• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sci Fi TV Recommendations

I've looked at things about it before. It seems to mostly be about drama, and I don't really care to see a show about adult Hogwarts but with angsty drama. It also apparently threw in all the "adult" stuff they could get away with on a basic cable show, and I hate that kind of thing when its done just to be done. Basically, it seems more like an angsty drama show for an older demographic that just has some fantasy elements, and angsty drama, in any form, is a huge negative for me.

The fantasy stuff is a huge part of the show, with the personal stuff a close secondary. The main focus of the story is the fantasy stuff, and the personal stuff does tend to tie into it quite a bit. If you want a show without personal stuff you're going to be very limited in what you can watch, since most shows have a lot of personal story lines.
As for the adult stuff, a lot of it is pretty important to the story, so I wouldn't say that's it's there just to be there.

Well, like I said, the reviews all make the show seem like something not worth my time, and I don't like the idea of a fantasy world that's actually just post apocalyptic Earth anyway/
Understandable, I just wasn't sure how much you really knew about it.


Its a CW show about the lame kind of vampire that's popular nowadays, which I don't like. Looking at the the wikipedia description, its also focused on the kind of drama I hate. I should point out that I don't like normal CW shows anyway. Outside of the DC Superhero shows, I really dislike the stuff CW puts out, and this looks like a standard CW drama but with irritating vampires. So, exactly like TVD. Its not something I'd ever be willing to watch.
So what kind of Vampire's do you like? Pretty much all of the Vampire stories I know of have these kinds of Vampires. They're not really that different from the Buffy/Angel Vampires which I think you said you like.
I'm still not sure what to make of the whole "drama I don't like" thing What kind of drama do you like?
I watched a few episodes of Being Human, it had a few ok ideas but was mostly just the vampire/supernatural drama I already mentioned I don't like. If it was just the werewolf and the ghost and had a bit less drama it might have been alright. Haven is listed as a fantasy but was too "Stephen King-y" for me. Supernatural has one good main character, one whiny one and bad writing. Hercules The Legendary Journeys was watchable but not very impressive. When I was young and didn't have a way to watch anything that wasn't on TV I ended up watching all of Charmed because it was on before I went to school, but it was definitely not a good show. I got about 10 minutes into Once Upon a Time but the premise of the show (a woman follows a kid she gave up to a town and finds out she's a disney princess) just felt like a badly done rip off of the comic Fables, a comic I enjoy. Finally, when I was a kid I watched Sabrina the Teenaged Witch a lot, but that's not so much a good show as it is a show I have nostalgia for (and haven't seen in years).

That's all I can think of off the top of my head, and is probably mostly complete (although it only covers live action stuff, obviously).



Oh, yeah, I get it. I'm not against recommendations, I just know my tastes in fantasy are even more picky then sci fi so it felt pointless to mention it.
I like or love pretty everything there you said you don't like. The only one there I haven't seen is Haven.
Just out of curiosity, which Being Human did you watch?
I'm starting to think maybe I should just try to find should I think I'd hate, and try recommending those.
 
The fantasy stuff is a huge part of the show, with the personal stuff a close secondary. The main focus of the story is the fantasy stuff, and the personal stuff does tend to tie into it quite a bit. If you want a show without personal stuff you're going to be very limited in what you can watch, since most shows have a lot of personal story lines.
As for the adult stuff, a lot of it is pretty important to the story, so I wouldn't say that's it's there just to be there.

There is a difference between personal stuff and drama. I'm talking more about soap opera-ish drama ("Oh no, my secret love is sleeping with my sister instead of me") or angsty drama ("Life is uncertainty and pain and I don't know what to do"). As for the adult stuff, to be fair I don't think there is ever too much of a reason for it. Fake sex scenes and similar stuff are never needed, and to be fair that's part of the drama I dislike. not that good shows don't sometimes have that, but its never a huge part of shows I like. Actually, its usually part of bad episodes of good shows (like when a magic house made Buffy and Idiot Soldier Boy have sex, or the times Star Trek did anything attempting to be "sexy" :barf: ).


