That Vulcan in Engineering?

[exodus]

Tom's rank made no sense really. Helm is often manned by ensigns, he'd done nothing to deserve a senior rank, and his leadership skills were definitely inferior to Kim and Torres, especially considering the number of times their engineering skills benefitted or even saved the ship.

His Daddy was an Admiral and it would look good on Aunty Janeways service record if she could give his naughty son a second chance.

Tom's rank was a political move for Janeway, not much else...........at first.

 

[Pauln6]

Tom's rank made no sense really. Helm is often manned by ensigns, he'd done nothing to deserve a senior rank, and his leadership skills were definitely inferior to Kim and Torres, especially considering the number of times their engineering skills benefitted or even saved the ship.

His Daddy was an Admiral and it would look good on Aunty Janeways service record if she could give his naughty son a second chance.

Tom's rank was a political move for Janeway, not much else...........at first.

Ah right, sort of how NuPike groomed NuKirk for command after picking him up in that bar? "So tell me son, have you ever been in an Orion sauna?" I mean, it's not as if Kirk really earned such a rapid promotion is it? So from this we assume that Kim wasn't prepared to 'sit' on Janeway's promotion couch and Paris was?

 

[exodus]

Tom's rank made no sense really. Helm is often manned by ensigns, he'd done nothing to deserve a senior rank, and his leadership skills were definitely inferior to Kim and Torres, especially considering the number of times their engineering skills benefitted or even saved the ship.

His Daddy was an Admiral and it would look good on Aunty Janeways service record if she could give his naughty son a second chance.

Tom's rank was a political move for Janeway, not much else...........at first.

Ah right, sort of how NuPike groomed NuKirk for command after picking him up in that bar? "So tell me son, have you ever been in an Orion sauna?" I mean, it's not as if Kirk really earned such a rapid promotion is it? So from this we assume that Kim wasn't prepared to 'sit' on Janeway's promotion couch and Paris was?

Yep, Janeway was looking for Admiral pips on her uniform just like her dad. She wanted the quickest way with little effort. Remember in "Shattered" when Chakotay mentions Harry, Janeway scoffs at his name. Chakotay corrects her and tells her not to laugh because he becomes one of their best officers. Janeway didn't think much of Harry in getting her much of anything at first.

 

[kimc]

Tom's rank made no sense really. Helm is often manned by ensigns, he'd done nothing to deserve a senior rank, and his leadership skills were definitely inferior to Kim and Torres, especially considering the number of times their engineering skills benefitted or even saved the ship.

I always thought she restored his former rank because of his performance on the planet during "Caretaker". Besides, he had a reputation as a great pilot (well, before the accident) and Sadi was dead so the spot was open.

 

[jo jo]

1) whos sadi
2) i think his rank should have been restored alot later on so he had had enough time to prome himself worthy of said rank

 

[exodus]

1) whos sadi
2) i think his rank should have been restored alot later on so he had had enough time to prome himself worthy of said rank

Sadi is the Betazoid pilot you see flying Tom out to DS9/Voyager in the premiere episode.

 

[SilentP]

It's one thing for Paris to have started his career on Voyager at a higher rank than Harry, it's another for him to be demoted and then promoted back to his original rank as well, without Harry getting any promotion. Janeway really doesn't seem to favour Harry.