• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Starfleet Academy, take two

This is an awesome thread...what about academic based courses? You've listed a pretty good core of military classes but not any academic? I've scanned through the thread though so forgive me if some of these were mentioned. Xenohistorical classes could be given on the core Federation races and then a series of electives on other species within the Federation members could be offered. Also what about officer sponsors? Mallory was only in the Shatnerverse book we don't know how Kirk got into the Academy in the Prime Universe. Picard took the test three times before he got in. Perhaps this might be a aspect of the early Starfleet Academy program...we know that Spock sponsored both Saavik and Valeris. Sisko as mentioned gave Nog his recommendation and probably would have acted as a sponsor if this was in the 23rd century.

I dislike the idea of officer sponsors for citizens intensely. It harkens back to worst aspects of patronage.

I didn't go into the academic courses becauses there arre likely to be a couple dozen majors, and even figuring out what the hell might be taught is hard.

There's also the fact that the military courses are more fun to imagine.
 
Very interesting to read these posts, but what about the exploration and scientific arms, or departments, or aspects of Starfleet? Or are they shoved to the back and stuck behind desks, where no-one can see them?

Or, don't they exist? Are there any pure research vessels that don't have as heavy armament, like Grissom, in ST3?

In the post-Dominion War Starfleet (I wrote specifically for 2381-2383-ish), I'm never gotten the feeling there would ever be pure research vessels. The Galaxy's too unstable for Starfleet to go out and explore, there's way too much to do at home.

In reality, SFA's part in exploration training would be reflected solely in the academic courses - which, as I mentioned, are kinda hard to write about and kinda boring to write about. The military and, er, vocational courses are much more interesting to write about, and much easier to write about.
 
Very interesting to read these posts, but what about the exploration and scientific arms, or departments, or aspects of Starfleet? Or are they shoved to the back and stuck behind desks, where no-one can see them?

Or, don't they exist? Are there any pure research vessels that don't have as heavy armament, like Grissom, in ST3?

In the post-Dominion War Starfleet (I wrote specifically for 2381-2383-ish), I'm never gotten the feeling there would ever be pure research vessels. The Galaxy's too unstable for Starfleet to go out and explore, there's way too much to do at home.

In reality, SFA's part in exploration training would be reflected solely in the academic courses - which, as I mentioned, are kinda hard to write about and kinda boring to write about. The military and, er, vocational courses are much more interesting to write about, and much easier to write about.

Aren't there science officers and exobiology officers and science labs aboard every vessel, apart from Defiant?

Don't they play a part in assessing threats and some part in building more powerful weapons? What do you do if an alien comes aboard who has unheard of, or undiscovered, or resisitant technology? Just throw everything you've got at it and hope for the best?;)
 
The way I figure:

No, there aren't. A lot of smaller vessels might have a singular science officer, if that. It's something I didn't include in the main document because it's not really supported in either way, but my personal viewpoint is that Starfleet Sciences mostly lives on Starbases in the post-NEM era, fighting to get itself back on starships full-time.

It's one reason I see every SFA cadet getting a basic education in every branch's tasks, insofar as that's possible, during Plebe and Youngster years - science becomes everybody's job, filtered through their day job. There aren't going to be big labs aboard most starships. What research ships didn't get eaten up by the Dominion War probably got repurposed into scouts - mobile sensors, really, sent out ahead of the main body of a force to detect, say, cloaked vessels.

It's, for Star Trek, a very dark future, but it's definitely what's implied by the later TNG movies, the Dominion War, and even a good bit of the novel continuity (as I understand it).
 
For myself, I see three main reasons for this:
1) TOS established that the Preservers seeded several planets in this region of space with humans in pre-history. Many of those worlds may now be members of the Federation.
2) Various sources establish alien races that look human unless closely examined.
3) Nobody has been quite as enthusiastic about joining the Federation as the Earth people: we gave over several of our major cities to host Federation facilites, for example. When was the last time you heard about the United Earth Government? The Earth representative to the Federation? Earth Defense Forces? It looks like the Federation basicly is the government of Earth.