So what kind of Vampire's do you like? Pretty much all of the Vampire stories I know of have these kinds of Vampires. They're not really that different from the Buffy/Angel Vampires which I think you said you like.

They're really nothing like Buffy and Angel. At least when Angel brooded it was because of his situation and his past, not relationship drama or the kind of stuff you see in TVD/Twilight/Being Human/etc. I think it helped that Angel wasn't fighting "the beast within". He had a soul so, except for a few situations, having to fight his "hunger" or beast like stuff was never an issue for him. Outside of relationship drama and generally just being annoying, modern vampires fighting or giving into their monstrous qualities is another annoying part of vampire stories.

I don't care if Vampire A is trying not to eat humans while Vampires B and C are fighting for territory. There is a lot of vampire politics drama in modern vampire stories, which seems pretty bizarre (even Being Human, which was supposed to be about a vampire, werewolf and ghost, had a bunch of vampire specific drama which is what made me only watcha few episodes). That's just the vampire specific drama, those shows tend to have more standard relationship drama on top of that.

On the other hand, I do care about a vampire with a soul trying to save people while dealing with supernatural threats.

I'm still not sure what to make of the whole "drama I don't like" thing What kind of drama do you like?

Its hard to describe. I don't want love triangles or stuff like that. Basically, I don't want relationship drama to be a big part of the show. It wasn't for Buffy or Angel, although I consider this a requirement for any genre. The problems on a show should come from a situation or enemy, not someone's love life or personal problems with another main character. I mean, even that is a bad way of describing what I mean. Technically Angel's fights with Darla is both a personal problem and a love life based drama. But, its still a lot different then what you get in modern stuff.

I like or love pretty everything there you said you don't like. The only one there I haven't seen is Haven.
Just out of curiosity, which Being Human did you watch?

I watched the american version. I'm aware of the British version, but I'm pretty sure my problem with the US version would also be part of the UK version.
 
There is a difference between personal stuff and drama. I'm talking more about soap opera-ish drama ("Oh no, my secret love is sleeping with my sister instead of me") or angsty drama ("Life is uncertainty and pain and I don't know what to do").
I see what you're talking, but it's hard to come up with shows that don't have any of that kind of stuff in them. I think you kind of need at least a little bit of that to help invest in the characters and their relationships. I admit some shows do go overboard with this stuff sometimes though. If there's enough other good stuff, I can deal with it though, which I did with GOT and Spartacus.
As for the adult stuff, to be fair I don't think there is ever too much of a reason for it. Fake sex scenes and similar stuff are never needed, and to be fair that's part of the drama I dislike. not that good shows don't sometimes have that, but its never a huge part of shows
I guess I can see that. The only time I'm really bothered by it is in shows like Game of Thrones or Spartacus, or comic books like Saga that are just unnecessarily overly graphic.
Actually, its usually part of bad episodes of good shows (like when a magic house made Buffy and Idiot Soldier Boy have sex, or the times Star Trek did anything attempting to be "sexy" :barf: ).
OK, I actually do agree with you here.




They're really nothing like Buffy and Angel. At least when Angel brooded it was because of his situation and his past, not relationship drama or the kind of stuff you see in TVD/Twilight/Being Human/etc. I think it helped that Angel wasn't fighting "the beast within". He had a soul so, except for a few situations, having to fight his "hunger" or beast like stuff was never an issue for him. Outside of relationship drama and generally just being annoying, modern vampires fighting or giving into their monstrous qualities is another annoying part of vampire stories.

I don't care if Vampire A is trying not to eat humans while Vampires B and C are fighting for territory. There is a lot of vampire politics drama in modern vampire stories, which seems pretty bizarre (even Being Human, which was supposed to be about a vampire, werewolf and ghost, had a bunch of vampire specific drama which is what made me only watcha few episodes). That's just the vampire specific drama, those shows tend to have more standard relationship drama on top of that.

On the other hand, I do care about a vampire with a soul trying to save people while dealing with supernatural threats.



