The Borg should have never had a Borg Queen or any "Centralized" figure to speak for them other than Locutus in my opinion.
With nano technology, they should be able to look any way they choose.
The Borg should have never had a Borg Queen or any "Centralized" figure to speak for them other than Locutus in my opinion.
I have seen suggestions that the Dominion may be at a level (if just barely) to interest the Borg. Niche technology such as cloning. Note-the Federation, Romulans, etc. don't have even that. Even during First Contact they are still too primitive to offer anything of interest.The Borg would steamroll the Dominion.
I have seen suggestions that the Dominion may be at a level (if just barely) to interest the Borg. Niche technology such as cloning. Note-the Federation, Romulans, etc. don't have even that. Even during First Contact they are still too primitive to offer anything of interest.
Seriously.
The very first Borg story sets up a distributed and redundant nature, for which TBOBW expands upon. This only gets wasted later on for the sake of cheap drama and cheap solutions, which are also antithetical because what made the Borg so good was the ingenuity in their setup and how the crew had to defeat them based on the Borg's distributed and redundant approaches. The moment the plots turned the Borg into neutered puppies with "take out this one thing" or "just steal this one transwarp coil", it was frivolity - even if played straight (which is better than using self-aware camp).
"Q WHO" has Q flinging out the ship, where the Borg take a chunk out of them - a smaller scale of what they did at the Neutral Zone (dialogue confirmed the type of scooping was the same). By the next story, it is because of "Q WHO" that the Borg now want to expand, not just with technologies but via greater embracing and extending biological beings. Any old neutral zone station wasn't enough, it took the Enterprise and Jean-Luc to tangibly realize the potential for so much more.
When TBOBW (the last Borg story to have such a bulletproof script accorded them) had humanity succeeding somehow by the seashore, there's nary a peep out of them until "I, Borg" - the "both good and bad but is still the jump sharking episode" that I've not seen in years, but from recollection: It had the Borg just being there minding their own business via a crash, but is also an episode that went out of its way to change Enterprise characters for the sake of plot (antithetical) and from what I recall some treknobabble wasn't lining up logically either. Beverly was a real whiner with cognitive dissonance of what the Borg's actions were about as well, and they weren't a race but an alagmation of numerous species where many assimilated beings were doing things against their will (as Locutus could attest to). But instead of Picard getting to nag the Borg to death with a glorified Escher picture, they just give back an accidentally deprogrammed Hugh, which does something worse than death to the Collective (or this part of the Collective)...
...which means the Borg now all have individual names and go around killing everyone for a cheap thrill, complete with gorgeous art deco ship design showing creativity (making these psychos as creative as they are vicious, a genuinely interesting combination...) Which means we finally get a second story in which the Borg come across to be a genuinely terrifying menace, even if not taken to its fullest potential. (Although, even if imperfect, "I Borg" gives us a needed respite so that the big episodes still feel legitimate and "Descent" needed the events of 'I, Borg" to even occur...). Unfortunately, and unlike Wesley Crusher's warp bubble wrap trap, the universe shrinks by 99% this time because Lore shows up to neuter and drown the story with needless superficial fanwank. A shame "Descent" lost focus in pt 2 as Lore wasn't needed and Lore drags it down..
But after that, there's nothing, again, until the 1996 movie that just doesn't begin to hold up whatsoever (IMHO), and the Queen is the least of the movie's problems in terms of grounding and consistency (or sheer lack thereof). Sheesh, instead of Queen pointing out that humanity's past involvements are why the Borg decided to create their own locus, they do cheap retconning and lame dialog about "oh-so-three-dimensional terms", which is so beyond corny that even every single season 1 story just blushed in embarrassment over. Why didn't she sixty-dimensional out of the ship when it became obvious she was being defeated, but before I really dive down that long-eared rabbit hole...
So 1996 neuters the Collective, which is why 1997's "Scorpion" of VOY fame promptly pretends none of anything after TBOBW existed and they're a proper Collective again, but with a bigger big bad in liquid space dimension thingy that seemed a little cheesy and there's no problem in a ship designed for our universe to travel through fluidic faff, but at least the Borg seemed compelling again. Have no worries, a year or so later we get "Dark Frontier" where they have just one transwarp coil, not one of a bunch in redundant parallel or anything, on top of numerous other easy ways to dispatch the cyborgs. "Dark Frontier" was still decent, the true last gasp of glory, even if other continuity tweaks are introduced, including introducing another Queen. Must be a lot of them about. Gimmicks became so dumb that, when using future blu-ray player lasers attached to Janeway, Torres and Tuvok to not just one-up TBOBW but to triple-up, it was just sleeping powder. And that's not even the worst, that honor goes to "Unimatrix Zero".
If it wasn't for focusing on Seven re-learning humanity and double-act with Janeway (the latest iteration of the Data/Picard double-act but remains as innovative and fresh), the Borg introduction into VOY would have been a complete waste. At least "Scorpion" kept the Borg true to what they were, no matter how briefly.
Any idea of negotiating with the Borg is what lost me. The very point of the Borg was that you cannot make deals with them, that they are above that entirely. The Borg are a force of nature, a collective - they have no leader centralized leader. The idea of a "Queen" is even worse to me, it cheapens the whole viewing experience when it comes to the Borg.
It darkly amuses me to think that, if they wanted to, the Borg could launch a telepathic assault upon a Betazoid so overwhelming that being assimilated would come as a relief.Do you think telepaths like Betazoids have a worse or better experience in being joined to the Borg Collective?
I always wondered about an episode with a telepathic hive mind that had a portion of thier population that wasn't telepathic... B5 did a damn fine job of it...Do you think telepaths like Betazoids have a worse or better experience in being joined to the Borg Collective?
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.