• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The best main character in Voyager.

The Doctor is my favourite - he just grows so much from the grouchy program we knew from Caretaker. :D

I also like Seven of Nine - her presence really gave the show a lift in season four. I think overall she swallowed too much of the screentime, and by the end she was repeating lessons of humanity that she had already supposedly learnt.

The Doctor
Seven
B'Elanna
Janeway
Tuvok
Tom
Kes
Chakotay
Neelix
Harry
 
The Doctor is interesting because he didn't really seek to evolve, it's just happened by accident. It poses a lot of philosophical questions such as what makes us . .. us.

1. The Doc
2. B'Elanna
3. Janeway
4. Paris
5. Neelix
6. Kim
7. Seven
8. Chakotay

The Doc's a no-brainer. B'Elanna's alright. Janeway was the worst captain ever in the first two seasons, really overplaying the grim authority aspect imo, but she adopted a more natural style after that.
Neelix could at least act pretty well. Kim's saving grace is his friendship with Paris which was very convincing. Sort of like Bashir/O'Brien. Also he was cool in "Timelines". Seven was in too many episodes, plus her outfit is embarassing.

Chakotay's monotone annoyed me so he's last.
 
Jeez I can't comprehend some people not including Kes in their list tbh. I guess they hare her character so much, they'd just like to pretend she doesn't exist or something. I mean 70 episodes is not to be sniffed at o.O
 
I think she gets hated on by the raging Seven of Nine fans out of some superiority trip.

Though to be honest, Fury sent her out in a bad light even for me.
 
I think she gets hated on by the raging Seven of Nine fans out of some superiority trip.

Though to be honest, Fury sent her out in a bad light even for me.

At least it was like that shortly after "the changes in season 4". I remember when I started to write on some forums back then, stating my opinion that Kes should be brought back or never should have been thrown out in the first place. I was immediately attacked by some not so nice Seven fans who showed their malice over it. And me, being me started to pay back with the same not so nice behavior which triggered a chain of events which I'm not so proud over now.

As for "Fury", that episode was a direct insult to the fans of Kes. In fact, the pathetic creature we saw in that episode had no resemblance at all to the real Kes.
 
Neelix, Tom Paris and Barklay, but none more than Neelix.

Having just finished the series, and yes, somewhat disspointed with the final episode, none the less, it remains my favorite of all five incarnations. It sure beats the finale of TOS, ha ha, or Leave It To Beaver--have you seen that? Ward and June look through a scrapbook and then Kennedy is shot.

Neelix and Barclay are the theme of the whole series; discomfort, fish out of water and overcoming difficult circumstances. Tom Paris, looks the most like Captain Kirk, but always reminds us he is not, a Captain Proton fixed, sometime troublemaker, he learns to become a man and a father, an excon, falling short of parental expectations. He is a more realistic persona.

Things didin't always work out on this series the way we might have hoped or imagined, but I think that was part of the point of it. Neelix and Barklay represented this theme along with the beautiful Seven. What a tragic figure (hinted at more with the 23 years timeline Grandma Janeway erased) and genuine character she was. My first impression of her was she was strictly about sex appeal, but that would be a view held by casual, cursory glances at the show. Seven shared in the theme of a fish out of water along with Barkley and Neelix. The point of Seven was for all of us to see past her outer person and into her heart, again and again that theme is repeated, probably to little avail, but they tried. She is a real human being, not a cyborg or a magazine image. Can't she understand how much I care? Okay, sorry. Easy boy.

The "real" final episode of Voyager, for me, an episode with a more cozy, happy ending, was a few episodes back from Endgame where Neelix saves a colony of Talazians. That was more satisfying. I appreciate the writers efforts with Endgame, it was fine, and twisted things around, as most Voyager episodes did, right from the start. But, would it be that hard, to CG in a special edition ending, where we get a ticker tape parade? I don't think so.

To me, Neelix, is what Voyager was all about. The dweeby fans maybe?, the outsiders, the non-starfleet folks, the Barklays of the world, the unsong heroes, who never quite fit in. Hip folks like Janeway and Chokotay became the heralds of a misfit crew's journey, their story was almost secondary. But, in their own way, they were outsiders too.
 