Its hard to describe. I don't want love triangles or stuff like that. Basically, I don't want relationship drama to be a big part of the show. It wasn't for Buffy or Angel, although I consider this a requirement for any genre.
I see, I enjoy that kind of stuff.
The problems on a show should come from a situation or enemy, not someone's love life or personal problems with another main character. I mean, even that is a bad way of describing what I mean. Technically Angel's fights with Darla is both a personal problem and a love life based drama. But, its still a lot different then what you get in modern stuff.
A show should have at least a bit of personal drama to help you invest in the characters and their relationships. I get tired of constant will they/won't they, or when couples do nothing but fight, but we need something to get us to invest in the characters and their relationships.

I watched the american version. I'm aware of the British version, but I'm pretty sure my problem with the US version would also be part of the UK version.
They are pretty similar.
 
I see what you're talking, but it's hard to come up with shows that don't have any of that kind of stuff in them. I think you kind of need at least a little bit of that to help invest in the characters and their relationships. I admit some shows do go overboard with this stuff sometimes though. If there's enough other good stuff, I can deal with it though, which I did with GOT and Spartacus.

:shrug: I can think of a large amount of shows that have little to none. Everything from the vast majority of Star Trek to Doctor Who, Stargate SG-1, and even most of Buffy and Angel. I don't think that kind of drama is necessary in any situation, honestly.

A show should have at least a bit of personal drama to help you invest in the characters and their relationships. I get tired of constant will they/won't they, or when couples do nothing but fight, but we need something to get us to invest in the characters and their relationships.

Like I said above, I've been invested in everything from Buffy to Star Trek The Next Generation without having any of that stuff. In my opinion, a good sci fi or fantasy show doesn't base itself on relationship drama or even have much of it (if any at all). Everything from Trek to Buffy did that well, but we live in the era of angsty TV nowadays. So, instead of good stories and characters we get brooding morons and stories about their drama. This is especially true of modern fantasy shows, most of which only have supernatural/fantasy elements to slightly separate themselves from the hundreds of other lame adult dramas (although that doesn't really work when they have a bunch of angsty supernatural dramas all at once like they've been doing for years).

That's how I see it, at least. Maybe in 20 years shows like The Vampire Diaries, The Magicians or Teen Wolf will stop being popular and shows like Buffy and Angel will get made again. but, as long as their is money in shirtless brooding "sexy" vampires, or angsty adult drama, I doubt there will be a good fantasy show on TV. All that isn't even bringing up the hyper violent semi-porns like Game of thrones, but the clones it inspires are usually bad basic cable shows with all the depressing grim darkness but none of the extreme sexual content (because they're not on HBO), so its not really a trend like the brooding supernatural romances and "fantasy" adult dramas.
 
The drama on shows The Magicians or The Originals, really isn't any different than what we saw on Buffy, or Angel. Even DS9 had quite a bit of that kind of stuff with Odo and Kira, and Dax and Worf, and Voyager with Tom and B'Elanna.
 
The drama on shows The Magicians or The Originals, really isn't any different than what we saw on Buffy, or Angel. Even DS9 had quite a bit of that kind of stuff with Odo and Kira, and Dax and Worf, and Voyager with Tom and B'Elanna.

Well, I don't agree. I mean, having relationships isn't the same as the relationship drama I'm talking about. I mean, Star trek had problems with relationships, but it had problems with romance in general. It was different then the romantic drama of shows like the standard modern adult dramas. Sometimes it could be just as bad (the DS9 episode with Jadzia and Worf on Risa, for example :barf2:), but even then it was a different kind of bad. Its also not like DS9 or Voyager ever had a whole story line focused on relationship drama. A few individual episodes here and there, but they were usually terrible episodes so it doesn't really effect my opinion.

In the end, nothing on any of the shows I like was similar to the angsty drama or relationship drama of the standard modern adult dramas. Even the bad stuff was generally not as bad, and it was never the focus of a show. Most modern adult dramas don't just have relationship and/or angsty drama sometimes, its usually one of the themes of the show. That's not something you can say about any of the shows I like.

