• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Quark's root beer analogy of the Federation

NATO seems to work.

NATO is great, but it is just a defensive alliance. There's a pledge of mutual defence, some degree of training together, some effort to purchase compatible military equipment, but they don't regulate trade or do much to provide disaster relief.

Reed's? I buy it at my local grocery store here in Phoenix AZ.

Yes, Reed's widely available at grocery stores here in Seattle as well.
 
Canada Dry is still around and still making quite a few soft drinks. Their ownership has changed several times, it makes them look like a white chip at the poker table of corporate acquisitions.
 
The Federation in Journey to Babel was obviously VERY loosely knit. The individual members seemed to retain far more of their sovereignty (to say nothing of opinions and suspicions of the other members) than in later Star Trek. Given that the Enterprise had to run around and play taxi they didn't even seem to be a permanent standing body.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kkt
I don't know... I wouldn't like the idea of my planet's defence, import-export, and emergency assistance depending on a Federation in which I had no share in governance.

NATO seems to work.

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization is a defensive alliance, not a sovereign state possessing its own discrete territory, its own constitution guaranteeing certain rights and liberties and imposing certain functionalities on its government, its own government, its own codified body of law to which all persons within its territory are subject, its own system of courts, or any of the other traits that make up a sovereign state. Every North Atlantic Treaty Organization Member State has a representative on the North Atlantic Council. And most importantly, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization possesses no sovereignty over its Member States -- unlike the Federation, whose Supreme Court we learned in "Dr. Bashir, I Presume?" has the power of judicial review over the laws of all Federation worlds, including Earth's ban on genetic engineering.
 
If the Federation didn't, somebody else would have. :shrug:

Who and why, though?

The alpha quadrant powers (except for the Federation) don't seem that altruistic, so some self-interest probably has to be involved. At the beginning of DS9, Bajor is devastated, wrung dry of resources, and the wormhole hasn't been discovered yet. The Bajoran side of the story may be that they liberated Bajor under their own resistive power; the Cardassian side (which we hear less) may be that it was no longer economically profitable to maintain the occupation so the decision was made to abandon the planet. So no economic advantages are to be expected in the short term. The only reason could have been to gain a strategic foothold near to Cardassian space, which seems a bit of a 2nd rate power anyways, compared to Klingons, Federation, Romulans.
 
Yes. Americans are the only people in the world who like root beer.

Okay. I'm not a fan of sweet carbonated sodas in general, but root beer to me doesn't seem any worse than Coca Cola or Pepsi products. I do actually like a root beer float, maybe every other year or so.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top