• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 2x03 - "Assimilation"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    168
So basically we'd get alternate universe Elnor who'd have to go through Starfleet Academy all over again. Great.

Our Elnor has only been through one year of the Acadamy, FYI

In the event that Elnor's "real" body is still alive, it may be possible that he does indeed survive, but it's also possible this would just be evil Elnor in real Elnor's body or something.

This is reminiscent of Chekov in Spectre of the Gun. He dies early and just pops back into place on the bridge at the end not realizing any extra time has passed.
 
I didn't notice. What scenes, specifically?
Many scenes when there were more than 2 people in the room. A couple that stuck in my mind:

When Rios held Raffi back (after Hubby had struck down Seven); when before leaving the Sirena, Seven talked to Picard... Actually, pretty much everyone with Picard...

Maybe I even see this when it shouldn't be the case; e.g. when Seven walked close to Raffi, almost but not quite comforting her...(I'd assume those two and the Elnor actor were in one bubble, but what do I know...)

I need to get this out of my head!
 
I honestly didn't notice this. But at the same time, I can never see the damn sailboat either, so I might be missing some cones and rods or something.
 
The whole logistics of this misadventure don't make sense. We don't even have any determination for what allowed these specific characters to retain their memories in the new timeline other than that they're real life regulars of the Picard tv show. It's not who was on the Stargazer as Raffi and Elnor weren't there, and it's not the Starfleet squadron otherwise the Confederation would have had an entire uprising of an army of people who remembered the Prime Timeline.

Furthermore, Q specifically mentioned that Picard's new body was also synth, and Seven's body has never had enhancements. That means that Elnor, Picard, Seven, weren't physically transported to the new timeline, but had their minds transplanted into the bodies of their evil counterparts. In the event that Elnor's "real" body is still alive, it may be possible that he does indeed survive, but it's also possible this would just be evil Elnor in real Elnor's body or something.

I just chalk it to Q magic. Q transported their minds into their alternate reality bodies and allowed them to keep their memories.
 
I just chalk it to Q magic. Q transported their minds into their alternate reality bodies and allowed them to keep their memories.
In the past Q always pulled punches and the only casualties were people Picard barely knew (like the piece of the Enterprise carved out during Q Who). Now Q is directly responsible for Elnor's death.
 
In the past Q always pulled punches and the only casualties were people Picard barely knew (like the piece of the Enterprise carved out during Q Who). Now Q is directly responsible for Elnor's death.
Q probably isn't well, remember episode 2.

The actor who plays Elnor hinted he'll be back
 
Solid episode, although not as epic as the last two (the bar is set way high by now!).

I liked that they went straight to the past and also how the borg queen took control to do it, I was a bit surprised to see 7’s “husband” die and also elnor (and 7 isn’t usually so sloppy…not knowing his full name? Really?!).

So they came out of the temporal manoeuvre (really like how they did it) and crash land straight on earth. Very unlikely, but I guess the queen copied Spock’s botched calculations from TVH!

I’m confused on where they landed: “home”? Picard crashed the ship in a vineyard in France or what?

The 21st century is colourful and funny, I like it.

7 is starting to like being “normal”, something that will be important later, no doubt.

I was surprised that Raffi got so angry at Picard. Not that she hasn’t a point, though, Picard could have killed Q when he was human if he had wanted to…something that would likely have caused more trouble than not doing it, so he really isn’t that guilty. Speaking of Q, what was he talking about?


Rios is, as many predicted, arrested by immigration. The building relationship with a woman from the past is REALLY cliche by now, after Kirk and Paris did it, but was competently executed and I like the actor (and also the child): as usual acting is top notch on this show.

The part about restarting the queen felt a bit filler, but the end was impressive. Also, she is the scariest queen Star Trek ever put on screen, I don’t understand how Picard kept giving her his back, nor why they still haven’t disconnected her from the ship: she is totally right saying that the more they wait the more she is likely to assimilate the ship. Also nice tribute to terminator both when she crawls towards Jurati and when seven and raffi materialise in LA.

Main complaint: I can’t wait another week for the continuation!

8.

By the way, someone gave a 1 to THIS?! I don’t want to meet this person.
 
I honestly didn't notice this. But at the same time, I can never see the damn sailboat either, so I might be missing some cones and rods or something.
It's a schooner.
Q probably isn't well, remember episode 2.

The actor who plays Elnor hinted he'll be back
In POG form like ALF?

Watch "Mallrats (1995) You Dumb Bastard" on YouTube
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Watch "ALF POGS" on YouTube
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Last edited:
(and 7 isn’t usually so sloppy…not knowing his full name? Really?!
She didn't have time to look it up. Her focus was trying to find the others.

I’m confused on where they landed: “home”? Picard crashed the ship in a vineyard in France or what?
The coordinates on his console point to a farm between Palmdale and LA.
But the actual crash in the episode looked like a forest, so the coordinates might just be an easter egg or something.

2Q.png

unknown.png
 
Last edited:
In the past Q always pulled punches and the only casualties were people Picard barely knew (like the piece of the Enterprise carved out during Q Who). Now Q is directly responsible for Elnor's death.

True but we know from episode 2 that Q means business this time. He made it clear to Picard that is not a fun game this time, he said Picard is doing penance. Q seems much more serious, deadly this time.
 
Hm there is a big building outside La Sirena's window that could be Chateau Picard, maybe he did crash them in France? That would explain the 'Home' line. Though that means La Sirena is able to beam people half way across the planet.

Also explain why it's night when they crash but day in LA.
2Q.png
 
The whole logistics of this misadventure don't make sense. We don't even have any determination for what allowed these specific characters to retain their memories in the new timeline other than that they're real life regulars of the Picard tv show. It's not who was on the Stargazer as Raffi and Elnor weren't there, and it's not the Starfleet squadron otherwise the Confederation would have had an entire uprising of an army of people who remembered the Prime Timeline.

Furthermore, Q specifically mentioned that Picard's new body was also synth, and Seven's body has never had enhancements. That means that Elnor, Picard, Seven, weren't physically transported to the new timeline, but had their minds transplanted into the bodies of their evil counterparts. In the event that Elnor's "real" body is still alive, it may be possible that he does indeed survive, but it's also possible this would just be evil Elnor in real Elnor's body or something.

That's a general problem with "Star Trek" and "serialisation". If you have a concept (space Wizard! Mirror universe! Time travel!), it's easier to pull a single, compelling story from it that makes sense and answers all questions.
(I really hope that turns out to be right by SNW:crazy:)

Once you have to stretch it out over multiple episodes, between multiple writers, and find many different conflicts withing the concept to fill several episodes, the cracks start to become easily more visible.

I think ENT Season 3 was so far the best one pulling a season long arc off - and they made it by just throwing so many different mysteries together at once (Who are the Xindi/Anomalies/spheres/future enterprise/trellium-D/Degra/sphere builders) that somehow all turned out to be connected in a plot that made mostly sense. And similarly, because of the large number, they were able to solve some mysteries early one, leave others hanging, and introduce even more later on. And then having all major questions answered basically 3/4 of the way, they had several(!) episodes to properly wrap all plot threads up. And they STILL didn't stick the landing (space Nazis!:lol:) and left since threads unanswered (why the first attack on earth?)

PIC season 2 is in the very comfortable position that - if anything doesn't make any sense? A wizard did it. A single-letter named wizard.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top