• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Season 2 - DVD 2

SFRabid

Commodore
Commodore
I'm watching ENT again. Finished Season 2 DVD 1 last night. I just popped in S2D2 and sat down to watch when I noticed the lineup.

030 - A Night In Sickbay
032 - Marauders
033 - The Seventh
034 - The Communicator

Then I started to wonder, is this the worst DVD of Enterprise, or even the worst DVD of all Star Trek? I'm a big ENT fan but this will be hard to get through. :vulcan:
 
Watching deleted scenes of "A Night in Sickbay" now. I am so glad they deleted the scene where Archer calls Trip into sickbay in the middle of the night and then ask him how long it has been since he has been intimate with a woman. You could tell Bakula could barely get the line out from between his clinched teeth. They both spoke lines very softly and looked like "how did we get stuck with dialog this bad". Archer then apologises and starts talking about a faulty injector.
 
I remember liking The Seventh, but that was ages ago. I'm almost there so I'll probably be watching that disc next week.
 
I liked the The Seventh but I think it could have done with being a double episode. It was a bit rushed. It did add some Vulcan information to our database though :)
 
Well, at least they put them all on the same disc so you don't have to worry about skipping an episode here and there. :techman:
 
That would be a tough disc to get through. Although Marauders and The Communicator are enjoyable episodes.
 
Bruce Davison in "The Seventh" is fantastic as Menos. I love the idea of undercover Vulcan agents going rogue too. I'd like to hear the whole Menos story, why he made the choices he did.
 
I liked The Seventh but I remember it doing very badly in a poll here. Marauders is okay for me but the Klingons would have blasted that camp to bits form space before leaving. The Communicator was hard for me becase it was too close to those of TOS episodes where other worlds are just like 1940's Earth.

ANIS... The only thing worse in Enterprise is the episode which shall not be named. :censored:
 
C'mon, they can't be all bad...

"A Night in Sickbay" has Porthos (me love Porthos)

"Marauders" has T'Pol in her white catsuit and the boys in their desert suits :drool:

"The Seventh" has Travis! with dialogue! and Bruce Davison, and cool moody cinematography

"The Communicator" has Reed doing more than usual

Personally, I think they have more going for them than this, but that's just me... ;)
 
We have a win.... uh, LOSER! That does indeed appear to be the worst ENT DVD of all. Even the last disc bearing This Ain't The Valentine is elevated by Terra Prime.


A Night in Sickbay:
We were finally! seeing Archer behave like a grown-up (Shockwave, Minefield and Dead Stop) when this disaster came along and set him back 40 years. Petulant, whiny, crabby -- right back where we were in Broken Bow (except now we have Phlox manipulating him into developing a sexual fixation on his first officer's boobs). Thank you, Bermaga. :rolleyes:

Marauders:
You know what we needed here? We needed Trip to ask Archer if he had ever seen "The Magnificent Seven" or "The Seven Samuri." It would have made swallowing Archer's plan palatable. And I think it would have been even more credible if the crew hadn't lucked out by coming across the galaxy's only wussy Klingons.

The Seventh:
With all the crap TIIC threw at T'Pol throughout the series -- The Decon Scene, Fusion, The Boob Plunge, sexual inuendos in ANIS, possessed Malcolm coming on to her in her quarters while she's in her two-sizes-too-small PJs, her two-sizes-too-small PJs, topless neuropressure (I don't care who it was with), Bounty, assault by Rajiin, close-call sale into sexual slavery in Borderland -- I have to say, seeing her lean on Archer for moral support during a difficult mission is a walk in the park. A boring walk in the park, but nowhere near as offensive as the aforementioned scenes.

The Communicator:
1. Malcolm leaves his cellphone on a planet.
2. Archer decides they have to go back and get it so the natives won't try to develop cellphone technology.
3. He and Malcolm wisely decide to bring phasers and more communicators with them, never imagining that the natives may not be technologically advanced, but they are paranoid.
4. They get captured.
5. They don't want to scare the natives by admitting they're from another planet, so they tell the natives they are indestructible enemy super-soldiers!
6. Meanwhile, T'Pol -- who is committed to not interfering in the development of a less-advanced species -- has Trip and Travis work on getting the cloak to work on the Suliban cell-ship they acquired. She doesn't want to scare the natives by showing up in a shuttlepod. Because people armed with phasers popping out of an invisible ship is less scary.
7. T'Pol -- ironically -- congratulates Archer on being willing to die -- and take Malcolm with him -- to avoid contamination of a technologically less-advanced species. Is she kidding?!
 
Last edited:
Never noticed it before, but you may be on to something there. On a show that for me has very few weak episodes, that's about as weak a 4 ep run as there may be.

A Night In Sickbay (3/10)
Marauders (5/10)
The Seventh (7/10)
The Communicator (7/10)

A Night in Sickbay
was such a huge disappointment because I had so quickly become a huge Phlox fan, so when I saw that title, I assumed the episode was going to be awesome. It wasn't.

I thought the last two eps were pretty good, but 7/10 is on the low side for a show that got tons of 8's, 9's, and 10's from me.
 
Gah, I must confess that the more times I watch ENT the more I like well.. everything. Except the TNG episode. I had no idea The Seventh was in the sucks list. I thought it was very atmospheric and packed full of T'Pol history (Secret Agent, awesome), Vulcan political/social implications, mystery (tell me more about Menos treklit!)..the Archer and T'Pol bond is great to see too.

Once again we see what a flawed Vulcan T'Pol is, despite undergoing no doubt intense training with to become an agent she still can't handle having killed someone. She needs the Fullara ritual to keep from falling apart.

As to the others..

ANIS--take out the Archer storyline and show more Phlox grooming and it would be cool.

Marauders--it's okay, though we needed an explanation as to why the Klingons didn't level the place after they left.

The Communicator--bit of a camp romp, could have done with actual Nazis to achieve classic status. Great Reed ep!
 
The only one I'd skip over (and always do) is Marauders. Each of the rest has some wonderful scenes.
 
I dunno, disk 3 of the DVDs for DS9 Season 2 (Second Sight, Sanctuary, Rivals, The Alternate) is pretty tough to beat as weak DVDs go.
 
Well, the next DVD in the series has Precious Cargo so I guess things are looking up. :rommie:

I'm pretty sure we see Trip in his blue undies in that one..

Yes we do. And a strip tease as well...

sexy5.gif


OMG, just check out those abs!!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top