• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sussman Responds to Cogley!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Posted by JohnM:
Who knows, Berman can be any one of us.

All right, I confess. It's me, Rick. I'm just here keeping an eye on Sussman and Goodman and you folks figured it out. Darn!

And Morpheus, I know who you are and I expect to see you in my office Monday morning, got it?

Carry on.
 
Posted by Naminator:
Imagine this: Joel Schumacher decides to hold an interview with a movie website, let's say, CHUD. The plans are for him to talk about "Batman & Robin". He spends 10 pages of text explaining about how thought out his story was, and how plastic nipples were actually part of the Batman lore. ;)
lol!!! Nice post! :D :D :D
 
Posted by Lady Conqueror:
Why does nobody ever suspect me? :(
____________________________________________________________

You?
Nawww. You're nice. :) Berman evil. :mad:
 
Posted by JohnM:
Posted by slappy:
Posted by Power-Of-Ten:

#2 -- Sussman never replied to Mr Cogley's main point ... that there was no good reason for "Regeneration" since it wasn't a great Borg epiode and it didn't answer any lingering questions about the Borg.

#3 -- If Sussman felt the need to reply to an on-line review then it tells me that he doesn't really think the episode speaks for itself.... especially when he's giving us stuff that was cut from the final script.

Was he supposed to say "You know what? I had no reason to write this episode and I will attempt to correct my unoriginality in my future endeavors."?

Rick Berman doesn't give a rat's ass about anyone on this board, but when Sussman takes his time to talk to us, he's told that he's desperate and isn't proud of his work. Hmm.

Damned it you do, damned if you don't.

How do you know Berman doesnt come on here and either look or even talk with us??

Who knows, Berman can be any one of us. This is the biggest Trek BBS on the internet.

Im sure Braga and Berman are here or at least looking.

I sure hope so!
 
Hbomb:
Uh, he's referring to you, too.

You really are embarrassing yourself here, JohnM. You'd think a self-proclaimed "gusher" would act a little more sophisticated in his hero's thread.

While you're at it, why don't you tell Sussman about how you tried to sell all the TrekBBS members knock-off NX-01 hats in the first season.

1 official warning for trolling goes to Hbomb. It's fine to take apart someone's argument. It's not fine to get personal like that. Taking a cheap shot at John like that is trolling because it's intent is to ignite a flame war. This coming after the Mods have come in to ask for people to post peacefully, dude, it's just not kosher.

Noname Given:
Boy, you relly ARE a clueless idiot at times. If you ever bother to read the credits, you'd know that Rick Berman has been a part of the production staff on TNG since Season 2, and was a main producer from Season 3 onward. Kind of blows the above statement to bits as if this were the case, then by your logic the entire Star Trek franchise has 'sucked' from TNG season 2 onward.

If you're going to argue something you may want to get your facts straight before opening your mouth....OOOOPS I FORGOT ho I was talking to here.

1 official warning for flaming goes to Noname Given. I think this one's pretty self explanatory.

JohnM:
Im sure Braga and Berman are here or at least looking.

Everyone else was just kidding. But seriously, I am Braga. And, just between us . . . Jeri Ryan? Oh yeah, they're real! :D
 
I can admit I wasn't going to like 'The Borg Episode' no matter what it contained. I should have stayed away, but I couldn't help myself. Why? Because of people like Sam Cogley . No matter how much I dislike an episode, I know Sam , or someone like him, will make it worth my time in the long run. So I'm glad to see part of the S&S team feel the same way.

And, as much as I disliked Regeneration, I can also admit I appear to be in the minority. So (in answer to the question: Why a Borg Epy anyway?) if it was a stab at converting nay-sayers (at least on the web), it seems to have done it's job. (I don't know about the ratings - did they go up?)

I'm also glad some of the 'supporting' cast managed to be a part of the action. I hope these folks aren't going to disappear in favor of the new semi-cast of the 'Expanse' story. :(

-M

PS: The sandworm thing is gross. And, you don't really want a Stewy t-shirt, do you? :D
 
Posted by Othello:
It's amazing to me the number of people who still show they really need to get something that even remotely resembles a life after this gentleman took the time to respond to nothing more than bitter, twisted posts by people who wouldn't give the show a fair shake if their life depended on it.

bitter, twisted posts ?? Did you even read Sam's review? I thought it was funny as hell. And guess what, apparently, so did Mr. Sussman:

Posted by MikeSussman:
A very entertaining review, Sam

And there were plenty of people who gave Enterprise a fair shake last week, with "Cogenitor".

The only bitter post I see in this thread, comes from you.
 
Posted by where'sSaavik?:
Hbomb:
Uh, he's referring to you, too.

You really are embarrassing yourself here, JohnM. You'd think a self-proclaimed "gusher" would act a little more sophisticated in his hero's thread.

While you're at it, why don't you tell Sussman about how you tried to sell all the TrekBBS members knock-off NX-01 hats in the first season.

1 official warning for trolling goes to Hbomb. It's fine to take apart someone's argument. It's not fine to get personal like that. Taking a cheap shot at John like that is trolling because it's intent is to ignite a flame war. This coming after the Mods have come in to ask for people to post peacefully, dude, it's just not kosher.

Noname Given:
Boy, you relly ARE a clueless idiot at times. If you ever bother to read the credits, you'd know that Rick Berman has been a part of the production staff on TNG since Season 2, and was a main producer from Season 3 onward. Kind of blows the above statement to bits as if this were the case, then by your logic the entire Star Trek franchise has 'sucked' from TNG season 2 onward.

If you're going to argue something you may want to get your facts straight before opening your mouth....OOOOPS I FORGOT ho I was talking to here.

1 official warning for flaming goes to Noname Given. I think this one's pretty self explanatory.

JohnM:
Im sure Braga and Berman are here or at least looking.

Everyone else was just kidding. But seriously, I am Braga. And, just between us . . . Jeri Ryan? Oh yeah, they're real! :D

:lol: :lol:

And by the way, Hbomb, I was selling them LONG before the first season. Get your facts correct first. :rolleyes:

So, You're Braga?? And she's real? Of course, Ive seen her on MTV in her bikini. She's real.

I still cant decide, Jolene or Jeri on MTV. Both are in Bikini's, both look pretty wild!
 
Posted by Samuel T. Cogley:
Think Dune. You know, that movie with Picard in it. :p

Yeah, I was surprised to see Picard in Dune. Suder (from Voyager) was there too. That was a clear continuity violation. How do you rationalize that one?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top