Anyway, I don't want to argue. I'm not saying people can't like that stuff, its just happens to be among the things I hate the most in a TV show.There is no situation where I'd watch shows like The Originals or The Magicians, and in the end that's really all I have to say about it. Its for different reasons, but in the end its similar to why I won't watch The Expanse. Regardless of objective quality, they're just not shows I'd like.
 
You said you liked classic and new Doctor Who, ever you ever tried the audiobooks from Big Finish, there are some good gems amongst a gigantic catalogue.
 
You said you liked classic and new Doctor Who, ever you ever tried the audiobooks from Big Finish, there are some good gems amongst a gigantic catalogue.

I don't like Big Finish. Plus, if I wanted Doctor Who I'd watch one of the 73 or so remaining Classic Who serials I need to watch. I'll get to those eventually, but I was looking for something different.
 
I'm not saying its bad, but its not for me. I hate hard sci fi, and The Expanse doesn't even have interstellar travel. Its also hardly a space show (at least the type I'm looking for). It all takes place between earth, mars and the asteroid belt, which is not something I'd be interested in even if it wasn't hard sci fi. Its also space opera-ish, its a show about a detective solving a crime. All of that, plus the fact that even positive reviews I've read say the characters are weak, just make the show something I wouldn't want to see. So, no, I'm not eliminating it "out of hand", I have good reasons and I don't intend to argue about it. I'm not saying its a bad show, its just not for me.

To complain about the lack of good SF on TV, and to want space opera, and then refuse to watch what is by far the best space show on TV in recent years based on preconceived and partial information, that's just ...stubborn to the extreme. Or dumb, it seems.

Yes, it is hard SF. Which is *so refreshing* at this point.
Yes, it takes place in the solar system... But we've never seen it like this. But not just Earth/Mars/Belt. All of the outer planets and moons are there too. Jupiter, Saturn, Ganymede, Io, Titan. And the Oort cloud, and beyond.
As for interstellar travel and aliens...
Eventually, Yes and yes :D But not how you might expect
There is a detective yes, but he is only one of five main characters. All collecting pieces to a mystery that will turn the solar system on its head.
Season 1 is a slow burn for some of the character, now that season 2 is starting, they are well developed and the plot is accelerating.

Normally I would not have try to argue this with out, but you do not get to complain about the lack of good space opera and space based SF while being intent on ignoring the best such show in years. But this is the last I'll post about it here.
 
Last edited:
To complain about the lack of good SF on TV, and to want space opera, and then refuse to watch what is by far the best space show on TV in recent years based on preconceived and partial information, that's just ...stubborn to the extreme. Or dumb, it seems.

Yes, it is hard SF. Which is *so refreshing* at this point.
Yes, it takes place in the solar system... But we've never seen it like this. But not just Earth/Mars/Belt. All of the outer planets and moons are there too. Jupiter, Saturn, Ganymede, Io, Titan. And the Oort cloud, and beyond.
As for interstellar travel and aliens...
Eventually, Yes and yes :D But not how you might expect
There is a detective yes, but he is only one of five main characters. All collecting pieces to a mystery that will turn the solar system on its head.
Season 1 is a slow burn for some of the character, now that season 2 is starting, they are well developed and the plot is accelerating.

Normally I would not have try to argue this with out, but you do not get to complain about the lack of good space opera and space based SF while being intent on ignoring the best such show in years. But this is the last I'll post about it here.

That's all your opinion. I don't think a Hard Sci Fi can even be a space opera, to me they're two different genres. If it doesn't have interstellar travel, its not a space opera. If it conforms to realistic (or mostly realistic) depictions of living/traveling in space? Its not a space opera. Its hard sci fi, and I hate hard sci fi. There has never been any context where I haven't loathed hard sci fi. I find actual depictions of "realistic" space stuff to be tedious and unwatchable.

So, yeah, I can complain about the lack of space opera. The Expanse in no way, shape or form even remotely resembles a space opera. I don't care if other people like it, I'm not making an objective comment on its quality. I just hate the kind of story it tells. Hard Sci Fi is something I literally wouldn't watch even if the alternative was watching paint dry. That's just me, but it means that my statement is correct for me. There are no good space shows for me on TV. For other people that's not true, but it is for me.
 
