• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Strange New Worlds Episode 7 - Those Old Scientists

Grade The Episode


  • Total voters
    319
That scene pulled at my heart strings too. Who knew Boimler could be so sentimental, but he was right. Enjoy the moments with people you care about, because you never know when it will be the last.
There were some surprisingly deep scenes in this episode for sure. Boimler with Chapel and then with Pike were two of my favorites. But also Mariner with Uhura. Well written and kudos to all the performers for bringing the emotional impact to life.
 
One of the co-writers of the episode also co-wrote Charades and was an executive story writer on Lower Decks before jumping over to SNW as a producer... which probably explains why the episode balanced both shows so well.

Not just any Lower Decks episode: wej Duj, which was arguably the best episode in Lower Decks history to date.

Trek was really, really lucky to have found her, and I hope Kathryn Lyn gets to be a showrunner eventually of her own series at this rate.
 
I like Mariner a hell of a sight better in live action than animated.

Also I take it that there's no danger the Orions could actually USE the time portal? Assuming 1) they can't translate the instructions, and 2) there's no more hironium alloy to power it?

Oh and I agree about the scene with Boimler and Pike. It's no secret that I like it when people take things seriously. I'm glad Boimler got the chance to do that.
 
There were some surprisingly deep scenes in this episode for sure. Boimler with Chapel and then with Pike were two of my favorites. But also Mariner with Uhura. Well written and kudos to all the performers for bringing the emotional impact to life.
It's almost like this episode was able to weave serious and funny throughout.

*sensible chuckle as the credits roll*
 
I must also react to this episode. Loved it. There. Reaction done. Now who's up for dom-jot?
 
I took it as Mariner being a little evasive - she's not sure what the "safe" answer is.
"I can't say it's not a pin-up, but I don't want to say that it's a pin-up."
That was how I took it at the time, except that we learn later it's absolutely NOT a pin-up.

dJE
 
I took it as Mariner being a little evasive - she's not sure what the "safe" answer is.
"I can't say it's not a pin-up, but I don't want to say that it's a pin-up."
The joke is that it actually is NOT a pin-up poster in the common use of the expression even though it was a poster pinned up in his bunk. The real meaning that Mariner was trying to convey through her confusion was not clear until we saw it was a recruitment poster rather than a "pin-up" in the colloquial sense--and that's truer to Boimler's character too.

So, a bit of word play. Safe to say that Mariner wasn't being evasive but truly unfamiliar with the term "pin-up poster." And what she said was absolutely correct--it was a poster that was pinned up!
 
So, a bit of word play. Safe to say that Mariner wasn't being evasive but truly unfamiliar with the term "pin-up poster." And what she said was absolutely correct--it was a poster that was pinned up!

It was a good joke, but Mariner wasn't the right one to say it because there's no way in hell she doesn't know what a pinup is.

One of the few areas of the episode where I think Tendi or Rutherford being included would have worked better, since they're so much more "pure" than she is.
 
Is it just me or do the live-action Cerritos uniforms have more of the black area (near the shoulders) than the animated versions do?

In animation, the division color goes almost all the way up and only ends a short distance below the neck. But in live action the color area ends like halfway up the front!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top