• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

ST XI issues you want tackled in the sequel

Mach5

Admiral
Admiral
I suppose there's already a thread like this... Anyway, I'm too lazy to look it up, sue me. :angel:

I for one would like ST XI to visit the new Vulcan colony, just to get an update on the rebuilding of Vulcan society. How Vulcans deal with this is definitely something to explore.

Another thing; I want to see the young Captain Kirk attacked for his age. There's a huge amount of weight on his shoulders now that he's become by far the youngest CO in Starfleet history. Just imagine the pressure he's under!

How about you, people?
 
The number of shots with lens flares. (Yes it is an issue.)

The lack of a studio interior set of the Enterprise' Engineering deck.
 
IF there are going to be any planets attacked ever again I want to actually see their defenses.
And they should be capable and good defenses too.

It would be also good to see what happens to the Vulcans and their new home.
Though I'm not sure how much time they can devote to that in a 2 hour movie and how satisfying it can be.
Surely books or a tv show (if there was one) could have more time and luxury to deal with that.

I wouldn't mind seeing them use some kind of effect for the shields.It doesn't have to be huge bubbles.

The issue of Gaila's fate should be addressed. :p
Rachel Nichols should return and with an improved paint job.
 
I hope they don't go with Khan, or anything else that's already been done. I just hope they present a compelling story worthy of the Star Trek mantle.
 
I agree about the engineering set. I would hope they come up with something a little more practical, and call it a refit of the ship.
 
I know this might lead to flames a'plenty, but I'd like Amanda restored.

At the end of the novelization, somehow Archer's missing dog materializes on the Enterprise.

We know Amanda was already dematerializing when the ground gave way under her. That's got to be worth SOMETHING.

Scotty could be shown working on something transporter related throughout the movie, now and then, and at the end he asks Spock to come to the transporter room. Amanda materializes, maybe with Spock helping on the controls, and that's that. Doesn't have to be the same actress, we don't have to see anything besides Spock possibly saying "Mother-", we just see her restored and assume she ends up back with Sarek.

Call me an old softie, but the lady Amanda must be restored. :)
 
Call me an old softie, but the lady Amanda must be restored. :)


Okay, you're an old softie. :)

Seriously, it would be a shame to undo Amanda's tragic demise. What's the point of shaking up the timeline if you're just going to put things back the way they were?
 
For the most part I love the cinematography in the movie, but Nero stabbing Robau, the bar fight, Nero and Kirk fighting in the finale...all of these are barely comprehensible. So, just better cinematography for the physical fights, please.
 
Call me an old softie, but the lady Amanda must be restored. :)


Okay, you're an old softie. :)

Seriously, it would be a shame to undo Amanda's tragic demise. What's the point of shaking up the timeline if you're just going to put things back the way they were?

JJ took both Amanda and Vulcan. Uh-uh. One or the other. He only gets to off one, and Amanda is the one it'd be easiest to restore.

Besides, who's gonna slap Spock for not helping his father during the Journey to Babel? :p
 
Cupcake.

I want to see Kirk punch that piece of cheese in the chops. Really fracking hard.

Then take him out for a few drinks and a bit of tail chasing on Argelius II.
 
For the most part I love the cinematography in the movie, but Nero stabbing Robau, the bar fight, Nero and Kirk fighting in the finale...all of these are barely comprehensible. So, just better cinematography for the physical fights, please.


I agree.:techman:
 
I doubt the Vulcans will get much screen time. The upshot of the disaster will be to push Spock on a darker path than Prime Timeline Spock. (I am convinced that Spock's plotline is the reason why the writers blew up poor old Vulcan.)

There will be much angst, because we all love angst and stuff. Uhura will have her hands full with an angry repressed nutjob half-alien time bomb. Maybe she shoulda gone for Kirk after all. Then again, she looks like a gal who's up for a challenge. :rommie:

My main wish for the Abramsverse is for the Romulans to finally get the development they've needed for a long long time. Trek XI didn't do it and the next movie probably will be about anything but Rommies (except as a minor plotline to carry along the Spock-time-bomb subplot.)
I would like to see how they deal with the Obvious Jealousy some Officers will have about Kirk
Starfleet isn't that petty. Sure, it's unrealistic that they wouldn't be petty, but it's the Trek Way to depict Starfleet as a shining paragon of wisdom and goodness (leaving aside the odd insane admiral) that could never exist in the real world. This is science fiction after all, we don't always have to be believable.

At the end of the novelization, somehow Archer's missing dog materializes on the Enterprise.

Oh wow, good thing they left it out of the movie.

It would be cute to have some passing reference, even if it's just a glimpse of a beagle in the rec room playing catch with Chekov. Something subtle, just for eagle eyed fans.
Seriously, it would be a shame to undo Amanda's tragic demise. What's the point of shaking up the timeline if you're just going to put things back the way they were?
Agreed. Amanda stays dead. They killed her and blew up Vulcan so we can have Super Angst Spock. Unlike Quinto's bosses on Heroes, I have a feeling the Trek writers actually have a reason for the stuff they write other than random whim, and I'm interested to see where this all goes.

And I second (third?) the votes for bringing back Gaila and Cupcake.
 
Kirk's accomplishments came fairly effortlessly in XI. I'd like to see him put through the ringer in XII.
 
Kirk's accomplishments came fairly effortlessly in XI.

:confused:

Effortlessly ?
He got his ass kicked several times even by Spock, got thrown of the ship and almost got eaten by 2 monsters, jumped from space and had to parachute and land into a platform in the air, had to fight Romulans on it to the death.
Jumped after Sulu and barely managed to beam on the E before going splat, got into a phaser fight in a ship full of Romulans etc etc etc

Come on :p
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top