I don't think The Expanse is really hard sci-fi, it does approach things a bit more realistically, but it doesn't really focus on the science or tech very much. Most of it is just kind of there as set dressing.
 
Well, for me having no interstellar travel, along with things like no artificial gravity, etc is too "hard" sci fi for me. Plus, everything being limited to Earth, Mars and the asteroid belt is enough for it to not be a "space opera", and also somewhat "hard" sci fi by itself. Again, that's just my view on it. Its not a show for me, for many reasons.
 
It's set in space in the future, so for me that's enough for it to be space opera.:shrug:
 
It's set in space in the future, so for me that's enough for it to be space opera.:shrug:

That's not enough for me. But, again, it doesn't matter. I never wanted to argue about The expanse, that's why I tried to remove it as a recommendation in the very first post. I'm glad people like it, its always nice to have more TV that you like. But, its not for someone with my taste in Sci Fi.

I've pretty much given up on this particular topic. There are no currently airing Sci Fi/Fantasy shows, that I don't already watch, that I would like. There are no space operas, or Fantasy shows (outside of superhero shows), that I don't already know about that I'd like. That's what happens when you're a big nerd I guess, you learn about the best stuff pretty quickly. Hopefully Discovery will be great and I'll have a new Space Opera to watch. Until then I'll just go through the Classic Who and various Trek episodes I haven't seen, along with maybe a rewatch of an old favorite, for my space opera needs.

As for fantasy, its pretty much movies only. Until the trend of angsty YA/adult supernatural romances dies a well deserved death we won't be getting any good supernatural or magical shows, and I think that "high" fantasy is dead on TV (or, more accurately, never even "lived" on TV in the first place).
 
Last edited:
It's not what happens when you're a nerd, it's just what happens when you're really picky. I don't mean this as an insult, it's just pretty clear that you have your specific things you're looking for, and you're not finding those specific things right now.
There's actually more high quality fantasy and sci-fi on TV now than there has been in a very long time, it's just that none of it is what you like.
Here's what I can find:
Sci-Fi:
Rick & Morty
Justice League Action
(There might be some other Cartoon Network sci-fi shows, but I can't find a list on their website)
Star Wars: Rebels
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Jeff & Some Aliens
Archer
Avengers Assemble
Ultimate Spider-Man
Guardians of the Galaxy
The Expanse
The 100
Incorporated
Colony
The Flash
Legends of Tomorrow
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Timeless
Humans
Into the Badlands (debatable, there's not real high tech or futuristic stuff, but it does technically take place in the future)
Legion
Westworld
Dark Matter
The Killjoys
12 Monkeys
Power Rangers
Supergirl
Luke Cage
Jessica Jones

Fantasy:
The Vampire Diaries
The Originals
Sleepy Hollow
Lucifer
Son of Zorn
The Librarians
The Magicians
Emerald City
Game of Thrones
Grimm
Once Upon A Time
Preacher
The Strain
Outlander
Van Helsing
Wynonna Earp
Teen Wolf
The Shannara Chronicles
Salem
Shadowhunters

Coming soon:
Midnight Texas
American Gods
Star Trek: Discovery
Throne of Glass
The Handmaid's Tale
The Runaways
Cloak & Dagger
Iron Fist
Time After Time
This is just the stuff I found from a combination of my memory and a little bit of looking around online, I'm pretty sure there are a lot of others I'm not familiar with. I'm also leaving it to just US, if we expand it out to stuff from other parts of the world then there's some stuff I know of coming out places like China, the UK, and Australia that can be watched in the US.
 