While you don't hear about them, you were supposed to in "Paradise Lost" and "Homefront" in DS9. Certainly, though, we never hear about them on-screen, but then we've never really seen Federation politics either. Presumably, they exist. Presumably, it isn't a military dictatorship run by Starfleet; Presumably, it has more than a vestigial civilian governemnt. But as noted, I believe, in my thread on the point, you don't actually see much evidence of either concept on-screen.:)

SpyOne said:
While this seems quite reasonable, it stands in contrast to some canon evidence: Starfleet seems to recognize that life in Starfleet is not for everyone, and that it may take someone quite some time to figure out that life in Starfleet is not for them, so leaving seems to be a "no harm, no foul" deal. Take as examples Wesley Crusher, who resigned in his Senior Year (IIRC) and went on walkabout with The Traveller, and Nick Locarno, also a Senior, who resigned after accepting responsibility for an accident that killed a junior cadet.

It seems that serving in Starfleet is a privelege and not a duty: the training is available for free to all who make the cut, and there is no obligation of service (although there is a certain amount of shame in leaving the service).

Locarno can be easily explained. In the military there is such a thing as "resignation in lieu of court-martial". Locarno was probably facing several court-martial offenses, perjury and manslaughter among them most likely, and was given the option of resigning to save everybody the bother of a court-martial. (Presumably the family of the dead cadet would be asked for their approval for this course of action before it went off, as a courtesy.)

Crusher is a bit odd, and can only really be explained by some very wall-banger plot logic, IMHO. But he is also a very...special child, as we've seen. It may be they don't always exercise the options of recoupment or enlisted service, but I would presume that the option is definitely there.

It's a simple matter from a Sraefleet POV: They invest as much as they do in your training even after two years, and they're going to want something for that if you decide 2 years late that Starfleet is not for you. Every credit spent on your training could have been spent on someone else with more desire to or more likelihood to actually stick it out to get their commission. Even if you don't believe the UFP uses money, that basic concept sort of stares youi in the face.

Keep in mind how an institution like SFA operates: It *has* to be extremely selective. It could never accommodate even a quarter of those looking to get in. Except, I imagine, for very vestigial OCS and direct commission programs (OCS is practically required as a matter of sanity to deal with enlisted looking to become officers, and direct commission solves a few nagging canon issues re Troi (who never once mentioned going to SFA, only the "Univerisity of Betazed").), SFA is supposed to be the sole source (or at least the major source) of commissioned officers for Starfleet. Ergo, how many they have to graduate is essential for Starfleet's personnel folks to know -that determines the number of officers who can retire, how they handle injured officers, all sorts of things.

The number of appointment slots, therefore, is limited - especially at the San Francisco campus.

If a Midshipman can ordinarily quit on the cusp of getting their commission with no consequences, a lot of people will do that. It becomes, in a lot of contexts, insane not to game the system like that.
 
The way I figure:

No, there aren't. A lot of smaller vessels might have a singular science officer, if that. It's something I didn't include in the main document because it's not really supported in either way, but my personal viewpoint is that Starfleet Sciences mostly lives on Starbases in the post-NEM era, fighting to get itself back on starships full-time.

It's one reason I see every SFA cadet getting a basic education in every branch's tasks, insofar as that's possible, during Plebe and Youngster years - science becomes everybody's job, filtered through their day job. There aren't going to be big labs aboard most starships. What research ships didn't get eaten up by the Dominion War probably got repurposed into scouts - mobile sensors, really, sent out ahead of the main body of a force to detect, say, cloaked vessels.

It's, for Star Trek, a very dark future, but it's definitely what's implied by the later TNG movies, the Dominion War, and even a good bit of the novel continuity (as I understand it).

