Here's a brief review of the second half of season three of ROUTE 66 I wrote some years back. Hope it's pertinent to the discussion.
Alas, George Maharis, after giving us two and a half seasons worth of Emmy-caliber performances as Buz Murdock, has hit the road. Or rather, he's "unhit" the road, leaving his less flashy but more reliable co-star Martin Milner to go it alone. Yes, Buz is gone for good, never to be so much as referred to on screen again. And if you're a Maharis/Buz fan who just can't stand the idea of ROUTE 66 without your favorite character, perhaps you'd do well to halt your collection after Season Three, Volume One. Those of you who do decide to stick along for the rest of the ride, you'll be rewarded with many more memorable moments still ahead on the journey.
Season three of ROUTE 66 was marked by a turbulent upheaval such as few television programs have to suffer. It actually seems almost like three completely different seasons (if not completely different series) in one - first there was the show we'd come to know and love, featuring Tod and Buz in some of their greatest moments. Then the abrupt departure of Maharis, leaving Tod to go it alone. And then the final third part of the season, in which Tod meets Lincoln Case and a new partnership develops with a new set of adventures.
Each one of those three parts of season three of ROUTE 66 had its own separate dynamic. Stage One was the classic ROUTE 66 we've come to expect, a polished program which had settled into and was thriving in its format and the rapport between its two leads, turning out some of its best episodes such as "Man Out of Time" or "Ever Ride the Waves in Oklahoma?". The sudden departure of Maharis brought that to a skidding halt. Then came stage two, in which Tod wandered the road alone, the show becoming more and more like a genuine anthology series as Milner's character, as well-developed as it was, clearly needed a foil to realize its full potential. Although many of the Milner solo episodes display the excellence we've come to expect from this series (such as the delightful "Suppose I Said I Was the Queen of Spain", with Lois Nettleton as a woman who puts on and discards personas like clothes), others come across as somewhat muddled and underdeveloped. For example, Stirling Silliphant apparently intended "Shall Forfeit His Dog and Ten Shillings to the King" (in which Tod joins an Arizona posse searching for a pair of killers) to be a condemnation of the vigilante mob mentality; but this is undermined by the direction which turns the episode into a standard tale of frontier justice in which the good guys and the bad guys are clearly designated. In this context, Tod's denunciation of his fellow posse members at the episode's conclusion makes little sense.
It was obvious that Milner needed a new sidekick. Names such as Robert Duvall and Burt Reynolds were considered, but finally, in March 1963 America was introduced to Glenn Corbett as Lincoln `Linc' Case, an Army Ranger recently returned from the Vietnam `'conflict'. Making that war a pivotal element of an American television series at a time when it still wasn't making front page news on US headlines marks another historical first for the series.
Glenn Corbett has gotten his fair share of criticism from ROUTE 66 afficianados, mainly for not being George Maharis. But Corbett and his episodes have to be and deserve to be taken on their own terms. No fan mourns the lamentable loss of Buz more than I do, but at the same time I recognize that some of the series' finest stories came with Corbett in the passenger seat, and that some of those perhaps could not have been done they way they were with Maharis. One example is "What a Shining Young Man Was Our Gallant Lieutenant", which represents a highwater mark in Corbett's tenure in terms of his performance.
The third season concludes fittingly enough with the patched-together "Soda Pop and Paper Flags", itself emblematic of the chaos under which the show was laboring. It was originally intended to be a Buz Murdock episode, but Maharis said his famous "see ya later" just as filming on the show was beginning in St. Louis. Milner went ahead and filmed his own scenes in anticipation of an eventual new co-star. "Soda Pop" was not completed until a couple of months later in Florida, when Corbett filmed a few scenes of his own to finish the show. One thing this episode is notable for is featuring a young Alan Alda in surgical whites - a decade before the premiere of M*A*S*H and his career-defining role as Dr. "Hawkeye" Pierce.
Marc Scott Zicree once wrote of the fifth and final season of the original TWILIGHT ZONE that "if the series had faded, it had faded only in comparison with itself." The same can equally and truly be said of ROUTE 66 after the departure of George Maharis.