It's not what happens when you're a nerd, it's just what happens when you're really picky. I don't mean this as an insult, it's just pretty clear that you have your specific things you're looking for, and you're not finding those specific things right now.
There's actually more high quality fantasy and sci-fi on TV now than there has been in a very long time, it's just that none of it is what you like.
Here's what I can find:
Sci-Fi:
Rick & Morty
Justice League Action
(There might be some other Cartoon Network sci-fi shows, but I can't find a list on their website)
Star Wars: Rebels
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Jeff & Some Aliens
Archer
Avengers Assemble
Ultimate Spider-Man
Guardians of the Galaxy
The Expanse
The 100
Incorporated
Colony
The Flash
Legends of Tomorrow
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Timeless
Humans
Into the Badlands (debatable, there's not real high tech or futuristic stuff, but it does technically take place in the future)
Legion
Westworld
Dark Matter
The Killjoys
12 Monkeys
Power Rangers
Supergirl
Luke Cage
Jessica Jones

Fantasy:
The Vampire Diaries
The Originals
Sleepy Hollow
Lucifer
Son of Zorn
The Librarians
The Magicians
Emerald City
Game of Thrones
Grimm
Once Upon A Time
Preacher
The Strain
Outlander
Van Helsing
Wynonna Earp
Teen Wolf
The Shannara Chronicles
Salem
Shadowhunters

Coming soon:
Midnight Texas
American Gods
Star Trek: Discovery
Throne of Glass
The Handmaid's Tale
The Runaways
Cloak & Dagger
Iron Fist
Time After Time
This is just the stuff I found from a combination of my memory and a little bit of looking around online, I'm pretty sure there are a lot of others I'm not familiar with. I'm also leaving it to just US, if we expand it out to stuff from other parts of the world then there's some stuff I know of coming out places like China, the UK, and Australia that can be watched in the US.

I did say "There are no currently airing Sci Fi/Fantasy shows, that I don't already watch, that I would like." So, all my comments were supposed to be about me specifically, although I might not have stated that very well. It also wasn't supposed to include include shows I already watch (Flash, Arrow, Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl, Rick & Morty, The Librarians, Power Rangers, Luke Cage, Agents of SHIELD).

To be fair though, a lot of those shows you listed aren't high quality (The Marvel cartoons are especially garbage, Justice League Action is mediocre and I think listing Archer is really pushing the definition of Sci Fi, and those are just the bad shows I have experience with). I never said shows in those genres don't exist or aren't airing, I said good shows and stuff I'd like. So, even ignoring that, of the stuff on that list I haven't seen about half of it is just terrible (Teen Wolf? The Vampire Diaries? Are those shows existing supposed to prove anything except what I've already said about angsty romances being most of the fantasy shows that get made?). I will grant that you found another Game of Thrones-ish semi-porn I forgot about (Westworld). But, besides that, the list really has no purpose, and doesn't go against what I've already said.

If you like trek-ish space opera, there isn't one show on that list. If you want real high fantasy you're out of luck, unless you count the post-apocalyptic romance Chronicles of Shannara (which doesn't actually count because you can't have "high fantasy" on Earth, it has to be a completely different world). Basically, that list just shows its a good time to be a superhero fan (which I am), and that adult Swim basically puts out the only currently airing non-superhero sci fi show that I think is good (Rick & Morty). The list does make me even more depressed about the state of Sci Fi/Fantasy TV, though. I didn't think so much junk was being made at once. It looks like Sci Fi on TV was at its high point in the 90s and early 2000s. The "high Quality" is debatable (most of the list is pathetic), but we're definitely at the worst time for Sci Fi/Fantasy TV we've had since I've been alive (so since 1990, basically).
 
Actually Archer, which is one of my favorite shows of all time, is very much sci-fi. It's dealt with space stations, clones, two major recurring characters are cyborgs, one of the main characters is a clone of Hitler, and they even had an episode with a couple of aliens.
I knew you were probably aware of most the shows I listed, I was just putting the list together to illustrate how picky I thought you were being, and showing that there are a lot of options out there if you were just a little more open minded about what you were willing watch.
I was also just doing it for myself for fun, just to see how many I could find.
When I said high quality, I was mainly talking about it in terms of budget, not necessarily quality. We've moved way beyond the days of ST:TOS, BSG:TOS, early TNG, and Classic Dr. Who.
I definitely disagree about this being the worst time for sci-fi and fantasy, if anything I'd say we're in a golden age, with some of the best genre shows ever on television being produced right now. I would definitely put The Expanse in that category, and putting aside my issues with it's over reliance on sex, when it hits it's heights Game of Thrones definitely goes into that category.
Going purely by numbers, I don't think there have been this many SFF shows on at the same time in quite a while.
 
