• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Great Chronological Run-Through

I seem to recall annotations for Constellations being online somewhere and thats probably where I found something.

That would be this:

http://www.allyngibson.net/st-const.html

The conversation between Kirk and Sulu was chronicled in Michael Jan Friedman's Star Trek trilogy, My Brothers Keeper Book Two: Constitution.

It says "Page 38," but in my copy it's on p. 36. That page summarizes the scenes in MBK in which Kirk and Spock decided on promotions and transfers in the wake of "Where No Man," including Sulu's request to transfer to the helm. Offhand, I'm not sure whether there's any conflict with Harbinger, but it's a brief enough passage that it would probably be a minor conflict.
 
Interesting. So the reference to My Brother's Keeper in "the Landing Party" should be treated like references to some of the 80s novels? There may have been events in the novelverse somewhat similar to what is depicted in the novels, but not everything in those novels is in the novelverse.
From what I remember, there are also numerous references made to Friedman's My Brother's Keeper trilogy throughout Mere Anarchy: Things Fall Apart, including Kirk and Gary Mitchell's service history together aboard the USS Republic and Constitution; the specific use of that series' name for the bridge communications officer seen onscreen in "Where No Man Has Gone Before" (Lt. Daniel Alden), etc.
 
If I remember that one correctly, there are references to the trilogy, but not to the events of the trilogy, if that makes sense.
 
If I remember that one correctly, there are references to the trilogy, but not to the events of the trilogy, if that makes sense.

Perfectly. Plot is one thing, background is another. If Kirk and Spock and Vulcan and Qo'noS can exist in multiple realities or continuities, there's no reason a character's first name or a starship or an alien language can't cross continuities.
 
Just to let everyone know, my laptop has committed mauk'to-vor and so I'll be rather scarce for about a week or so. I'll continue as usual when the replacement arrives.

Just in case anyone wonders where I am. :)
 
^Thanks for letting us know. When you don't post for more than 24 hours around here, people start to suspect the worst ;)
 
Bit of a belated followup:

Re the inclusion of the Animated Series: ... put it after "Turnabout Intruder." Despite lasting a nominal two seasons, I tend to think the series lasts for about a year (or even less) after the three years depicted in TOS.

Except that some tales have to take place a bit earlier. The Delta Triangle incident needs to take place before SCE: Where Time Stands Still, which needs to take place before What Judgments Come.

After reviewing the two tales, I'm not entirely convinced that has to be the case. In WJC, the Lovell's secondary hull is destroyed and the primary hull crippled, and it's said that Starfleet considers the ship too far gone to be worth repairing. But almost all of the crew survives. It's possible that they convinced Starfleet to change its mind and repair the ship after all, or that they got a replacement ship whose name they changed to Lovell. There's only one paragraph in WTSS that refers to it as a Daedalus-class ship. So if one were willing to fudge a couple of details, one could assume that WTSS happened well after WJC. Unless there's some other, more major issue that I'm overlooking.
 
Good analysis, Christopher. I suppose I personally prefer just moving The placement of the story and episode, but rebuilding the Lovell is a workable solution to this problem as well. A little fudging is neccesary each way.
 
There's also the fact that in Forgotten History, I said that "The Time Trap" happened "just over a hundred and thirteen years" before 2383 -- with a vague allusion to the events of Where Time Stands Still happening "soon thereafter." I guess I'd fudged the date of WTSS in my own chronology, and I hadn't yet read WJC when I wrote the book. Of course, that's just as minor a detail as the ones that would have to be adjusted in the other stories, so it could go either way depending on individual preference.
 
Say, Christopher, is it your interpretation that in "Tomorrow is Yesterday", the Enterprise time-traveled from 2266 to 1969 or from 2267 to 1969? Memory Alpha, Watching the Clock, and From History's Shadow say 2267, but the relevant section of Forgotten History says December 2266 for Kirk and Spock's briefing upon return to their Earth.
 
Well that's dismaying because I'm currently in the midst of trying to piece together my own chronology based on all the dates given in Vanguard, DTI, and the few other recent books. It was kind of a mess of confusing information already.
 