I think you would need science officers, even in the heat of war. Who was it who designed the defiant? Who would you need aboard in case they bumped into someone with even superior weapons to the dominion, or if the dominion came up with a new weapon? Somehow, I think would need even a ships counsellor, particularly in times of war. maybe not on the defiant. Science officers have combat training too, don't they?
 
To an extent, Science officers do. But their primary functions (especially the conduct of research) become irrelevant in wartime, and for the science-related tactical tasks, you can easily cross-train someone with more generally necessary primary functions to do the job. Curiously, re counselors, DS9 didn't have one til Ezri Dax.

Suggests they are not necessarily universal.
 
^ Not true. DS9 had a counselor named Telnorri, who counseled O'Brien after he was released from prison in "Hard Time".
 
Stuff that didn't fit elsewhere:

Retention Rates

The first two years of SFA are hard. This applies for all branches - yet is more so the case for the San Francisco campus, where the pressure of being the elite only makes it worse. For San Francisco: for Plebe Summer, 10-15% of the Plebes separate from the Academy before the summer is done. This is expected and to some degree necessary; if Starfleet were to face a situation where every Plebe stayed on, or even if only 5% of Plebes left during Plebe Summer, they'd have severe space issues.

But more broadly, at San Francisco, 15-20% of the Plebe class doesn't make it to their second year. (The branch campuses, it's a bit better, 10-15%, due to the lack of quite the same pressure.) This can be for any number of reasons: Physical disqualification, mental issues, academic issues, discipline issues, you name it.

Once you make it to your second year, you're a lot less likely to quit. It's not uncommon for not a single Youngster to quit, even in the face of the "Night of No Return" that marks when the Youngsters incur their service obligation.
Past that point, voluntary separations are very, very rare. The hardest 2 years of the Academy are behind you, for one thing. It's still possible for you to be separated involuntarily for discipline issues (usually after a meeting of the Cadet Honor Board that recommends dismissal to the Commandant and then the Superintendent, as most of what causes that are Honor Concept offenses), or academic issues (where this takes a meeting of the campus Academic Progress Board, a group of professors who reviews all facets of the Cadet's record to determine if they're worth retaining), or obviously physical or mental problems, but it's not common.

[Note that Starfleet has never expereinced a drawdown in the force, canonically, to the best of my knowledge. So we have no idea how they'd handle that.]

How the staff is organized

Okay, from the top.

At the top of the Academy chain of command is Starfleet Command, namely the Commander of the Starfleet Training Command, usually a full admiral (four pips). (Usually, stuff from SFA that reaches SFC goes before a bunch of admirals, but the Commander of SF Training Command handles day to day stuff.)

Below him is the Academy Superintendent, a vice admiral (three pips). He acts in many ways like the President of a civilian college, except with greater powers and responsibilities. Starfleet does not follow the old US military practice of the Superintendent being on their final tour. Often, the Superintendent will be a flag officer recalled from retirement, or will be an officer pulled from the line for the purpose, but plenty of officers have served as Supetintendent and then gone on to higher posts in Starfleet. The Superintendent serves out of San Francisco.

The Academy Superintendent is advised in his governance of the Academy by the Board of Visitors, a statutorily-established body consisting largely of Federation Council members - the statute states that "The Board shall inquire into the state of morale and discipline, the curriculum, instruction, physical equipment, fiscal affairs, academic methods, and other matters relating to the Academy that the Board decides to consider."

Here the chain of command and responsibility gets a little complicated. Starfleet Academy was founded as a one-campus institution; many of its organizational structures have not caught up to the establishment of branch campuses.

[Given how we only have the barest mentions of Academy annexes in canon, I have to assume they were established quite recently.]

For the Branch campuses: Each campus besides San Francisco is headed by a Rear Admiral (two-pips), officially entitled the "Commander, Starfleet Academy, <branch> Annex". These officers have basically the same duties as the Superintendent does in relation to the San Francisco campus.