Last edited:
Actually Archer, which is one of my favorite shows of all time, is very much sci-fi. It's dealt with space stations, clones, two major recurring characters are cyborgs, one of the main characters is a clone of Hitler, and they even had an episode with a couple of aliens.
I knew you were probably aware of most the shows I listed, I was just putting the list together to illustrate how picky I thought you were being, and showing that there are a lot of options out there if you were just a little more open minded about what you were willing watch.
I was also just doing it for myself for fun, just to see how many I could find.
When I said high quality, I was mainly talking about it in terms of budget, not necessarily quality. We've moved way beyond the days of ST:TOS, BSG:TOS, early TNG, and Classic Dr. Who.
I definitely disagree about this being the worst time for sci-fi and fantasy, if anything I'd say we're in a golden age, with some of the best genre shows ever on television being produced right now. I would definitely put The Expanse in that category, and putting aside my issues with it's over reliance on sex, when it hits it's heights Game of Thrones definitely goes into that category.
Going purely by numbers, I don't think there have been this many SFF shows on at the same time in quite a while.

Ok, while I consider Archer more "super spy" then Sci Fi, it might have some elements. I basically watched the pilot and hated it, and have seen various clips around the internet since then, and it was even less "sci fi" then a lotof the spy stuff around. But, since I haven't seen much of it, it might qualify, even though it seems to be a spy show first and foremost.

I completely disagree about this being a "golden age", though. We used to have two Trek shows at once, along with classics like Babylon 5, Stargate SG-1, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, etc. That was the golden age of Sci Fi/Fantasy TV in my opinion (even for superheroes because of the DC Animated Universe). I say this as someone who had to experience most of it after the fact, since not having cable and mediocre local stations means I missed most everything wqhen I was growing up, until the internet and DVDs os seasons became more avaliable.

I'd say that the worst genre shows on television are being produced right now, with angsty romance on basic cable and violent semi-porn on the premium stations. Add in a few trend breaking (which doesn't make them better, but admittedly non standard) stuff like The Expanse, and its a bad time for genre TV.

Also, I'm open minded enough. I know what I like and what I hate, but I'll give a show in a style I like a lot of benefit of the doubt. I hated NuBSG once the planet arc began (Season 2?), but I still watched every second of that badly written, "symbolism" filled pile of pain. I id that because I like the type of show, although where I got the endurance to watch all of that show I'll never know. Honestly, I think it would be bizarre to be any more "open minded" then I am.

But, I'm not judging other people. I watch too much stuff that some people consider stupid (everything from Power Rangers to anime) to care if people not in the demographic watch stuff like The 100 or Teen Wolf. Same with shows I just find personally unwatchable outside the YA romance style (like The Expanse, Magicians, etc). I just wish we got good stuff in addition to that, like some space operas or different kinds of Fantasy shows that didn't involve brooding loners. As for me personally, thinking about it I'm not that picky, Sci Fi and Fantasy has just gotten so bad on TV that there are only a few types being made, and outside of superhero stuff its mostly styles/types of shows I've always hated (angsty romance, angsty adult drama, hard sci fi, violent semi-porn, etc).

Hopefully if Discovery takes off it will open the door to more space operas. Fantasy, however, is screwed until the angsty romance genre dies off and Game of Thrones is off TV for a few years. Until then, at least we have good superhero shows, which isn't a replacement for other stuff but is still a good thing to have. We're in the dark age of (non superhero) sci Fi and Fantasy TV, but there are still a few bright spots and hopefully something like Discovery will bring good things with it (like how TNG kind of started the Sci Fi boom of the golden age, even if it took a few years). Until then, I'm happy some people can find stuff they enjoy, but I'll keep hoping the trash eventually gets rejected and shows I like get made.
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top