OK... first, the good:
I liked the interactions between Picard/ Riker and Picard/ (Riker)/ Seven.
The JL-Riker interaction is funny and slightly self-ironic. "Excellent recovery admiral!" - "Shut it, Will!"
"So long as we dont have to move or shoot well be fine."
Seven rocks! Loved how she threatened to throw them out an airlock. (It actually gave me fond Babylon 5 callback vibes, where Ivanova frequently threatened to do this to people.) But girl, don't blame Picard for your career change, it was your decision.
Captain Shaw. I already suspected he was a goner after the trailers. Now he's deadnaming Seven and being a general d-bag, so yeah, he's toast and good riddance. But I found him entertaining at the table, so he goes on the 'good' pile.
Loved that Laris/ Orla was back. Nice surprise.
Janeway name drop.
The not-so-good:
For me, it has the feel of a particularly tropey Trek movie. Which I'm sure many fans will love, so... No doubt our heroes will reunite to save their friend in peril and the universe, yadda yadda.
The worst offender of tropes, for me, would be if Bevs son (?) really was Picard's son, too. I don't care how they explain it, this plot belongs to soaps. We had foreshadowing in season 2 (Picard's speech about not having offspring), and in this episode, a big fat anvil: "I don't need a legacy!" And they probably chose an actor with a British accent for a reason. AND Picard hasn't spoken to her in 20 years... There's also a possibility that he is Bev's and another man's son. Even Jack Crusher's in a timey-wimey way. In any case, wouldn't Riker or other old friends know about him? Did she not see them for 20+ years either?
That said, I'm totally clinging to the hope that "son" is really a shapeshifting alien, the one who attacked Beverly, and who pretends to be her son as long as she's in stasis!
Hated they paired Laris up with Pic after all. I'm not a Pic/ Bev shipper, it just feels like a waste of her character and the actress to me and, let's be real, it won't last.
Sooo... Riker. I can't say I cared much about him and Troi as a couple during TNG, but I liked them a lot in Nepenthe. So ofc there's trouble in paradise. "Deanna and Kestra will eppreciate the time away from me." Oh-oh.
Is it a midlife crisis? "Galaxy class, young lady!" OK boomer. "Hello beautiful!" Seriously, are they going for "sleazy old dude" with him? Not everything on 90s tv was great!
Riker to Picard "Why did you cut everyone off?" He includes himself and Troi. Does he mean 20 years ago? Nepenthe didn't give me that impression, at least with Troi and Riker. Do they mean after season 2?
Some clunky exposition dialog, e.g. with Picard/ young LaForge and with Raffi/ handler. Speaking of which... warrior talk in Trek means Klingons. Is Worf her handler?
I do hope that other anvil will come true: "Youre gonna make it to cpt before you know it, Commander Hansen!"
I didn't hate it.