• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Great Chronological Run-Through

What I have in my Rise of the Federation notes as a possible meaning for "High Commissioner" is that by the TOS era, the UFP has enough member worlds to have more than one commissioner for each portfolio, and the senior one in a given department is the High Commissioner. I'm not sure that makes sense, though, especially given the established existence of cabinet secretaries in that era.

To be fair, I'm not sure what the earliest reference to Federation cabinet secretaries would be. Are there references to cabinet secretaries in Kenneth Wescott's administration in the Errand of Fury books?

In the British Empire, a High Commissioner was essentially the governor of a protectorate, or an agent of indirect rule. It's been used in other countries as a term for a colonial governor.

Hm. That might dovetail nicely with the idea I batted about where a commissioner is the government's "field commander" in a less built-up region of space.

In the modern Commonwealth, though, it's essentially the ambassador between one member nation and another (although the Federation actually uses the ambassador title for that role).

Well, the idea with the Commonwealth of Nations is that their membership in the Commonwealth and their historical ties as former colonies of the British Empire means that these states, while fully sovereign, are not truly foreign to one-another, the way that they are to states outside the Commonwealth. The practice was set by those states for whom the British Monarch also reigns as local monarch, called the Commonwealth realms. (There is a legally separate monarchy for each Commonwealth realm that the Monarch holds separately and simultaneously -- so Her Majesty is simultaneously Queen of the United Kingdom, Queen of Canada, Queen of New Zealand, Queen of The Commonwealth of the Bahamas, etc.) Since they share the same head of state, they cannot exchange ambassadors, because ambassadors in legal theory represent one head of state to another. Thus, the evolution of the term "High Commissioner" (whose diplomatic missions are called High Commissions rather than Embassies), who represents one head of government (Prime Minister) to the other instead of one head of state to the other. This practice is carried over by those members of the Commonwealth who are either republics or who have monarchies not inhabited by the House of Windsor, but its legal justification comes from the Commonwealth realms.

I suppose in theory, if one were writing Star Trek fresh and anew, it would make sense for Federation Member States to exchange High Commissioners with one-another rather than ambassadors, since in theory they're all part of the same sovereign state in the UFP and thus all share the same head of state in the UFP President. But that ship has sailed.

Ferris's title, however, was "Galactic High Commissioner," which adds another layer of uncertainty. Was he meant to be the colonial governor of the whole galaxy? Or an ambassador to it?

I'm inclined to disregard the "Galactic" part, or perhaps to speculate that it's a bit of informal slang on the part of the people who used it, the equivalent of calling the head of the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy the "drug czar."
 
As ever, I think we might explain any discrepancies between correct political terminology and the state of things in the Trek 'verse as a consequence of non-Human influence. We might even say that it works to make the Federation more believable as a union of four multi-planetary cultures if its political structure is out of synch with the systems as they exist in reality. The Federation came together quite quickly in the aftermath of the Romulan War, and since the Coalition was something quite different it can't have laid that much in the way of groundwork, surely? Perhaps the system they threw together shows its seams a bit, particularly in terms of the terminology they settled on, since the four races had overlapping but non-identical roles that loosely translate as equivalents but never quite fit one another's legal definitions. An "ambassador" in Federation terms is presumably some unholy amalgamation or compromise born from the same general concept that developed along different lines for Humans, Vulcans, Andorians, and Tellarites. Some linguistic awkwardness seems inevitable to me, and I wonder if the official definitions had to be stretched a bit, or in some cases an awful lot.

On other topics, this talk of the Commonwealth has left me wondering what the situation is on Arken. Is Arken's head of state still the Empty Throne of the Andorian Empire, do you think? In Rise of the Federation, while newly independent and explicitly said to be cautious about jeopardizing their status as such, they're implicitly represented within the Andorian Guard branch of Starfleet and, if my speculation is on-point, are still possibly using official Imperial Names.
 
Last edited:
Arken II is no longer under Andorian rule, but the separation was amiable, so they're still allies. I'm assuming that there's still an Andorian shipbuilding facility on Arken II, and that the Arkenites get to keep using it for their own purposes now, but they're still building Andorian-design ships because that's what they're set up for, and because the relationship is still close. Kinaph operates under the AG branch because the Arkenites don't have that much of a space administration of their own established, and they're still very new to the Federation.

As for the names, I'm not sure about that.
 