Each brigade of Midshipmen, including San Francisco, has a Commandant of Midshipmen. This officer, a Starfleet Captain, oversees all activities of the Brigade of Midshipmen at the campus. Below the Commandant, experienced Starfleet officers are assigned as company and battalion officers, providing guidance to the Midshipmen within their assigned company or battalion, acting as role models of Starfleet officers, and handling some administrative and disciplinary tasks.

On the Academic side, the Academy is overseen by an Academic Board, consisting of the Superintendent (or Branch Commander), the Commandant, and selected deans of the various division. Each campus offers the same academic program, set by the Superintendent in conjunction with Starfleet Training Command, but the Academic boards handle a lot of routine stuff.

The Academy's faculty is divided as such:

There are the divisions, groupings of academic departments. The divisions group several departments, or related special programs, under a dean (or in the case of the military training and officer development divisions, a commander).

Divisions
Humanities and Social Sciences
Mathematics and Science
Engineering and Weapons
Pre-Medicine and Pre-Counseling
Pre-law
Officer Development
Military Training
Physical Trauining
Library

Below the divisions are the academic departments. These are not unlike academic departments at civilian universities, and are headed by department chairmen.

[I'm not going to try to list every single academic department at Starfleet Academy.]

Civilian faculty are adjunct, assistant, associate, and full professors. (Adjunct professors are part-time. Everybody else is full-time.) It is not uncommon for there to be "Diplomats-in-Residence" posted by the Federation Diplomatic Corps, who are ranked as assistant professors, as well as other visiting faculty. All civilian faculty members have PhDs (or their equivalent).

About 40-60% of the faculty are Starfleet officers - the percentage varies, but is usually hovering above 50%. These officers almost all have Master's degrees (or the equivalent) - a few have PHDs. Unlike Civilian faculty, Starfleet officers on the faculty do not receive tenure. Generally, Starfleet officers are posted as Academy faculty in 3-year tours, but there are a limited number of Permanent Military Professors, who serve at the Academy until retirement, and advance along the civilian faculty path from assistant to full professor. The Divisions of Military Training, Physical Training, and Officer Development must, by regulation, be led by active-duty Starfleet Officers, and virtually all of the faculty in those divisions are active-duty Starfleet personnel.

SFA uses a good number of Enlisted personnel, especially in the Physical Training and Military Training Divisions. Almost without exception, these are experienced NCOs, starting with the Command Master Chief for each Academy Branch.

Outside of the Academic structure, SFA is in many respects like a normal university. There are admissions folks, and HR folks, office staff, and so forth and so on. These are typically civilian employees of Starfleet hired specifically to work at that Academy campus.

Components of the Academy that fit nowhere else:

The Academy Infirmary, at each of the campuses, is not unlike a small clinic. Staffed by Starfleet medical personnel, they handle (among other things) the intake physical exams of Plebes and the pre-commissioning physicals of upperclass cadets, and do the other things you might expect from a Starfleet sickbay aboard any ship. (Hospital care is typically provided by Starfleet hospitals, where possible.)

{If the Academy has chaplains, they have a Chaplains section, if not a Chapel. I'd see chaplains deployed at the Academy battalion level for the cadets.]

Post-Graduate training

On SFA's expansive San Francisco campus, numerous advanced training programs are hosted.

Among some of them:

Starfleet Medical School, known often as "Starfleet Medical", operates under the auspices of the Starfleet Medical Command. This institution trains Starfleet's physicians.

[It makes more sense to imagine that Beverly Crusher commanded the Starfleet Medical School, not the entirety of Starfleet Medical Command, which seems more like an Admiral's job than a Commander's.]

Starfleet Counseling School, which trains Starfleet Academy cadets destined to become counselors.

Starfleet Command School, which is required of all officers en route to serving as Executive Officers or Commanding Officers aboard Starfleet ships, units, or bases.

