I don't mean to be rude or anything, but I'm dismayed that half of voters in this poll found this joyless, senseless, witless, artless, headache-inducing fiasco "Above Average" to "Excellent". Absolutely
everything about this disaster was
horrible, from the awful casting to the Looney Tunes action to the vomit-inducing dialogue to the utter defilement of a terrifying Cold War parable stomped and corrupted into a third-assed
hur, hur riff on the prevalence of the Cloud in modern life. I love
Terminator 1-
3, but this is a franchise that no longer has
any good reason to exist.
Shame on everyone involved. Shame! With the lone exception of J.K. Simmons, playing a character who actually seemed like a plausible human. Everyone else utterly failed and/or embarrassed themselves.
I disagree. Nick Stahl was bad casting. It was several years later, and John Connor should have been wiser and grittier at that point in his life. He should have learned a few lessons on the streets and been emotionally tougher. It made no sense that he had somehow evolved into an even bigger dweeb (than Eddie's John Connor in T2) by the time of judgement day. The character had no apparent leadership qualities and was not believable as the future leader of the resistance.
What you're talking about there is the writing, not the casting. The character was written that way, as not having grown much since T2, and it was cast well in that regard. And honestly, I'm not sure it's terrible writing either (maybe just mediocre). John is raised his whole life to be some sort of savior, finally realizes that it's true, but then averts Judgment Day. Once it's over, his purpose is no longer apparent. Everything that he's ever been taught has basically vanished, so it's understandable that he might be having some issues about it.
Yes, absolutely. I love
T3/Stahl's portrayal of John as a scarred shell of a survivor from the events of
T2. He's either one of the most important people who ever lived, or someone who's doomed to live his entire life off the grid in an increasingly digital world, lest he compromise his identity on the off chance that Skynet has somehow survived and might find him once more. The one thing in his life that can give himself purpose and a reason to live is the very thing he least wants to happen, for the good of humanity.
... Yeah, I'm thinking living with that's gonna severely screw up a guy.
