• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

SPOILER ALERT -- Review Myriad Universes: Infinity's Prism

Yo, hardcore Voyager fan here. I just finished "Places of Exile." I agree with you that it was overall interesting, but I didn't care for this version of Annika. Erin and Magnus Hanson were bold explorers and scientists, and there's no reason their daughter would be such a shrinking violet even if she'd never been assimilated at all.

Personality traits aren't strictly a matter of genetics. Anyway, it's been a while, but I presume I extrapolated my version of Annika from how she was portrayed in "Unimatrix Zero." The person she was in there had led a sheltered and cozy life; I don't see where the "grim and tragic" comes in, unless it's from having that fantasy stripped away.


I also didn't like how Harry didn't seem to give a crap about much of anything. Of all people, Harry should be the most devastated by Voyager being forced to give up the quest home, and SPOILER his best friend's death.

I'm sure he was hit hard, but he's also the type who'd likely bounce back from it fairly easily. The story suffered somewhat from being so compressed; I had to skip over a lot of time in between segments of the book, and that's when Harry would've done his grieving.


The epilogue was also rather icky, in the way that some "Harry Potter" fans think Book 7's epilogue was.

No idea what you mean by that.


That said, the Doctor, B'Elanna, and oddly enough Kes were well done, and took some interesting turns. (Until Kes crossed right back through the Mary Sue threshold in the epilogue.)

My portrayal of Kes was based on the show's own portrayal of the potential she had within her. My goal was to develop the plot and character threads that the show hinted at but left unfulfilled or abandoned outright. Voyager only allowed Kes to ascend to her full potential in order to write her out of the show; I wanted to explore what she could have become if she had stayed.

Anyone else want to see the B'Elanna of this timeline meet the Tom Paris of "Before and After?" What would a Miral Paris born from two different universes be like? I see some potential for a cool sci-fi story here.

If the same two parents procreated at a different time and under different circumstances, there's no way the exact same gametes would combine, so whatever child they had would not have been Miral, at least not the same one. And this timeline's B'Elanna would never have reconciled with her mother Miral and thus wouldn't have wanted to use that name for her daughter.


Yeah, I was also disappointed that Kes returned to Neelix. The justification was believable enough, but for such a different timeline I wanted to see her with someone new.

I considered that, but ultimately it made sense to me to bring Kes and Neelix back together, in a context where the relationship was more earned and was the choice of a more mature, experienced Kes, rather than an adolescent falling for the first guy who showed her any kindness in the outside world.
 
Personality traits aren't strictly a matter of genetics. Anyway, it's been a while, but I presume I extrapolated my version of Annika from how she was portrayed in "Unimatrix Zero." The person she was in there had led a sheltered and cozy life; I don't see where the "grim and tragic" comes in, unless it's from having that fantasy stripped away.




I'm sure he was hit hard, but he's also the type who'd likely bounce back from it fairly easily. The story suffered somewhat from being so compressed; I had to skip over a lot of time in between segments of the book, and that's when Harry would've done his grieving.




No idea what you mean by that.




My portrayal of Kes was based on the show's own portrayal of the potential she had within her. My goal was to develop the plot and character threads that the show hinted at but left unfulfilled or abandoned outright. Voyager only allowed Kes to ascend to her full potential in order to write her out of the show; I wanted to explore what she could have become if she had stayed.



If the same two parents procreated at a different time and under different circumstances, there's no way the exact same gametes would combine, so whatever child they had would not have been Miral, at least not the same one. And this timeline's B'Elanna would never have reconciled with her mother Miral and thus wouldn't have wanted to use that name for her daughter.




I considered that, but ultimately it made sense to me to bring Kes and Neelix back together, in a context where the relationship was more earned and was the choice of a more mature, experienced Kes, rather than an adolescent falling for the first guy who showed her any kindness in the outside world.

Well this is awkward! I overall liked your story though. Definitely one of the better "Star Trek" stories I've read.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top