Starfleet in which time period do you like the best?
- Thread starter USS Belmont
- Start date
Option 3. TOS AOS SNW
TOS.
I think for most people, it'll be the law of primacy as the deciding factor. I had TOS Trek my first 18 years of life before TNG even showed up as a possibility. For me, TOS was 'hard wired' as 'Star Trek' in my brain at that point, along with a lot of FASA gaming and content.
I think for most people, it'll be the law of primacy as the deciding factor. I had TOS Trek my first 18 years of life before TNG even showed up as a possibility. For me, TOS was 'hard wired' as 'Star Trek' in my brain at that point, along with a lot of FASA gaming and content.
Bucking the trend..
Enterprise Era/ after founding. Everything was new, and full of wonder. Designs were utilitarian, bit cramped, but not so much so as not to be comfortable. Real sense of adventure.
Enterprise Era/ after founding. Everything was new, and full of wonder. Designs were utilitarian, bit cramped, but not so much so as not to be comfortable. Real sense of adventure.
That's tough. TOS was my first love, but TNG holds a special place in my heart.
3. The TOS/TAS/TOS-M era. Its the only period to truly mix the inherent mystery of / living up to the idea of a "Final Frontier", which made the dangers and discoveries seem important--grand and unique, even to the technologically advanced members of Starfleet's vessels. Being intentionally regimented in the militaristic sense (despite Roddenberry's 70's convention & TNG era revisionist spin jobs), there was an edge to proceedings, yet the most soulful characters (good, bad and all emotions in-between) and reactions at its center, making their exploration far more appealing than other periods.
Right now, 25th century/PIC era, despite my frustrations with the show itself. There have been enough shake-ups between Nemesis and PIC that there's potentially a whole new political map to be drawn and a lot of world-building to be done, and I hope we get to see more of it.
TNG to Lower Decks era by far. The fact that it contains about 580 out of Star Trek's 880 stories might be making me a bit biased, but I do have a lot of fondness for the 'places people might actually want to live in for years at a time' look.
I think right now I like the Picard era the least, because it's sad to see Starfleet so miserable and corrupted. Every time it looks like they're pulling out of it they just fall in further. Discovery's Starfleet is a close second just because of that colour grading that makes Starfleet HQ seem like a horribly sterile and unpleasant place to be.
I think right now I like the Picard era the least, because it's sad to see Starfleet so miserable and corrupted. Every time it looks like they're pulling out of it they just fall in further. Discovery's Starfleet is a close second just because of that colour grading that makes Starfleet HQ seem like a horribly sterile and unpleasant place to be.
I really want to say TNG era because I feel so comfortable with it but, I would like ENT era when everything was new and uncertain and dangerous. (But, ENT era as exemplified by Hoshi and Phlox, not necessarily Archer, who was desperately of a study abroad period or lessons in cultural relativity).
late DS9 era because those uniforms look comfortable. The late 23rd Century uniforms, I would dread doing anything besides sitting in an extreme climate controlled environment. They look unforgiving in warm temperatures.
Anything but the 32nd century of DSC.
Honestly, I'm getting kind of tired of all the magic tech they have then. The magic insta-transporter, the magic bridges (inside Federation Headquarters) that magically build themselves right when somebody wants to walk over them, the magic Programmable Matter (holy hell, I *really* hate that), the magic non-attached warp nacelles, the magic starships that look like mutant sea creatures....need I go on?
Hell, I doubt there are even DOCTORS that far in the future. They probably have magic medical technology that magically gives everyone immortality.
There is one thing, though. in that one episode where the ninja assassin steals dilithium, they showed the inside of a 32nd century starship, but it still has corridors that people can walk around in. I understand this was probably just a redressed set from Discovery but at least the interior of a starship is still recognizable, with people walking around and probably even a bridge to use. They don't have everyone wired up to the computer piloting the ship with their brains. So there's SOME hope...
Honestly, I'm getting kind of tired of all the magic tech they have then. The magic insta-transporter, the magic bridges (inside Federation Headquarters) that magically build themselves right when somebody wants to walk over them, the magic Programmable Matter (holy hell, I *really* hate that), the magic non-attached warp nacelles, the magic starships that look like mutant sea creatures....need I go on?
Hell, I doubt there are even DOCTORS that far in the future. They probably have magic medical technology that magically gives everyone immortality.
There is one thing, though. in that one episode where the ninja assassin steals dilithium, they showed the inside of a 32nd century starship, but it still has corridors that people can walk around in. I understand this was probably just a redressed set from Discovery but at least the interior of a starship is still recognizable, with people walking around and probably even a bridge to use. They don't have everyone wired up to the computer piloting the ship with their brains. So there's SOME hope...
Should have had that with the transporter centuries ago.Hell, I doubt there are even DOCTORS that far in the future. They probably have magic medical technology that magically gives everyone immortality.
Right at this particular moment, the era that intrigues me the most is the post-Nemesis era seen in Lower Decks, Prodigy and Picard.
It's the late TNG-DS9-VOY era for me. The first Trek I saw was TOS, but I came of age with 90s Trek, and I was immersed in it. I wasn't just watching the shows, I was playing Elite Force and Away Team and Armada, saturated by this shared universe with common aesthetics and overlapping characters. To me, the Defiant-Voyager aesthetic is just 'right'.
Mid to late 24th Century Starfleet (TNG, DS9, VOY, TNG films)
It's the era I grew up with. True, I did watch the occasional episode of TOS, but I didn't really get into Star Trek until TNG. Though I often prefer the ship based shows (TNG, VOY), I often watched DS9 as well and have some favorites on that series as well (Quark and Odo being the main two), even if it isn't my favorite. I might have enjoyed TOS more if it was my generation (I was born in the early 70's), and I always thought that Kirk was too much of a ladies man (though Picard can be to, but he's a little more sophisticated about it) for my tastes.
P.S. I love it when Data says: "YES!" in Generations when the Klingon Bird of Prey is destroyed (since the Duras sisters are technically responsible for destroying the Enterprise-D, even though the saucer section crash landed on Veridian III).
It's the era I grew up with. True, I did watch the occasional episode of TOS, but I didn't really get into Star Trek until TNG. Though I often prefer the ship based shows (TNG, VOY), I often watched DS9 as well and have some favorites on that series as well (Quark and Odo being the main two), even if it isn't my favorite. I might have enjoyed TOS more if it was my generation (I was born in the early 70's), and I always thought that Kirk was too much of a ladies man (though Picard can be to, but he's a little more sophisticated about it) for my tastes.
P.S. I love it when Data says: "YES!" in Generations when the Klingon Bird of Prey is destroyed (since the Duras sisters are technically responsible for destroying the Enterprise-D, even though the saucer section crash landed on Veridian III).
Similar threads
