If I had to guess I'd say they're both Janet Kidder but the lighting and angle on the viewscreen shot are different.
Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 3x08 - "The Sanctuary"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
Forget the nose, the cheeks definitely look different.
I thought it was a different character for a short while after which I realized with astonishment that it was supposed to be the same person. Even the acting is not exactly the same.
Lighting aside, they definitely messed up keeping her hair consistent.
Lighting can do a number on how the same actor looks from one shot to the next.
You could be right. Of course it’s also possible that the Orion makeup job is just really bad. Not sure what happened to Disco’s makeup crew. I really liked what they did with the Tellarites and Andorians. The Orions just look really bad, plastic and fake.Has it already been pointed out that Osyraa appears to be played by two different women (or at least looks drastically different between scenes) in this episode? Or am I missing something?
Somehow, Enterprise has done the best Orion makeup.
It does say a lot when literally 1960s Orion makeup in the original series looks a lot better than here.
Did we see an Orion in TOS? O_o
Just the dancing girl from The Cage. I don't even think it was canonically established that she was an "Orion" until TAS.
Edit: Also the sidekick of Garth of Izar from Whom Gods Destroy.
Oh, right, thank you. I had forgotten that part.
In any case, my eyes must need adjusting since the Orions look fine to me...
Viridian is a blue-green pigment. Its a play on the fact that the chain is an alliance of blue and green aliens
A nice planetary adventure, but still nothing to write Kwejian about.
Things I enjoyed:
Things I enjoyed:
- The character bits between Michael and Book, Culber and Philippa, and the Two Gay Space Dads and Adira.
- That this was mostly a planetary adventure with little of The Burn arc, which by this point in the show I should care about but don't.
- Love, love that Michael is in a relationship with someone that makes her smile. She deserves happiness and I love how at ease she is with Book.
- Culber is an awesome doctor. I love that he doesn't take any shit. Of course, he's with Paul... so he's had some practice with obstenent personalities.
- Saru didn't give a motivational speech before the crew did anything. Although... why does every captain now need a "catchphrase"?
- I like all the Adira scenes. But wouldn't 23rd Century folks be used to non-binary pronouns?
- Tilly acting more like Saru's yeoman instead of his Number One. Why is she responsible for scheduling his appointments?
- The show trying to hard to convince us the Federation NEEDS to be brought back by making everything so black-and-white... i.e. the Chain is just evil, cause slaves and Rancoring people that fail them. Maybe it's because I question a message that says we should return to some mythical "golden age", especially in today's political climate. It's the same issue I had with the new Star Wars trilogy. I liked that TLJ asked the question of whether the Jedi and the Empire should even be brought back. Wish Disco did that more with the question of the Federation.
- I'm sick of the CW Superhero/Teen drama staging. Everyone just stands on their marks pontificating while the camera keeps moving. Give everyone some biz in these scenes. Make them exist in these spaces.
- Trek has moved on from bumpy foreheads and noses to shinny skin color.
Last edited:
That's because they probably are literally plastic: https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/janet-kidder-star-trek-discovery-osyraa-villain-green-skin
Kidder adds that unlike some of the Orions of the past — like Susan Oliver or Yvonne Craig in TOS, or Rachel Nichols in Star Trek 2009 — this isn't just green body paint. "That's a full prosthetic head," Kidder says. "It takes about four hours to put on!"
No wonder Osyraa looks so different between scenes. They were probably figuring things out. Maybe they wanted to spare actually painting the actress, but if it takes 4 hours to put it on that's not really an improvement. Kidder's natural beauty isn't coming across through that prosthetic head, and Orions are supposed to be very alluring.
For some reason with the exception of Romulans/Vulcans, Kurtzman Trek just loves to put everyone in a full-face silicone mask, rather than individual "bits" as is needed.
This is taking it to an absurd conclusion, as there was nothing on her face even outside the norm of human variation. I actually wonder if part of the reason she came across as so flat is because she couldn't emote properly through the mask. You need a top-notch actor like Doug Jones to pull it off.
And a conscientious film lab tech restores her natural skin color and wonders how she got so green in the first place...
Yeah I read that story.
Yeah, I'm reading that and looking at Vina's make up and thinking that looks more fake than Osyraa on some level.
It's not perfect but it still works.
That was one of my favourite episodes of Discovery.
Had a nice plot that could have been a stand alone Trek episode but also fit in nicely and the quieter moments were good and again showed that Discovery has a fine crew when given a bit of screen time.
The question of Adiras pronouns was wrapped up in a really nice and no fuss way and was as good a way as possible to do it.
I still dont like Georgiou but at least her scenes gave Culber some quality lines and everyone else had good parts and moments in the episode
AND best of all when the chips were down and the most dangerous alien in the galaxy needed defeating did the real hero of the U.S.S. Discovery step up
Had a nice plot that could have been a stand alone Trek episode but also fit in nicely and the quieter moments were good and again showed that Discovery has a fine crew when given a bit of screen time.
The question of Adiras pronouns was wrapped up in a really nice and no fuss way and was as good a way as possible to do it.
I still dont like Georgiou but at least her scenes gave Culber some quality lines and everyone else had good parts and moments in the episode
AND best of all when the chips were down and the most dangerous alien in the galaxy needed defeating did the real hero of the U.S.S. Discovery step up
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
