BillJ was the one who was annoyed, not me. Like I said --twice -- it doesn't bother me.
ST:TMP on Blu-Ray - a second look
- Thread starter Procutus
- Start date
BillJ was the one who was annoyed, not me. Like I said --twice -- it doesn't bother me.
That, and the one shuttle carrying Winona that clearly isn't holding more than 7. so that's about +1 more person to every other shuttle. Freaking hogger.
Two possible explanations that come to mind:
And while legends do grow over time, I wouldn't expect Pike, who'd written a paper on the incident, to get the number wrong unless he did so deliberately to drive home a point to the younger Kirk.
Still, 800 saved seems awfully improbable after the pounding we'd just seen the ship take. I'd be surprised if more than a fraction of the crew made it off before she impacted with the Narada.
- There are groups of shuttles fleeing in more directions than just to the right of frame in that long shot
- The number actually saved by George Kirk has been exaggerated
And while legends do grow over time, I wouldn't expect Pike, who'd written a paper on the incident, to get the number wrong unless he did so deliberately to drive home a point to the younger Kirk.
Still, 800 saved seems awfully improbable after the pounding we'd just seen the ship take. I'd be surprised if more than a fraction of the crew made it off before she impacted with the Narada.
Voted for The Director's Edition. Although the Blu ray theatrical is certainly spectacular quality. I too hope my prefered version is upgraded in the not-too distant future. I prefer the fixes like the Vulcan planet surface, Spock's weeping, Scotty preparing the self-destruct and the walk from the Enterprise's hull to V'Ger at the end. I wish more of the Memory Wall sequence existed, with space suited Kirk & Spock, as that would be sweet.
Don't be. If it's not one thing, it's another.
The memory wall was dull on the page and supposedly duller on screen. I think they made the correct decision to make it just a rocket-ride from Spock's POV. Kirk's being there doesn't add anything.
And if you wanna see Kirk being attacked by tiny pyramids, when he is at the Memory Wall, check out the official comic adaptation.
Thanks
Just didn't think it could steer the thread that far off course!Just the name of this thread makes me long for a 1080p DE.
I would like that too, if they could make the new FX in HD, but I don't think they'll go to that extent. Still, it's nice to dream.
I'm wonder why Paramount didn't transfer The Director's Edition to Blu-Ray?
For me it "sounded" and "felt" real and gets your attention. The new beep beep beep does not have the same impact and to me screams cheap. The new klaxon also makes me cringe because it has more of a campy sound to it. But that is my take on it.
It would have been interesting if the scene had been filmed. But what was on the screen was just fine.
Do you mean include it with the Blu-Ray, or why they didn't use it as the release version? If the former: I dunno. If the latter: the new VFX were only rendered at DVD resolution and not in HD.
It was filmed. There are photos of Kirk with the pyramids all over him.
Here's one (you may have to cut and paste the URL to get it to work): http://forgottentrek.ottens.co.uk/images/TMP/MW009.jpg
I once bought a set of TMP contact proofs in a charity auction. One whole page has little b/w stills of Kirk and Spock hoisted over the Memory Wall, and Kirk covered in tiny pyramids.
Don't forget this thread:
http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?p=2636670#post2636670
Still patiently waiting...
http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?p=2636670#post2636670
Still patiently waiting...
Ah, now that's cool news!
Similar threads
