• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Smallville#8-11: "Legion" Discuss/Grade <SPOILERS>

Grade


  • Total voters
    52
^ I must've missed that but yeah I'm realizing that the stand in must be him. Also does anyone think that Chloe actually remembers Clark being an alien or was she talking about something else? She didn't actually say it when he asked her.
 
^ I must've missed that but yeah I'm realizing that the stand in must be him. Also does anyone think that Chloe actually remembers Clark being an alien or was she talking about something else? She didn't actually say it when he asked her.
I actually noticed how vague her statements were, and I think it's cool we have no idea. But in general I think it's safe to assume that this is just a Voyager-style reset and Clark can just mull over in private what an ass he was to play god with her head.
 
Also does anyone think that Chloe actually remembers Clark being an alien or was she talking about something else? She didn't actually say it when he asked her.

Well she said
" Are we talking about your secret ? What in the world would make me forget that ? It would take a lot more than Brainiac to wipe that from my brain "

I don't see what else she would be talking about. I think it's safe to assume that Chloe is back to remembering everything, thank god.
 
The way she said that though sounded kind of vauge and even Clark's reaction to her statement seemed unsure at best. I'm not sure that this plot has been resolved yet. I would like to think that it has been since I wasn't a fan of the memory wipe in the first place. I understand what Clark was trying to achieve but it's better that Chloe knows who he is. Also just to be snide with you...the Jor-El simulcrum IS a lot more than Brainiac, although Brainiac did say as well that Clark's father was gone, offline as it were. I wonder if they'll touch on this later since Doomsday has emerged from the crysalis.
 
I wonder what's the deal with Doomsday/Davis now.
After all he didn't stay as long as he was supposed to inside the chrysalis, did he ? Brainiac's deactivation released him early.

Maybe because of his early release he can now turn from Davis to Doomsday and back at will, instead of having permanently the monster look ?
 
^
So then why a Superman fan? He his the ultimate white hat of the 20th century. That's how he's always been and always will be.

Comic books are the mythological fairy tales of this era. All comic book heroes (Yes, even the Marvel ones.) are "white hats." Except, Supes reigns supreme and is at the very top of that list.

He is the quintessential do-gooder and beacon of light and hope. There is no middle ground or shades of gray with him. Every other comic hero, from Bats to Manhunter to Captain America to Spidey, has some wiggle room, but not Superman. He is the truest of the true.

And, anytime someone has tried to change that, it's been recieved very negitivly. People like him just the way he is. He is a pillar of hope, not just in his fictional universe, but in the real one as well. People like that.

People like that, while it is true things never go "your way" and decisions have "repurcussions," they don't for Superman. In the end he always finds a way to do the right thing. That's what makes him Superman and that's why he brings hope.

That was the point of the Superman movie, and that was the point of the episode. And, as I said, it was one of the few things it got right.

Because when I was a kid I was a Supes fan and I did liek that aspect of him. But I'm not a kid anymore so, while I am still a fan and still have my "geek out" moments from my youth and comic appreciation even for stuff I'm not overly familiar with like The Legion, I also don't have the same tastes and expectations I did when I was a kid.

And it's NOT true that Superman always wins in the end. At leats not in this show. There have been times on this how where he hasn't. Alicia, who is easily one of my favorite guest characters, certainly wasn't saved by him and is a perfect example.
 
He's not Superman yet.

This is the story of him becoming Superman. "Legion" was a milestone for him, where he finally came out and acted as the man he will become, not the boy he was.
 
Someone has to kill Chloe and inspire Clark to fly. Why not a Kryptonian death machine?

Maybe Doomsday can do the King Kong routine.
Take Chloe at the top of the Daily Planet building and while Clark is up there too he somehow drops her.
If that doesn't inspire Clark to fly and save her, nothing will.:p
 
Well I keep thinking that Chloe either a) Just becomes known as Chloe Olsen and leaves Metropolis after divorcing Jimmy and sorta doesn't stick around for the 'Superman' era. b) Has a falling out with Clark after he starts dating Lois. c) She goes to the 31st Century d) she gets stuck in the Bottle City of Kandor.

Or... they retcon her into the Superman mythology and be done with it! I like Chloe more than Lois honestly.


Or she gets so pissed at Clark for wiping her memories she tries to destroy him an gets killed in the process and Clark never mentions her again thus being lost in the telling of supes history....
 
He's not Superman yet.

This is the story of him becoming Superman. "Legion" was a milestone for him, where he finally came out and acted as the man he will become, not the boy he was.


Problem is, even the man he is to become isn't perfect. While he may have godlike powers he's not a god and thus is fallible.
 
Sorry I missed the discussion but had to work.:p Just gotta say I loved it. Chloe's memory is back (as expected), the LEGION was pretty cool, and Davis is now all Doomsday all the time. Next week looks to be fun hope to see you all then.

P.S. Best season ever!!!
 
Whoa, hey guys, I absolutely did not know a new episode was coming on and missed it, Proc just informed me about it. I'll get caught up though and then leave my opinions on it here.
 
I'm giving this an average.

For one thing, I need to stop watching it after Battlestar Galactica. Chloe's new look was interesting.
 
I'm giving this an average.

For one thing, I need to stop watching it after Battlestar Galactica. Chloe's new look was interesting.

My opinion of your opinion just dropped by about four notches. BSG put me straight to sleep last night, while Smallville had me cheering out loud several times during the episode.

I know, "big deal". Like my opinion matters to you.

But "Average"? C'mon. Just the way they did the Legion rings made this an above average episode alone. And the magnificent Chloe as Brainiac pushed it to Super. And all the rest was an awesome cherry on the top.

This was an awesome adaptation of the classic first meeting of Kal-El and the original three members of the Legion. Anyone who says different needs their heads examined IMO.
 
^You are right, your opinion of me doesn't really make much difference to me.

Battlestar Galactica is vastly superior to this show in every way imaginable. This episode was average.
 
^You are right, your opinion of me doesn't really make much difference to me.

Battlestar Galactica is vastly superior to this show in every way imaginable. This episode was average.
:rolleyes:

Battlestar Galactica is the most overrated piece of crap ever conceived.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top