• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starship Platform Lifespans

There was one from a parallel universe where everything was tiny at the beginning of the last season Lower Decks. I would’ve forgotten it if I hadn’t double-checked.

Ah. I was referring to the use of the studio model or CGI model during the Berman era.
 
i believe there's a WWII minelayer that drachinifel or ryan szymanski (curator of battleship new jersey) did a tour of, that got coverted to being a personal yacht at some point after the war, that they were in the process of reconverting to her wartime config.

it actually seems to be pretty common in museum ships to "backdate" them, or rather, pick a point in their history to represent, unless they went straight from commission to museum status. if they had a short active span, then they went into mothballs, a good chunk of their equipment getting taken to use on fresh ships. and if they had a long service life, they had a lot of changes, and not all of them uniform...

it's not too unreasonable to think that the STIV Saratoga got refit into a similar configuration as the later one, then later decommissioned and a fresh ship in the same class and configuration built...

Many warbirds were converted into VIP transports. Who doesn't want to b in a plush A-26 or B-23 doing 300 kts while your competitor is riding a DC-3?

If I'd been around then, a surplused PT boat with three Allisons would have been awful tempting.
 
Doesn't count, since we only saw part of what looked like an engineering hull. That's not enough proof to say that it was a full Constitution II class.

Same time, we never see another ship with that particular hull anywhere else in the franchise, that I’m aware of.
 
The JTVFX fan video on the Battle of Wolf 359 has a recreation of that scene of the Enterprise going through the debris. Interestingly, while this version has a modified Constitution II present at the battle they have that specific hull as a Federation II-class hull (TMP refit of a Federation-class dreadnaught).
 
The JTVFX fan video on the Battle of Wolf 359 has a recreation of that scene of the Enterprise going through the debris. Interestingly, while this version has a modified Constitution II present at the battle they have that specific hull as a Federation II-class hull (TMP refit of a Federation-class dreadnaught).

That is their personal interpretation, though there is no on screen evidence to support.

Is there any on screen evidence that the Federation II exists?
 
Well, hero ships are always weirdly distributed compared to guest ships that don't have the same narrative obligation to be distinctive. We didn't see a second Sovereign-class ship until 2022. We've only ever seen three Intrepid-classes, and one of those was only allowed for logistical reasons since DS9 needed a guest ship with more rooms than could be reasonably redressed from the Defiant.
Yeah, I think the Defiant and Galaxy are the most seen hero ship classes. More Galaxies than Defiants.
 
That is their personal interpretation, though there is no on screen evidence to support.

Is there any on screen evidence that the Federation II exists?

Not a TMP refit version of it, no. The only time the Franz Joseph version appeared on screen was the outline of it on a display in TWOK, and those little models in Guinan's bar in PIC. And a dreadnought with the name USS Entente NCC-2120 (taken from FJ's manual) was heard in radio chatter in TMP, but it wasn't seen on screen so it could have looked different from the FJ version.

The ironic thing is that they could probably design a TMP version of the dreadnought and wouldn't get in trouble with FJ's estate, because although it would be the same configuration, it wouldn't be the same design.
 
Well, we did see an FJ Dreadnought model in Picard, and Entente’s registry in TMP.

I am willing to entertain a notion that Entente perhaps was at Wolf 359….but Stargazer with four nacelles was its better.

Excelsior gets the latest tech, and Hathaway gets simpler, proven tech.

A Federation II could have separated its saucer and escaped—presumed destroyed.

The saucer has its own nacelle after all….making it a destroyer equivalent on its own.

I might have had the secondary hull ram the cube on autopilot.
 
Yeah, I think the Defiant and Galaxy are the most seen hero ship classes. More Galaxies than Defiants.

They used the Galaxy class CGI model in the DS9 Dominion War fleet scenes because the Enterprise-D had already been destroyed and they had the Sovereign class Ent-E, so the audience would not have been confused and thinking they were seeing the Ent-D. If the Ent-D had not been destroyed in Generations, I doubt the DS9 VFX people would have used the Galaxy model.
 
They used the Galaxy class CGI model in the DS9 Dominion War fleet scenes because the Enterprise-D had already been destroyed and they had the Sovereign class Ent-E, so the audience would not have been confused and thinking they were seeing the Ent-D. If the Ent-D had not been destroyed in Generations, I doubt the DS9 VFX people would have used the Galaxy model.

They did use a Galaxy-class model in “The Jem’Hadar”. A few months before it was destroyed in Generations.
 
They did use a Galaxy-class model in “The Jem’Hadar”. A few months before it was destroyed in Generations.

Yes, but they specifically mentioned in dialogue that the ship was the Odyssey. I was referring to the random Galaxies in the Dominion war fleets.
 
USS Odyssey was a Galaxy-class for the "Worf Effect" with the new Dominion. Bring the strongest known starship in the Federation and have it clobbered in a fight. Much like having the new alien or godlike being toss Worf over the railing on the Enterprise bridge to show just how strong they are.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top