holmes, even if he played Holmes as more of a romantic leading man than is traditional. And, hey, it's Patrick Macnee as Watson. And the gaslight New York setting was fun.

(As I recall, I even bought the novelization!)
 
What about Charlton Heston in "The Crucifer in Blood"?

Never saw that one, but I agree it's a bizarre choice. At least Moore was English.


I guess I enjoyed "SH in NY" more than you did. I thought Huston made a great Moriarity and Moore (surprisingly) was fine as Holmes, even if he played Holmes as more of a romantic leading man than is traditional. And, hey, it's Patrick Macnee as Watson. And the gaslight New York setting was fun.

I don't remember much about it beyond how horrifically wrong Moore was for the part. That kind of ruined the rest of it for me.
 
Of course, given that this is the trekbbs, I'm surprised nobody has yet mentioned the 1970s tv-movie version of "Hounds" in which William Shatner played Stapledon the butterfly collector . . . .
 
Murder by Decree is a favorite of mine and the wife's. Plummer brought a certain humanity to Holmes' usual detachment.
 
Jeremy Brett WAS Sherlock Holmes. I like the Basil Rathbone series, but Bruce's Watson irritates me.
 
Of course, given that this is the trekbbs, I'm surprised nobody has yet mentioned the 1970s tv-movie version of "Hounds" in which William Shatner played Stapledon the butterfly collector . . . .


I remember seeing that one as a kid. Stewart Granger was Holmes and I think Bernard Fox (Dr. Bombay of "Bewitched" was Watson).

Someone above mentioned "A Study in Terror." I saw that one on TV as a kid, as well. I never forgot the one. (I also read the Ellery Queen novelization about the same time.) I recently acquired the DVD from Amazon. I still find it an extremely well done Holmes movie. It's my favorite of the Holmes-Ripper matchups (though Lyndsay Faye's novel Dust and Shadow is very good).
 
Of course, given that this is the trekbbs, I'm surprised nobody has yet mentioned the 1970s tv-movie version of "Hounds" in which William Shatner played Stapledon the butterfly collector . . . .

I didn't know about that, but I have seen Leonard Nimoy play Holmes. It was on a very interesting educational series called The Universe and I which aired on Kentucky Educational Television back in the '70s and '80s. It was an anthology of 15-minute stories dramatizing and presenting scientific concepts in a variety of different styles and genres. The Nimoy-as-Holmes one, "Interior Motive," was toward the more comedic end of the spectrum, with a very dense, doddering, Nigel Bruce-style Watson, and used Holmes's deductive methods to dramatize how scientists study the interior structure of the Earth. Here's a summary, a transcript, and a brief clip.


Unfortunately I can find very little online about The Universe and I. It doesn't even have an IMDb entry. And that's a shame, because some of its episodes were very good and worked as engaging science fiction stories in their own right, and they often had name actors in them. I particularly remember a period piece set in the '50s or '60s with Bill Mumy as a man claiming to be an alien and telling people things about the planets of the Solar System that wouldn't be discovered until the Voyager missions, with nobody believing him. (Come to think of it, I believe Mumy did some of the music for the series too.) There was another period piece set in WWII or the Cold War or something about a man being shown a secret weapons program that involved altering the four fundamental forces, but it turned out he was a known spy and it was a hoax to pass disinformation to the enemy. And there was a particularly compelling and dark one involving the terraforming of Venus, which was more about the ethics and responsibilities of science than about facts and figures, and could've stood up pretty well as a legitimate SF short.
 
Of course, given that this is the trekbbs, I'm surprised nobody has yet mentioned the 1970s tv-movie version of "Hounds" in which William Shatner played Stapledon the butterfly collector . . . .


I remember seeing that one as a kid. Stewart Granger was Holmes and I think Bernard Fox (Dr. Bombay of "Bewitched" was Watson).

Someone above mentioned "A Study in Terror." I saw that one on TV as a kid, as well. I never forgot the one. (I also read the Ellery Queen novelization about the same time.) I recently acquired the DVD from Amazon. I still find it an extremely well done Holmes movie. It's my favorite of the Holmes-Ripper matchups (though Lyndsay Faye's novel Dust and Shadow is very good).


Hmm. I have a copy of "Dust and Shadow" but haven't found time to read it yet. Maybe it should move up on my to-read list.

As I recall, "Study in Terror" starred John Neville as Holmes, long before he played Baron Munchausen in the Terry Gilliam movie or the The Well-Manicured Man on THE X-FILES.
 
I have a copy of "Dust and Shadow" but haven't found time to read it yet. Maybe it should move up on my to-read list.
That's been on my "To Be Read" list for a year now, and I haven't found the time.

Holmes and the Ripper makes for a veritable subgenre of pasticherie.

Edward R. Hanna's The Whitechapel Horrors is an incredibly thorough exploration of Holmes and the Ripper.

Michael Dibdin's The Last Sherlock Holmes Story ties together Holmes, Moriarty, and the Ripper.

Ellery Queen's A Study in Terror, based on the movie, is downright terrible. It's decent as a Holmes story, but it's terrible as a Ripper story, with the victims out of order and a suspect who didn't even exist historically. I would have liked the novel better if it weren't a Ripper novel.
 
I don't think I've seen a really bad version of this story. Because I saw the Peter Cushing/Christopher Lee version first, it is the one that would be my personal favorite.
 
As I recall, "Study in Terror" starred John Neville as Holmes, long before he played Baron Munchausen in the Terry Gilliam movie or the The Well-Manicured Man on THE X-FILES.

Or poker-playing holodeck Isaac Newton on TNG!

Right! I forgot about that.

I remember seeing John Neville on Broadway in 1973 or 1974 as Sherlock Holmes in a Royal Shakespeare Company production of "Sherlock Holmes", originally written by William Gillette and ACD. This is the play in which Nimoy eventually appeared.
 
Three movies with Basil Rathbone as Sherlock. They are

Sherlock Holmes and the Woman in Green
Dress to Kill
Sherlock Holmes and the Secret Weapon.

The best of the Rathbone films is probably The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, with George Zucco as Moriarity, plotting the steal the Crown Jewels!

I would agree with your choice of the best Rathbone film, but I would also add The Scarlet Claw as an excellent film in the series. And one I also love is Terror by Night, Holmes vs Col. Moran on a train from London to Scotland!:techman:

BRG
 
Three movies with Basil Rathbone as Sherlock. They are

Sherlock Holmes and the Woman in Green
Dress to Kill
Sherlock Holmes and the Secret Weapon.

The best of the Rathbone films is probably The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, with George Zucco as Moriarity, plotting the steal the Crown Jewels!

I would agree with your choice of the best Rathbone film, but I would also add The Scarlet Claw as an excellent film in the series. And one I also love is Terror by Night, Holmes vs Col. Moran on a train from London to Scotland!:techman:

BRG

You know, I almost mentioned The Scarlet Claw, which is nicely eerie and atmospheric--like an old Univeral horror flick.
 
I would say the Jeremy Brett version is definitive and closer to the source material than the others. 'Sherlock' has Holmes more involved with the story. The Peter Cushing version is Hammer Horror and the most fun version of the three. So it depends what you are looking for.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top