Last edited:
Neelix, Tom Paris and Barklay, but none more than Neelix.

Having just finished the series, and yes, somewhat disspointed with the final episode, none the less, it remains my favorite of all five incarnations. It sure beats the finale of TOS, ha ha, or Leave It To Beaver--have you seen that? Ward and June look through a scrapbook and then Kennedy is shot.

Neelix and Barclay are the theme of the whole series; discomfort, fish out of water and overcoming difficult circumstances. Tom Paris, looks the most like Captain Kirk, but always reminds us he is not, a Captain Proton fixed, sometime troublemaker, he learns to become a man and a father, an excon, falling short of parental expectations. He is a more realistic persona.

Things didin't always work out on this series the way we might have hoped or imagined, but I think that was part of the point of it. Neelix and Barklay represented this theme along with the beautiful Seven. What a tragic figure (hinted at more with the 23 years timeline Grandma Janeway erased) and genuine character she was. My first impression of her was she was strictly about sex appeal, but that would be a view held by casual, cursory glances at the show. Seven shared in the theme of a fish out of water along with Barkley and Neelix. The point of Seven was for all of us to see past her outer person and into her heart, again and again that theme is repeated, probably to little avail, but they tried. She is a real human being, not a cyborg or a magazine image. Can't she understand how much I care? Okay, sorry. Easy boy.

The "real" final episode of Voyager, for me, an episode with a more cozy, happy ending, was a few episodes back from Endgame where Neelix saves a colony of Talazians. That was more satisfying. I appreciate the writers efforts with Endgame, it was fine, and twisted things around, as most Voyager episodes did, right from the start. But, would it be that hard, to CG in a special edition ending, where we get a ticker tape parade? I don't think so.

To me, Neelix, is what Voyager was all about. The dweeby fans maybe?, the outsiders, the non-starfleet folks, the Barklays of the world, the unsong heroes, who never quite fit in. Hip folks like Janeway and Chokotay became the heralds of a misfit crew's journey, their story was almost secondary. But, in their own way, they were outsiders too.

Well said.

Though, as regards Voyager's "ticker-tape" parade, we sort of had that at the start of 'Endgame'. The celebrations of ... what was it? tenth? .... anniversary of Voyager's return to Earth, and it was obviously a big deal with the fireworks display and all.
 
For me, I can't just pick the 'best' character, but I'm going for most improved or most growth character(s)

In that way I think the Doctor had grown so much and became more than just his programing. Next in the growth would be Tom. He grew from being kind of self centered to really caring about the rest of the crew and proved himself to be a valuable crew member. And then B'Elanna. She came to terms with her anger and found love:adore: ( awwwwwwww )

But I also liked how Neelix grew and changed, too. I think it would have been cool if they could have found a way for Tuvix to stick around, but that's for another post

All in all the characters aren't too bad. Harry was progressing pretty good, if a bit slow.
 
Ensign Harry Kim.

He is quite possibly the most real world example of sticking out a tough situation, keep going at it when others around him do not treat him fairly and equally, and always performs his duties beyond expectations no matter what his personal stance and particular situation at any given time.

But, isn't he supposed to be Korean (Specifically, Korean American)? Then why all of a sudden was he given a Chinese heritage with a popular Korean surname like that?
 
Ensign Harry Kim.

He is quite possibly the most real world example of sticking out a tough situation, keep going at it when others around him do not treat him fairly and equally, and always performs his duties beyond expectations no matter what his personal stance and particular situation at any given time.

In other words, he had absolutely no emotional depth, and all he did was complete the functions that was expected of him on Voyager and little more.

But, isn't he supposed to be Korean (Specifically, Korean American)? Then why all of a sudden was he given a Chinese heritage with a popular Korean surname like that?

When was he given Chinese heritage? I don't remember that
 
For me it had to be:



Captain Janeway
Seven of Nine
The Doctor
Chakotay
Tom Paris
B'Elanna
Tuvok
Ensign Kim
Mr. Neelix
Kes
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top