• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Reason for holographic communication and its abolishment?

Good you made that clear - I‘m
sure nobody ever thought of that.

You're welcome.

30 years from now there will be similar conversations going on then, too, when new tech gets introduced into a future that looks antiquated by 2049 standards vs. 2019 standards. But I'm down with your urge to explain it in an in-u way. Good thoughts.
 
You're welcome.

30 years from now there will be similar conversations going on then, too, when new tech gets introduced into a future that looks antiquated by 2049 standards vs. 2019 standards. But I'm down with your urge to explain it in an in-u way. Good thoughts.
You do know that tech goes backwards in real life too? While the solid state drives replacing hard drives in laptops are technically much faster, the long term data retention of such drives is far below that of the older hard drives. Eventually all the charges in a solid state drive will wear out, and leakage means data is lost much earlier than in hard drives, where magnetic polarity shifts more slowly.

Optical (CD, DVD, etc.) disc drives were commonplace in laptops and now most don't have them anymore. Ethernet ports are far more reliable than wifi and most laptops don't even have those anymore. The analogy with holograms on starships is striking.
 
Last edited:
There’s a world of difference between using a piece of software or hardware, and making genetic changes to your body.
Starfleet and the Federation have been shown to be inconsistent in their overreactions. Besides, since holographic communication eventually comes back (briefly) it seems something that was tinkered on again and off again.

Also, until it was demonstrated to be reliable it wouldn't surprise me if they used more reliable tech on their frontier ships.
 
Even in 100 years time.

View attachment 8590
its-real.jpg
 
Starfleet and the Federation have been shown to be inconsistent in their overreactions. Besides, since holographic communication eventually comes back (briefly) it seems something that was tinkered on again and off again.

Also, until it was demonstrated to be reliable it wouldn't surprise me if they used more reliable tech on their frontier ships.
In the real world military, some ultra secure command codes are still on floppy disks... Sometimes, the military is often the slowest to deploy the latest tech, and sometimes it's the fastest.
 
Voyager showed they were even used as tools for Vulcans dealing with Pon Farr (literally a life or death matter for a Vulcan) if the Vulcan is out of range of civilization.
If sex with holograms really works for ponn farr, maybe Vulcans should just masturbate every seven years instead.
 
Except it didn't work. It was only temporary, which is why B'Elanna and Vorik beat the crap out of each other while three crewmates watch. Perfectly logical...
It worked for Tuvok.

Although maybe it would have been more dramatic for the Voyager crew to walk into the holodeck and find a dead Tuvok on the floor, and realize it failed to help his Pon Farr.
 
It worked for Tuvok.

Although maybe it would have been more dramatic for the Voyager crew to walk into the holodeck and find a dead Tuvok on the floor, and realize it failed to help his Pon Farr.
Tuvok was a lot older than Vorik so maybe that had something to with it.
 
Tuvok was a lot older than Vorik so maybe that had something to with it.
Nah, Tuvok even said in the episode with his ponn farr that the Vulcan libido increases with age. So if anything, him being older than Vorik should have made it less likely to work.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top