"Court Martial"

This one’s different in tone to most of the episodes so far, and I quite like it. I’m not sure how realistic or convincing the legal scenes are, but it doesn’t really matter because there’s more going on here than just a courtroom drama. This is about the image and the reputation of a certain key figure; the starship captain. We’ve already seen evidence in other works of the legendary esteem in which the role is held in this era; the responsibilities and burdens that give the position almost a mythic status, and here it’s made quite evident that Starfleet itself buys into this as much as anyone. Kirk is described as “not an ordinary human”, but “a starship captain”. Shaw further all but explicitly states that Starfleet Command will come down hard on him precisely in order to retain the image of extraordinariness that the role has come to be equated with. There has never been a starship captain brought to trial, Stone claims. Even Finney’s acrimony is due to his being denied the opportunity to some day advance to that legendary position, even as he reveals his incompatibility with it. Okay, by this point -- yes, even this early point -- madness and excess is rather underwhelming in a Trek character, but the overall point of the episode, the power that underlies it all - that is, the meaning of “starship captain” to the 23rd Century - is essential to understanding the pressure that Kirk and other characters are always working under in these stories. So this is a useful episode, I think.

Continuity

I wonder what the Vulcanian Expedition was. Vulcan launching a colonization initiative, perhaps? That would require Starfleet support. Whatever the expedition involved, it happened after Kirk's graduation in 2254 (and surely should be mentioned in any later discussion involving Vulcan participation in, or partnership with, Starfleet). Another interesting piece of relatively recent Starfleet history would be the initiative that earned Kirk the Palm Leaf of Axanar Peace Mission commendation. Something very interesting seems to have happened at Axanar over the last few decades; an historic battle with serious ramifications for the Federation and Starfleet, not least of all how they perceive and present themselves, followed some years later by a peace mission. Add to this the implication in Inception that Axanar has recently joined the Federation as a member world, and there’s an interesting untold story here.

Kirk refers to the “United Starship Republic”; I still privately insist that this is shorthand for “United Starfleet (Star)Ship”, which is the only thing that makes sense to me.

This episode introduces a hefty list of Starfleet awards, medals, and commendations that a number of characters will later earn over the course of the franchise. I won't include the Palm Leaf of Axanar Peace Mission, since that's clearly a one-off:

Grankite Order of Tactics (may we assume that Grankite was a person? Sounds Tellarite, maybe?)
Karagite Order of Heroism (same, I guess. I propose "The Adventures of Grankite and Karagite" as an ongoing action series.)
Starfleet Award of Valor (not valour)
Starfleet Citation for Conspicuous Gallantry
Starfleet Legion of Honor (not honour)
Starfleet Medal of Honor
Starfleet Silver Palm
Starfleet Surgeons Decoration
Vulcanian Scientific Legion of Honor
(more evidence for Vulcan participation in, or cooperative endeavours with, Starfleet).

First Appearances of Things That Are Important

Starbase 11, I believe, in orbit of the planet Yko.

Samuel Cogley, who will show up again in The Case of the Colonist’s Corpse.

Next Time: And... back to Starbase 11. But it's the Star Trek clip show that's actually very good, so I'm not complaining.
 
Last edited:
^Interesting that you've this episode first, as I started a thread about Commodores Mendez and Stone in the TOS sub-forum a few days ago in which several posters have argued that "The Menagerie" actually happened before "Court Martial." In any case, it will be interesting to hear your take on why Starbase 11 suddenly has a new commanding officer--one who's much more friendly with Kirk and well-liked by fans.

--Sran
 
^Interesting that you've this episode first, as I started a thread about Commodores Mendez and Stone in the TOS sub-forum a few days ago in which several posters have argued that "The Menagerie" actually happened before "Court Martial." In any case, it will be interesting to hear your take on why Starbase 11 suddenly has a new commanding officer--one who's much more friendly with Kirk and well-liked by fans.

--Sran

I do recall a similar discussion in this sub-forum (you may have been heavily involved in that one too). Being a little too lazy, I decided I would simply go with the order I already had down and then discuss any problems or complications that arise from that decision in my post for "The Menagerie".

For what it's worth, I liked Stone. It's nice to have a command officer who isn't a friend to the captain yet isn't shifty or unprofessional either. He's doing his job, we can't hold it against him. Between Stone and Shaw I actually think Starfleet Command came out of this one looking rather respectable.

