• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek TOS Re-Watch

The characters in universe see what we see. The machine is adding the visible effect for their benefit. Without it, transporter function and malfunctions would be invisible until it was done, and thus the whole situation would be more fraught with mystery, more jarring.
I always thought it was the carrier wave.

This sounds way worse. :cardie:
 
I think the transporter effect looks to onlookers as it does to us. But each transporter can have a different energy pattern. So the Klingon transporters look different than the federation transporters, etc. When Compton disappeared, he also had a visual which could easily have been a transporter.

Another words, it shouldn't have been that flabbergasting. Surprising and unexpected? Sure. But they've seen this sort of thing happen in front of their eyes countless times.
 
Last edited:
An outsider definitely sees something when a person is being transported. We know this thanks to the "say what you see" gangster chap from "A Piece Of The Action":

OXMYX: You know what to do.
KALO: Don't worry, Boss. They can't do nothing till they're through sparkling.
 
Right. Sound effects during some vanishing acts are debatable, but visually - what you see is what everyone gets.
 
Another words, it shouldn't have been that flabbergasting. Surprising and unexpected? Sure. But they've seen this sort of thing happen in front of their eyes countless times.

"Hey Jim, we got another one."
"Crewman? Gone? No transporters?"
"Yup. (handwave) Pfffft. Splitsville. Y'know, same old, same old."
 
My wife and I watched The Corbomite Maneuver last night. She's been listening to Ron and Clint Howard's autobiography, and wanted to see it.

A nice turnaround story for Bailey, but seriously...about 15 minutes of that episode is just us watching the crew watching the view screen.

:lol:
 
A nice turnaround story for Bailey, but seriously...about 15 minutes of that episode is just us watching the crew watching the view screen.
Hey! Where have I heard THAT before?

STTMP-Sulu-Bridge_6c0c164bd2b597ee32b68b8b5755bd2e.jpg
 
My wife and I watched The Corbomite Maneuver last night. She's been listening to Ron and Clint Howard's autobiography, and wanted to see it.

A nice turnaround story for Bailey, but seriously...about 15 minutes of that episode is just us watching the crew watching the view screen.

:lol:
I am disappointed that modern storytelling spends more time with characters talking about their feelings instead of staring at viewscreens. It's a great way to evoke the submarine in space vibe and I miss that.

I don't miss that life is soo harrrd for Tilly so much. I love Tilly but you're in Starfleet now. Shape up or ship out!
 
My wife and I watched The Corbomite Maneuver last night. She's been listening to Ron and Clint Howard's autobiography, and wanted to see it.

A nice turnaround story for Bailey, but seriously...about 15 minutes of that episode is just us watching the crew watching the view screen.

:lol:

And with no Goldsmith music this time. But McCoy does his best to spark up the proceedings. Nobody can chastise Kirky like McCoy.
 
I'm a mental health counselor. It's what I do :)
Aha! We need a lot more of you.

The issue with regard to drama is balance. Too much staring at the screen or too much social drama and you lose part of your audience. I wonder if the 10 episode format means that trying to give each of the principal characters some emotional drama means that we get a fair chunk every episode as opposed to more occasionally within 26 episodes.
 
Aha! We need a lot more of you.

The issue with regard to drama is balance. Too much staring at the screen or too much social drama and you lose part of your audience. I wonder if the 10 episode format means that trying to give each of the principal characters some emotional drama means that we get a fair chunk every episode as opposed to more occasionally within 26 episodes.
I think the parts that have also resonated with me (the ones that stand out in Star Trek) are those interpersonal ones. Balance of Terror and Kirk and McCoy's discussion prior to the attack. The acknowledgement of the loss of life, and the challenges of these different cultures and people and their values in the face of attack.

Kirk and Spock Prime in ST 2009 is one of the most emotionally gripping conversations for me.

To me, hearing about social drama draws me in faster than say the mysterious anomaly of the week. The reactions and humanity are interesting.
 
The connection the characters have to the event of the week need not be direct every time; the times it is a relative (e.g. Sam Kirk and family), the story will have greater impact that way.

Most stories ought to have the characters draw parallels between the current issue as we do - an allegory or similarity to our situation.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top