The trilogy was a novel and interesting look at an "extended" alternate universe scenario (with Spock Prime there to ground it). It would of course be fun to see another adventure, but if it never happens, we'll always have ST'09, ST:iD, and... S.T....Beyond (blah). Yes, the studio dropped the ball on this potential franchise restart.
It's sort of interesting to note that, by the time any such hypothetical movie would hit the screen, we'd be as far from ST'09 as TMP was from the Cage. Of course the actors are about a decade behind in age as compared to their TOS counterparts.
Anyway, I've paid my respects to the Paramount quasi-reboots, and am perfectly happy to embrace the new CBSAA adventures that appear on my TV box (yes, I'll even give Lower Decks a shot).