(Okay, obvious conflict of interest with Shaw, admittedly, but she herself was fine so it's more the fact that she was allowed and not her actual behaviour).
 
I’m not sure how realistic or convicning the legal scenes are...

I think they're about as bad as courtroom procedures in TV usually are. For one thing, in real life, according to the US Manual for Courts Martial (which I studied for The Buried Age, and which Dayton Ward directed me to), it's a conflict of interest for the officer who brings the indictment to sit on the court-martial panel. So Stone shouldn't have been one of the judges. (I established in TBA that there hadn't been such a rule in the 2260s but that one was in place by the Stargazer court-martial.) And there are tons of problems with Cogley's antics and the whole "reconvene on the Enterprise" thing.


Kirk refers to the “United Starship Republic”; I still privately insist that this is shorthand for “United Starfleet (Star)Ship”, which is the only thing that makes sense to me.
I see it as "United [Federation of Planets] Star Ship." Keep in mind that Kirk says "United Space Ship" nearly as often. The "U" in "USS" is short for "UFP," and people saying it out loud presumably elide the full name to "United" in the analogous way.


This episode introduces a hefty list of Starfleet awards, medals, and commendations that a number of characters will later earn over the course of the franchise. I won't include the Palm Leaf of Axanar Peace Mission, since that's clearly a one-off:

Grankite Order of Tactics (may we assume that Grankite was a person? Sounds Tellarite, maybe?)
Karagite Order of Heroism (same, I guess. I propose "The Adventures of Grankite and Karagite" as an ongoing action series.)

The "-ite" suffix suggests a nationality, allegiance, or species -- cf. Israelite, Trotskyite, or Tellarite, respectively. (Or else a mineral, like dolomite, but that seems unlikely.) The novel Preserver suggested that the Order of Tactics was awarded by a group or civilization called the Grankite Totality, while the FASA role-playing game said that the similar Grankite Order of Honor was named for of a Tellarite named Grankess. FASA also explains the Karagite Order as being named in honor of the successful defense of the planet Karag.


Starbase 11, I believe, in orbit of the planet Yko.

In orbit? No, it's on the surface of the planet that the Decipher RPG called Yko, according to Memory Beta. There were no orbital starbases in TOS, only planet-surface ones.
 
I see it as "United [Federation of Planets] Star Ship." Keep in mind that Kirk says "United Space Ship" nearly as often. The "U" in "USS" is short for "UFP," and people saying it out loud presumably elide the full name to "United" in the analogous way.

Hmm, yes, that would make sense. I still think United Starfleet Ship (as in, "ship of the United Starfleet" or, to appropriate your example, "ship of the United [Federation of Planets] Starfleet) makes more sense for USS, but the evidence won't seem to allow it.

The novel Preserver suggested that the Order of Tactics was awarded by a group or civilization called the Grankite Totality, while the FASA role-playing game said that the similar Grankite Order of Honor was named for of a Tellarite named Grankess. FASA also explains the Karagite Order as being named in honor of the successful defense of the planet Karag.

The novel 'verse, then, is free to interpret these however it may wish. I wonder if Grankess at least will be lifted/incorporated.

Starbase 11, I believe, in orbit of the planet Yko.
In orbit? No, it's on the surface of the planet that the Decipher RPG called Yko, according to Memory Beta. There were no orbital starbases in TOS, only planet-surface ones.

Indeed! I don't know why I wrote otherwise. It's late here, that's my excuse...
 
Well, the fact that the Enterprise is being repaired at Starbase 11 would seem to point at orbital facilities, even if we never see them.

(It was me who argued for the reversed "Court Martial"/"The Menagerie" placement, in both this thread and Sran's. We all have our hobby horses, and this is mine! Wait until I advocate for switching "Duet" and "In the Hands of the Prophets"!)
 
Actually, error. I can't do Menagerie yet because I still have a Pike story set shortly before his accident to cover. I don't know how I missed that. So, slight revision is in order. We'll bump Menagerie a few places down the line. It gives Stone more time to fall out of a window or retire to Risa or whatever.
 
So, next up then we'll have "Shore Leave" (may God help us) and then I'll take a look at Where Sea Meets Sky (which requires a Pike).
 