Advanced Tactical Training, a twenty-four week program for commissioned officers focusing on advanced starship and ground tactics.

[This is the program taught at by Chakotay and attended by Ro Laren, expanded to cover ground tactics.]

Starfleet School of Law, training future lawyers for the JAG's office and Staff Judge Advocate positions across Starfleet.

Remaining stuff

The elite "squadrons", such as Nova Squadron or Red Squadron, by all accounts, produced far more problems than they solved. Hence, after being suspended in the wake of the Leyton Coup, the squadrons were formally disbanded in 2375.

Instead, cadets are recognized through several honors programs:

---

Advanced Combat Training Program - established only in 2379, this program is open to the top 40 cadets heading into their senior year. On top of everything else for senior year, cadets in this program train extensively in combat tactics, both personal and collective, in a variety of environments. It requires screening by Starfleet Intelligence to enter, as the program deals with the details of starship and ground tactics and strategy, at levels from one-on-one combat to fleet engagements and regimental engagements. Program lasts for the entire year, and the cadets live in their own dormitory. Beyond that one exception, cadets otherwise receive no extra privileges.

Semester in Space - select first or second-class cadets may enroll in this program, which places them aboard a starship for one semester, rotating through departments and serving as a junior officer, while still undergoing their regular SFA curriculum.

Faculty-Student Research Program - select Midshipmen may, for academic credit, apply to act as research assistants to faculty members in their own research projects. Particularly popular with sciences and premed students.

---

Starfleet Academy cadets may also be awarded scholarships to study at noted graduate institiutions across the Federation, including Oxford University, the nearby University of California - Berkeley, and the Vulcan Science Academy.

The top-scoring cadet being commissioned in that year's class may, at Starfleet Command's option, be commissioned at the rank of lieutenant, junior grade.

---

And I've run out of stuff that seems like it belongs.
 
Advanced Combat Training Program - established only in 2379, this program is open to the top 40 cadets heading into their senior year. On top of everything else for senior year, cadets in this program train extensively in combat tactics, both personal and collective, in a variety of environments. It requires screening by Starfleet Intelligence to enter, as the program deals with the details of starship and ground tactics and strategy, at levels from one-on-one combat to fleet engagements and regimental engagements. Program lasts for the entire year, and the cadets live in their own dormitory. Beyond that one exception, cadets otherwise receive no extra privileges.

The top 40 cadets? Academically or in physical fitness? I don't think the top 40 academically ranked students would necessarily be the same top 40 physically-fit cadets.

And why would SI need to screen these cadets? Since when are starship operations secret? Anyway, isn't all of that stuff what cadets entered SFA to learn? If they're going to be screened by Intelligence, why not at the beginning, before even being admitted?
 
Top 40 in the Overall Order of Merit. Which combines academics, physical readiness, military training, and a number of other factors, and is used instead of a normal class rank derived from GPA. You can be in the top 40 academically and not even close on the OOM.

The screening by SI is because these cadets are studying advanced stuff - the operational level of warfare, perhaps best defined as the level of warfare beyond the immediate range of tactical weaponry (well, that's the popular definition used in publications today, I grant it may not translate as well to space). Basically, the implicit purpose of this program is to plan and groom war planners and prospective admirals, or at least officers on track to become flag officers within a few decades.

Cadets are screened by Starfleet Intelligence - before even being invited to take the entrance exams, as I noted in the plebe summer post. This is a much deeper and in some ways more invasive screening. The difference in RL terms would be between the screening you undergo for a Confidential or Secret security clearance, and the more detailed screening you undergo for Top Secret clearance. These cadets, unlike the other Starfleet cadets, actually do deal with classified information (instead of simply FOUO (For Official Use Only) stuff). I won't deny that "Ender's Game" gave me a hint of a concept - indeed, the working title for the program before I came up with the ACTP label was "Ender's Revenge" - in training cadets to be admirals, not merely Ensigns or starship Captains. (They still advance through the ranks, but they're trained in big picture stuff from their time in the Academy.) They're not meant to be total badasses (though with that much combat training, they won't be slouches), but they are meant to have advanced training as combat officers in their specialty. (Entirely possible for a science type or medical type to take this, yes.) The methods it uses aren't used extensively because they essentially consist of pushing cadets until they're ready to break - constantly. For a full academic year. Most cadets couldn't take that for a semester without cracking.
 
