Poll Rank the 1701s
- Thread starter Lord Garth
- Start date
At least you you aren't Dopey.Don't mind me. I'm grumpy tonight.
Wait until I get some liquor in me!
Is there a dwarf named Drunky?
I think he's kept in the same vault as Song of the South, and the Donald Duck Nazi cartoons.
TOS (seems the most spacey and uninhibited)
Refit (refined and elegant but a little too tough and pretty)
Disco (snazzy)
Cage (vintage)
‘09 (a comic book version detailed real)
Beyond (epitome of the idea — an abstract scribble in background panel of comic book detailed real)
Refit (refined and elegant but a little too tough and pretty)
Disco (snazzy)
Cage (vintage)
‘09 (a comic book version detailed real)
Beyond (epitome of the idea — an abstract scribble in background panel of comic book detailed real)
Last edited:
1. TOS Enterprise
2. Disco Enterprise
3. TMP-TSFS Enterprise
...
999. The Dinghy of Suckitude isn't even worth mentioning for me
2. Disco Enterprise
3. TMP-TSFS Enterprise
...
999. The Dinghy of Suckitude isn't even worth mentioning for me
Last edited:
The original. It's the only one with that feel of "sixties cool", which is one of the main reasons why I watch Star Trek in the first place.
The Abrams version looks good from certain angles, but I don't like the bulbous nacelles, or the stubby ones that replaced them on the "A".
Kor
The Abrams version looks good from certain angles, but I don't like the bulbous nacelles, or the stubby ones that replaced them on the "A".
Kor
The Original will always top the list for me. I spent plenty of time creating my own kit bashes in MS paint as a teen before I discovered Josephs' Manual.
Abrams probably comes in second, followed by a tie between the refit and Discoprise.
Abrams probably comes in second, followed by a tie between the refit and Discoprise.
So this thread is "NCC One-Seven-Oh-One, no bloody A, B, C or D"? 
That TMP refit has the best wow factor, IMHO, & it only got more improved in the subsequent 2 films. It might be my favorite all around Enterprise
Then the TOS model, which is like an old haunt with a warm place in my heart
I guess the Discoprise after that. It doesn't annoy me nearly as much as the Kelvinprise, with that goofy bridge & brewery engine room
That TMP refit has the best wow factor, IMHO, & it only got more improved in the subsequent 2 films. It might be my favorite all around Enterprise
Then the TOS model, which is like an old haunt with a warm place in my heart
I guess the Discoprise after that. It doesn't annoy me nearly as much as the Kelvinprise, with that goofy bridge & brewery engine room
1. TOS Starship Class U.S.S. Enterprise
2. TMP Enterprise
3. JJ Enterprise
4. The short lived Beyond Enterprise which looked quite interesting through
a series of well shot beauty passes. I was disappointed to see that version
go... so quickly.
You have to upload an image to your own external hosting space, and then you can do the IMG tags to hotlink from there. You can't upload directly to Trekbbs.com unless you have a premium membership.
Kor
1. Discoprise – stunning ship, both inside and out.
2. TOS – sixties cool vibe.
3. Kelvin – beautiful, clean, and futuristic interior. But those nacelles are bulky.
4. TMP – never really had a soft spot for it. I preferred the 1701-A more.
2. TOS – sixties cool vibe.
3. Kelvin – beautiful, clean, and futuristic interior. But those nacelles are bulky.
4. TMP – never really had a soft spot for it. I preferred the 1701-A more.
I wish Short Treks would do a '70s-style "What If?" with the Phase II Enterprise.
Of course, I'd also like to see the '70s version of the Crossfield Class also shot with models and looking in the style Planet of the Titans would've.
Similar threads