"Shore Leave"

9ugz1gZ.png


The Enterprise has had a busy three months and is evidently on an exploration assignment to the Omicron Delta region. Meanwhile (I'll claim for the purpose of my project here), Pike is telling tall tales in a bar (we'll get to that next with Where Sea Meets Sky - an actual novel again, I'm pleased to say) and Commodore Stone is presumably facing some change in career circumstance.

And now, after an interesting teaser regarding the effect of long-term space travel on this crew of hard-working professionals...

Ah. It's one of those episodes.

I suppose, in a season that has explored so many facets and capacities of the psyche, it makes sense enough that "lazy, quasi-imaginative indulgence" should take its place in the lineup, but I can't quite conceive of why it would be considered a good idea. "Shore Leave" is an ode to the idle, underwhelming, pointless daydream, and I guess it does the job? In that it's pointless, dull and completely forgettable. Everyone is addled in the brain, which I assume is excusable story-wise in that the planet is working its magic and they're all operating in the flighty state of mind that the episode has chosen to explore. I have to think that because otherwise the characters become impossible to respect.

Even the climax is simply Kirk having a dull fight with a giggling conjured avatar of someone for whom he holds a rather petty resentment, in an act of pointless, idle indulgence. And we have to keep in mind it's intended to be exactly that. It's almost the equivalent of writing a poem or a novel with the intent that it be bad and forgettable. There can't be any interest or catharsis here. If the point is supposed to be made that the human mind requires this sort of outlet, then that's fine, but it's akin to writing an episode about Kirk snoring away in bed because the human body needs sleep. It's not interesting, even if Spock walks in at the end and raises a brow at the illogical human need for sleep and everyone laughs.

The only world-building we can take from this (other than that there are chorus lines on Rigel II, I suppose :shrug:) involves the unknown caretaker and the implications that it represents the remnant of an ancient people, but there isn't much to say. Part of me quite likes the idea of a galaxy filled with inexplicable artefacts and tailored environments left by any number of departed civilizations that may have achieved wonders (and the eccentric outlooks that probably correlate with that degree of creativity). We can do better than this, though, and there isn't anything interesting to learn or even conjecture about the galaxy based on what we see here. I don't even care who the creators were (Magratheans, I assume). We'll revisit in the Animated Series, and I don't think we learn anything new in that instalment.

This is the most pointless episode thus far, probably even more so than "Trip and the Kriosian Princess". There are a few interesting musings on the burden of starship life, especially on the commander, and a nice sense of the crew's friendship, but nothing that can save this one.
 
Last edited:
"Shore Leave" is a pretty fun episode, certainly notable as the Trek debut of composer Gerald Fried. But it is self-indulgent. It's very typical of '60s TV that Kirk is having fun beating up an avatar of his Academy bully just minutes after McCoy has apparently died.
 
"Shore Leave" is a pretty fun episode, certainly notable as the Trek debut of composer Gerald Fried.

I don't have the ear for music, I'm afraid. Its also the case that the various background and production details tend not to interest me, which I happily admit removes a robust layer of potential appreciation from a given episode. They'd be richer and more intriguing if such things did attract my notice, for certain, but I've never been as interested in the more expansive view of the franchise and its installments.

It's very typical of '60s TV that Kirk is having fun beating up an avatar of his Academy bully just minutes after McCoy has apparently died.

Given how easily everyone succumbed to mindless participation in the various scenarios, and their apparent inability to work out that their own thoughts and desires were driving it until somewhere near the end, I have to assume that the planet was affecting their minds throughout, that it induces a certain light-headedness conductive to relaxation and idle indulgence. Aggressive marketing, I assume. Like setting up a burger bar and then psychically projecting a hunger for burgers into the brain of anyone who enters, just to make sure they get the most out of the establishment, you understand.
 
Continuity and another untold tale there: Ruth, the greatest lost love of Kirk's life. Their romance having happened fifteen years prior puts her smack in the middle of Kirk's Academy years, which almost certainly makes her the 'little blond lab technician' Gary Mitchell hooked Kirk (in his decidedly non-studly 'stack of books with legs' period) up with* - and that Kirk almost walked down the aisle with (choosing her over a Starfleet career?). That she appears instead of Carol Marcus, Janet Wallace or Areel Shaw lends considerable weight to how much this girl meant to Kirk.

* And not Carol Marcus, though Peter David's confusion there is understandable.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top