You've certainly given this version of Starfleet Academy a lot of thought. I'm not certain if you're posting it here for feedback or just to be appreciated as a detailed world-building exercise. I just don't see any advantage to training students to be admirals when they're going to be commissioned as lowly ensigns. I think you're neglecting the fact that officers will probably return to the Academy for advanced courses like the one you've laid out. There is such a thing as on the job training; I don't see why all your SFA cadets have to learn everything in just a single 4-year curriculum. Surely there must be a Starfleet Academy grad school program to learn how to be a command officer. Will you be laying out your ideas about Starfleet post-graduate education?
 
I do a lot of these threads because I'm bored IRL. Only then do I think about how other people will react.

So far as post-grad stuff: I'd do it, but we know less than nothing about post-graduate training, and there are likely dozens of programs.
 
Fascinating stuff...your version of the Academy is pretty close to what I have always imagined it being like. Kind of makes you wanna go doesn't it?
 
To an extent, Science officers do. But their primary functions (especially the conduct of research) become irrelevant in wartime, and for the science-related tactical tasks, you can easily cross-train someone with more generally necessary primary functions to do the job. Curiously, re counselors, DS9 didn't have one til Ezri Dax.

Suggests they are not necessarily universal.

I don't think science officers will ever become irrelevant. Without science, there would be no starships in the first place. Again, what happens if the enemy develop a new weapon, and you are lightyears from a starbase? you'll be saying you don't need engineers, next!

Are you in the military, by any chance?
 
Wouldn't science officers be under the Operations Manager's department in the TNG era? This is what I always assumed.
 
I honestly could not guess either way. On the one hand, they wear blue, but they aren't medical or counseling. I suppose it depends on the ship/base/unit.
 
So far as post-grad stuff
Before McCoy entered SFA, he was already a MD, his broken marriage lead him into Starfleet. Bashir, I believe, was also already a doctor. SFA did not train them to be doctors, it trained them to be a Starfleet officer - doctors.

With their likely pick of applicants, SFA can select people who already possess MD's, PhD's, masters degrees, engineering certificates. If you step away from the requirement that new cadets be young, the SFA is then opened up to a great number of trained professionals, who would only need to be trained in Starfleet techniques and methods, this would apply to both officers and enlisted.

Are you in the military, by any chance?
It might be useful to consider what role officers play in Starfleet. Silly question? Something people who are civilians and have had little personal contact with the military aren't always aware of is that officers don't actual run the military. On a day by day, month by month basis, the military is largely run by the sergeants and petty officers, often with little interaction with their officers. That's their job. Officers provide leadership, overall direction and are (especially above the rank of lieutenant) resource managers. The officer in charge of a science section or in command of a science ship wouldn't necessarily have to be a scientist herself. Have a basic knowledge in science only. A starship engineering officer might know how to fix something that's in need of repair, but usually won't be the one who touches it.

The US Air Force had a problem in this area back in the 1980's, they instituted a policy that officers were to be officers first and technicians second. In other words, get out of the way of the sergeants.

Without science, there would be no starships in the first place.
The impression I've received from the show is that Zefram Cochrane wasn't a theoretical scientist but was instead a practical engineer and inventor. Someone who took a collection of disconnected theories about energized plasma, warp fields and subspace impellers and came up with a crack-pot idea. He assembled a team of other engineers and technicians, traveled around to private investors and aerospace corporations for financing and then invented a working warp drive.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top