Yeah, I think this relates to that question I asked you a few days ago, Christopher. Before Vanguard, the 2266/2267 split was usually put around Galileo Seven, but Vanguard put it around Return of the Archons instead. Since TOS episode dating was never especially explicit before Vanguard (it was the Chronology that put the split in the original location, I think, and everything else just got it from there), I think you should just consider Vanguard as the definitive TOS dating and adjust any pre-Vanguard books to match as needed, Ryan.
 
Harbinger

The first actual novel of the Vanguard series (in a normal read-through the very first Vanguard you get), and it’s still a very strong book. It’s a very full novel, introducing a whole host of characters and situations that fit together nicely into a true ensemble. More than this, it’s invaluable not only in its obvious role of establishing the players and arcs of the Vanguard series but as a depiction of the setting that the series rests in and builds upon. It fleshes out the mid-23rd Century in so many valuable ways, really spinning the sense that this is a three-dimensional society, a fully-realized civilization among the stars. There are so many interrelated layers here: Colonization drives and the settlement of the frontier; Federation law and its applications; high-level diplomacy between the Federation and its neighbours; journalism and the press; the underworld both shallow (Quinn) and deep (Ganz); Starfleet’s services, agendas and mission statements both above-board and covert; insight into the Klingon and Tholian governments; not to mention normal human (and non-human) drama. All of this content will be followed up on - these arcs all snake their way through the rest of the series - and it's impressive how much is put forward here without the reader reeling under the weight of it all. Amusingly, it makes me think of Vanguard Station itself - thrown together so rapidly, yet here the completed station is. It's really quite impressive.

Basically, the series launches very successfully, with so much of its content neatly established and set in place for further exploration - while also being rewarding off the bat rather than exposition or rote seed-planting. What more could you ask for? It was great to reread.

As well as everything mentioned above, it also fits in Enterprise crew dynamics that make sense following on from “Where No Man Has Gone Before” but don’t overshadow the rest of it. Kirk and co are here to ease the transition (and they note that they’ll probably be back), but they never intrude in the story, they work as simply another interesting addition to the ensemble.

(I'll note that reading two short Vanguard stories prior to this didn't really affect my reading of Harbinger; this is still obviously the real beginning to the station's saga, those stories were, taking this approach, just interesting prologues. "Almost Tomorrow" sort of takes the more expositional role that if anything helps boost this novel's more thick-of-the-drama introduction).

I suppose I need to mention the loss of the Bombay, since this event will remain a ghostly but ever-present part of the backdrop for the remainder of the series, and it comes to represent the first and most poignant demonstration of what the saga is about. The surest and sharpest example, though not the most spectacular, we might say. For the rest of the series, it quietly encapsulates the central theme, of hidden losses, of people and truths and resolutions sacrificed on the altars of secrecy and security, and the open question whether it was worth it. On top of that, it’s a really effective action sequence. I’m not one to be interested in action scenes on the whole, but I can appreciate a well-written one.

I also love the two conversations between T’Prynn and Spock, and it’s a shame we couldn’t have more of them at a later point. Of course, the purpose here is clearly a "spinoff sendoff", having a familiar Vulcan character introduce us to the new one, but I do so like to see well-written Vulcans playing off of each other. I also liked T'Prynn's reflections on the contradictions upon which Vulcan society and culture are built - which doesn’t illegitimize that culture, either in-universe or in their depiction, but does makes them, well, fascinating.

This is (chronologically of course, not in publication history), where we’re first introduced to the Tholian social structure and their unusual form of communication, their Lattice and the various castemoots and linkages. Tholian POV scenes are always interesting; they give me the impression of light refracting through a crystal, which is surely intentional.

First Appearances of Things That Are Important

Shedai themselves, in the form of the Wanderer.

Cervantes Quinn, possibly (probably?) the true protagonist of the series, unless that's Pennington (also a very real possibility).

Planets of note mentioned for the first term: Barolia (Quinn mentions he's been there), Cait (traffic leaves here bound for Vanguard, since Cait is either very near to the Reach or inside its boundaries; Caitian Starfleet officers will show up in the next few books), Kessik IV (just colonized), Theta 116. The Kalandra Sector is mentioned, having been passed over for a colonization drive in favour of the much more distant Taurus Reach. Starfleet will get to poking around that way further down the line (first contact with Bajorans and the first name-dropping reference to Tzenkethi aren’t that far off).

