Discussion in 'Star Trek: Discovery' started by Commander Richard, Jan 21, 2018.
That last one was Nova Squadron, not Red Squad.
Yes, I'm giving DSC the time. Mainly, because it's such a fantastic show in itself. And there's plenty of time for it to come into its own Trek space in the future.
It's quite normal in modern day militaries for doctors to graduate at higher ranks. They are much higher qualified than the average graduate, need authority in their jobs, and also they have to have pay grades which are at least similar to what they could expect as a civilian doctor. We can argue elsewhere over whether the latter applies to Starfleet....
Yeah, the Lorca-orchestrated-it-all plotline explains Tilly and Landry as much as Stamets and Burnham. Lorca wanted the people he knew on the other side.
She's an engineering genius. I like to think precocious Cadet Killy developing some sort of undetectable transporter drone kit, and then using it to instantaneously kill 50 people above her one day.
MU Rhys: "What the hell is happening?!"
MU Killy: "I have no idea, but if you make me Captain, it will probably stop."
Young cadets like that are full of piss and vinegar anyway, all thinking they're completely invincible and acting like Audie Murphy with 'roid rage. Saw it in ROTC all the time back in the day. They're all looking to make their bones and be visible enough to command so that they have a better sponsor and MOS pick by the time they graduate and land their commission. In the situation of the Valiant, you add a "Lord of the Flies" scenario into an already toxic mix of youthful bravado and you wind up getting a baby silverback gorilla playing with a thermonuclear device. They were quite accurately portrayed, IMO.
Imagine Lorca's reaction when he expected Capt. Killy and got Tilly. Kind of a shame we didn't get to see that.
In his farewell speech to the crew he seemed proud of the work he'd done ramping them up. I think he took it as a challenge to get these wierd hippy-cult members into some kind of fighting shape.
A little late, but my take on "Vaulting Ambition" (for anyone still reading this thread :-) ). https://wp.me/p8wVHj-bp
But that was painfully stupid.
(Not that I have a problem with Tilly, they're probably not gonna make her captain for reals.)
That's Captain "Killy" to you!
I suffered no ill effects
Proof that Starfleet is run by idiots and we wonder why the Andorians and Tellarites stay away...
Separate names with a comma.