• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

News Starfleet Academy Coming to P+

Does the article really say that? The only use of "edgy" is in the PR speak announcement.
I think it's more of that Prodigy was thought of as a way to get younger kids interested in the Star Trek franchise.

However, what they found is that they don't need such a show to get younger viewers interested in Star Trek. Kids are either introduced to it via watching it with their parents; or they find it on their own.

(I myself became a Star Trek fan at age 6 when I saw the series on NBC back in 1969.)
 
I'm beginning to have my doubts about SFA. Short of amping up the sex and/or having a serial killer running through the halls of Starfleet Academy, how do you make it edgy enough for the Yellowjackets crowd without getting too far away from its target demographic (teenagers)?
Watch Buffy or Smallville. They'll have cadets doing drugs and with the American school system being a literal battleground, a school shooting plotline is inevitable.
 
SFA may well have the same problem Prodigy had (they risk appealing to everyone except their target demographic -- teenagers).
 
SFA will last for one or two seasons. The series will be fine for what it is, don't get me wrong, but I have a feeling that's what Paramount+ is going to do.
 
SFA may well have the same problem Prodigy had (they risk appealing to everyone except their target demographic -- teenagers).

I think we can guarantee the bulk of the viewership will be made up of the same demographic as every other Trek show - 30 to 40+, predominantly male and bitching how it isn't what they want.

I'm wary of this "flavor for every demographic" approach, as am I the up-until-now futile efforts of Paramount to hook a more mainstream crowd that's probably never going to bite. Chris Pine spoke to this in an interview a few months back: stop trying to be Marvel and Star Wars, basically. Even in those properties you can see a sizable chunk of the crowd have disengaged.

STA will have to bring something pretty special to the table for it to resonate with a young audience that would otherwise have nothing to do with Trek.
 
I think we can guarantee the bulk of the viewership will be made up of the same demographic as every other Trek show - 30 to 40+, predominantly male and bitching how it isn't what they want.

I'm wary of this "flavor for every demographic" approach, as am I the up-until-now futile efforts of Paramount to hook a more mainstream crowd that's probably never going to bite. Chris Pine spoke to this in an interview a few months back: stop trying to be Marvel and Star Wars, basically. Even in those properties you can see a sizable chunk of the crowd have disengaged.

STA will have to bring something pretty special to the table for it to resonate with a young audience that would otherwise have nothing to do with Trek.

Actually I think they switched from Dis to SFA because it'll be cheaper to do SFA then Dis, I would not be surprised in SFA if they get 2 thirds to half of Dis' budget.

Smaller actors salaries, more focus on personal stories, then SFX, younger cheaper actors, more bottle episodes, maybe fewer crew behind the camera, etc...
 
Actually I think they switched from Dis to SFA because it'll be cheaper to do SFA then Dis, I would not be surprised in SFA if they get 2 thirds to half of Dis' budget.

Smaller actors salaries, more focus on personal stories, then SFX, younger cheaper actors, more bottle episodes, maybe fewer crew behind the camera, etc...
Here's hoping.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top