Continuity

Among the in-jokes: “It’s Green”. Although we don't know that's an in-joke yet.

A Bolian bartender shows up.

Manón's species, the Silgov, are explicitly located a long way distant from the Taurus Reach (we'll later know that they’re from somewhere beyond the Typhon Expanse, right on the other side of explored space). We’ll see them again more than a century from now, trying to steal a box.

Starfleet has new uniforms, in bright primary colours. My eyes will feast upon these for the foreseeable future. I do wonder, though, what Starfleet's reasoning was. A more cheery appearance after all that somber getup they had before? "We're eager, helpful space do-anything-officers, not drab plumbers going through the motions". A more visible profile for the Starfleet? A happy Ithenite fashionista who couldn't get the fezzes but thought this was the next best thing? Either that or the message is "Don't eat us, we may be poisonous"; useful in a landing party out on the frontier.

There's a fair amount of humour regarding the "end of an era" as the galaxy faces the reality of an Enterprise without Pike, as commented on by both Starfleet and Klingon observers. As well as being amusing, it also contributes nicely to that sense of the 23rd century as a lived-in place. Kirk isn’t a legend yet (and won’t be until V’Ger), Pike is the legend.

There are at least two female Klingons on the High Council (one, notably, due to Imperial Intelligence connections, which may not be coincidental). Some later sources see Klingons claiming that Azetbur was the only female to hold a high political office, and not merely the only female chancellor, but since the Klingons explicitly have a habit of rewriting their history this isn’t a problem.

There’s a dentist’s office on Vanguard, and the dentist is an Andorian in glasses. First appearance of an Andorian dentist wearing glasses.

Next Time: Summon the Thunder. The Romulans reenter the meta-story, and the Wanderer throws the first in a series of escalating tantrums.
 
Harbinger was such a great book! I remember grinning so much during it, including at all the fashion and design touches. I really liked, in re-reading it a while back, how charismatic and yet unlikable many characters were. Including Gorkon and the Enterprise were great ideas, but most brilliant was how multi-special and varied the station's population and the members of Starfleet felt. Just great.

It's harder now to think of it as an isolated book. Certain future events, like Quinn's soldiering days, do feel non-visionable at this point in the series, but not impossible. I do wish certain plots, such as Raina's detective investigation of Ganz and indeed Diego, hadn't gone away. That was a nice build up to ... a not super interesting trial.
 
Summon the Thunder

The biblical quote that summarises Summon the Thunder - "Watch ye therefore: for ye know not when the master of the house cometh" - is indeed illustrative not only of the novel but of the role this instalment plays in the series. More than this; when viewed as a commentary on the path of that series, it takes on a more subtle nature as a warning. The storm clouds are gathering in more ways than one, and there's an immediate payoff in the novel to one form of threat while the more subtle danger remains, for now, foreshadowed.

If the first Vanguard novel was the impressively multi-faceted establishing act, crafting a complex picture of a active frontier, then the second is the introduction to the Shedai and the threat they pose to it; that is to say, the more direct antagonistic force of the series, and the obvious source of tension. It also drapes the setting in an ominous veil of uncertainty, which is important because it's the third novel that will introduce our primary threat - the true thematic source of tension, which is the wavering ideals and deteriorating self-respect that threaten when the stakes get too high; the awesome power and responsibility that acquisition of Shedai technology will entail, and the compromises - (in both senses of the word, because there's two disparate ethical slants to what is actually only the one definition) - that are made in the name of securing it.

So, this book establishes not only the Shedai as a potent force, but a general tone of dark anticipation. The Federation, Tholians, Klingons and now the Romulans are all dancing around each other, but forces far more primal and impressive can swat them all aside in a moment. We're shown the power of even a single Shedai elite, and are introduced also to the concept of Telinaruul, a label applied to disruptive alien agitators, connoting the essentially synonymous concepts of existence outside Shedai hegemony and a status as base criminals without law. While the Shedai are an ominous and immediate example of the dangers awoken by those meddling around in the Taurus Reach, we'll see soon enough that they're more than simply a threat on the straightforwardly antagonistic level (and what a threat!), but that they thematically embody the real threat of the series. After all, the goal of the Federation Starfleet, for whatever defensible reason(s), is to become in turn the "masters" of this house. The Shedai are the future as well as the past.

