Do you really think that's going to change given the lack of turn-over in the writing staff and the way things are going on DISCO? I'm not hopeful.
Neither am I. They had their chance to do so with Season 4... and thus far, I'm not impressed.
We're both disappointed with reality.
Reality is often disappointing... what saddens me is that Disco has a 'team' of writers who apparently know their Trek inside and out... and STILL decided of not just repeating the mistakes of old series, but exacerbating them in the process.
Here's a transcript of the scene about the tether that I made:
Burnham:
- Yes, which is why you'll be going as a holo
Stamets:
- Oh. Well, in that case...
Burnham:
- Your body will be right here on Discovery the entire time
Stamets:
- The anomaly creates enormous distortions.
- We might not be able to maintain a holo signal.
Burnham:
- Right, which is why we'll be using a tether to help Book's ship maintain proximity to Discovery
- And, if we have to, we will use it to pull him out.
- <Facing Culber> And I want you on the bridge, listening in on comms
- Let me know if you have any reason for concern.
Culber:
- Yes, Captain.
You mis-remembered the scene. The tether is only used to make sure Book's ship maintains proximity to Discovery so that their Holo-graphic Signal is within good proximity range given the distortion's disturbance to subspace radio.
Basically they wanted to be within good WiFi range and the Tether was there to gurantee that incase the worst case scenario happened.
Or that they wanted to deliver the data in-tact to discovery without SubSpace WiFi in a murky environment jamming and muddling up the signal.
What's more reliable than sending in data going through heavy SubSpace Radio interference?
Deliver the data in person and transfer it directly from Storage Drive onto the parent vessel to disseminate to the rest of the folks who needs it.
No need to send corruptable data over Wireless if you can avoid it. Especially given how many times we see Stamets Holo Projection fritz out.
Given how important the sensor data is, you want every bit to be as accurate as possible.
Not corrupted because you send the data over WiFi in a spotty area.
There's a reason why Sneaker-Net is still useful for critical data.
Huh... thanks for the reminder.
Then I would say that kinda shoots down the idea they used HyperSubspace communications for the holo presence.
By its very nature, HyperSubspace needs to be much more powerful (and reliable) at extremely small distances than regular subspace (in the 24th century at least)... but again, its interesting how Stamets holo was able to maintain connection and verbal communications were still possible... but somehow, sending a copy of the sensor data to Disco was impossible.
Send out 1 copy of the data while STILL trying to get out. That way, if the wifi copy fails... the original is still on its way out.
24th century still sent out sensor data using Wifi under extreme circumstances... with no corruption I might add. Sure, instances were encountered where data could be corrupted if you sent it over massive distances... but its been over 800 years since then.
This would then imply SF made 0 progress in improving overall technology and signal strength.
Also, don't forget that Book's ship is private property and not StarFleet standard issue. There might be Hardware/Software compatibility issues with his Sensor Data or other aspects of his sensors that prevent him from sending all that volume of data over WiFi.
In the world of Aviation, proprietary hardware is quite common. Not every piece of kit works with every other manufacturers piece of kit perfectly. There's no guranteed common standard in many aspects of Aviation Hardware.
There are some standards, but not everything is guranteed to work with other makers devices.
This is sensible, but again, with Book and his ship being a part of Disco now for a while now (over 5 months), you'd think they would have improved on any hw incompatibilities.
Also, I'm curious to see where he got that ship of his... it certainly seems more advanced than most ships we saw.
You're expecting too much out of the DISCO writing staff.
Eh... that could be it.
What was once "Hyper Subspace" in the 24th century, just might be the standard SubSpace communication and the term "Hyper" has been dropped.
I certainly wouldn't object, but nothing was mentioned one way or another... so, I would have to assume that regular subspace is what they're using.
Let the DISCO writers do their thing in explaining why they can't figure things out.
Which they probably won't do.
The setting feels more like a parallel world then a direct lineage from Berman-era Trek.
Yes, and still nowhere near what 810 years (not counting the 120 years of Burn) of technological and scientific evolution might actually look like in Trek for preexisting technologically evolved spacefaring civilizations.
Regardless of how you cut it... the technology the 32nd century employs is far closer to what mid/late 25th century would have.
It would certainly be interesting if it turned out they went to a parallel world through that Wormhole or into a science experiment of some kind where the crew doesn't ask too many questions about advanced technology (because lets face it... from their POV, even the late 24th/25th century would look extremely advanced to them).
And there's not that many StarShips left.
The numbers seemed small yes, but sparing 10 to 20 people would likely NOT be an issue.
Vance may not be the best Admiral you know. Especially given a staffing shortage.
He seemed to be quite capable... just a bit... jaded and in defensive mode at first.
You give the writers TOO much credit to expect them to think through all these basic world building elements.
I guess I am when you factor in the premise that Earth at the moment has nearly 8 billion people... and that each and every UFP member world would (even post Burn) at least have similar numbers (albeit obviously living in a sustainable capacity with minimal environmental impact).
That's at least 304 billion people to work with. Even if we assume that just 1% of those populations would want to join Starfleet to help keep the UFP together... that's 3.04 million people.
That took under a minute with a calculator btw.
I concur, DISCO should've gotten a few 32nd Century natives to integrate into their crew.
Yup
They might not have been "In Trouble", but they might still be busy doing milk runs.
With how many people aboard... I sincerely doubt they wouldn't have the time to study modern technology and science in detail.
The amount of people needing to transport dilithium from a mining ship or two near that nebula onto Disco would be what... 1?
Then you need Stamets or Booker to use the spore Drive to get to various worlds and deliver the dilithium in question... again, most of the crew would be free to study.