This is the first work, I think, to really give us a look at Klingon colonial authority, and how jeghpu'wI' are incorporated into the empire. Palgrenax might not be entirely representative, in that it has no existing technological infrastructure to be co-opted, but it's certainly a useful illustration of how Klingon occupation often works. That's something it's important to have established, perhaps, if we're to be as invested as we should be in later works that deal with Klingon expansionism and annexation of minor systems. We'll soon be moving into a period of looming war, with border systems eyed hungrily for their strategic value. Knowing "first hand" how a population fares under Klingon military occupation is pretty useful knowledge to have going forward. The depiction here is successful, I think, at expressing the brutality and dysfunction of it while also making the occupation sensible enough in light of Klingon philosophies and worldviews (to whatever degree something emerging from those can be considered "sensible"). As self-serving and nebulous as the supposedly iron-clad Klingon warrior codes are (as Jetanien memorably notes in sarcastic fashion at one point), the treatment of the Palgrenai does ring true from a viewpoint defined in those perceptual standards, and the novel shows this quite effectively. As I've noted before, it's difficult to win with Klingons.

Of course, in this case the Palgrenai are minnows taken by tuna which then disappear themselves down the maw of an orca whale, because the Klingons are in turn entirely crushed by a superior power. By another measure, then, the Klingons miscalculated, thinking themselves the dominant power on Palgrenax, when in fact this space is not, by right of force, theirs, any more than it is the Palgrenai's. It's the Shedai's. These mortals, Palgrenai and Klingon both, have paid the price for daring to get underfoot and becoming irritants to the masters of the house.

When we get to the third book in the Vanguard series, and it becomes clear what the Federation has awoken out here - and this time I don't mean the Shedai - the destruction wrought by the Wanderer in defence of her people's claim should be resonating in a reader's mind. That, of course, is one possible outcome, one ultimate destination, of a mindset that covets control and security, and turns the power of incredible creativity and a claim to civilized virtue to incredible destruction and malice.

There are other things to like here. In terms of the series and its emerging conventions, this one begins the trend of odd relationships and mismatched friendships, kicking off with Pennington and Quinn, who have formed an association of sorts having essentially gravitated together due to being mutual "losers", down-on-their-luck. There's also a pleasing sense of scope to the backdrop, which just emphasises the power and threat of the Shedai, that their shadow should fall over it all. We have references to Federation investment in the region that moves beyond the settlements and Starfleet/civilian legal disputes already established; mention, for instance, of an arbitration over a planet claimed equally by Tellar and Rigel, demonstrating that the unseen Federation core worlds are indeed invested in what's taking place out here. (As an aside, I liked the description in the same scene of a barfight between two Denobulans and the uncertainty as to whether it was assault or domestic battery. Federation law must be a chore at times).

Continuity

The Romulans are back. They've perfected cloaking technology at long last and are beginning to probe covertly far beyond their borders. Vrax is still alive, and has actually winded up as Praetor. Evidently, he got the last laugh.

The colony on Ingraham B has gone dark. We'll find out what's happening in that part of space soon enough (it involves killer pancakes).

This is the first appearance of a Zakdorn. They're known to Quinn, and with a reputation at that, so apparently they're active enough in the interstellar community. The Taurus Reach is a long way from Zakdorn, so at least some of them are far-travelled. Qualor II has already been mentioned - the Lovell, which features again in this story, was re-commissioned from the surplus depot there - although we don't know who's running the depot at this point in time. It might be that the Zakdorn move in and take over existing Federation facilities whenever they wind up joining. Zakdorn will basically become the Federation's Vorta - bureaucrats, administrators, armchair tactical commanders - but in hilarious contrast will be prissy and difficult rather than smoothly unctuous.

Next Time: Reap the Whirlwind
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top