Perfect Actor To Play 'Q' in nuTNG

[USS Triumphant]

My son just said this, and I agree with it entirely. The Old Spice guy, Isaiah Mustafa, should be Q!

"Look at your desk. Now look at me. What's in my hand? It's that report on Tagus III that you were writing. Look down, look up. I'm in safari gear, asking if you'd like to see the ruins for yourself. Finger snap! Now you're in a Robin Hood costume. Anything is possible with the power of the Continuum."

 

[The Wormhole]

Brilliant idea!

 

[TiberiusMaximus]

Ha ha that's awesome!

"I'm on a Tarkassian Razorbeast."

 

[Cheapjack]

John De Lancie is the Q. He understands the Q best. The Q is not just a jokester, and he could be older.

 

[illeanacross]

Old Spice Guy is pure win.

If that doesn't work out (he's a busy guy what with being on all those horses and stuff) then I nominate Neil Patrick Harris. A lot younger, granted, but still... win.

 

[Praxius]

I'd much rather Hugh Laurie (House) as Q.... he has the intelligence, the attitude and the dry humor.

John De Lancie nailed the Q perfectly and always was one of my favorite actors/characters through Star Trek..... but by his last appearance in Voyager, he was really looking old....

Then again, they could also just use his son in Voyager to carry on the torch.... he did pretty good as a Q.

 

[Admiral Buzzkill]

No - Old Spice Guy FTW!

 

[Nardpuncher]

I'd much rather Hugh Laurie (House) as Q.... he has the intelligence, the attitude and the dry humor.

John De Lancie nailed the Q perfectly and always was one of my favorite actors/characters through Star Trek..... but by his last appearance in Voyager, he was really looking old....

Then again, they could also just use his son in Voyager to carry on the torch.... he did pretty good as a Q.

Though the Old Spice guy is a good funny idea, I was wondering what could be a more "serious" idea and Hugh Laurie sounds like a good idea.
Now I'm wondering what actor could also be Q....

 

[Nardpuncher]

My son just said this, and I agree with it entirely. The Old Spice guy, Isaiah Mustafa, should be Q!

"Look at your desk. Now look at me. What's in my hand? It's that report on Tagus III that you were writing. Look down, look up. I'm in safari gear, asking if you'd like to see the ruins for yourself. Finger snap! Now you're in a Robin Hood costume. Anything is possible with the power of the Continuum."

Also, your son sounds like a witty, clever guy!

 

[USS Triumphant]

Though the Old Spice guy is a good funny idea, I was wondering what could be a more "serious" idea and Hugh Laurie sounds like a good idea.
Now I'm wondering what actor could also be Q....

I feel sure that Mustafa can be a bit more serious than he is given time for in 30 second spots - probably wouldn't have any choice but to be, really. But I'm kinda liking ileanacross's idea about Neil Patrick Harris in the role, too.

 

[illeanacross]

I'd throw David Tennant into the ring too but he gets called for any off-center role. Same with Christopher Eccleston. And probably every other Doctor there has ever been.

Except for the 8th. Never the 8th.

 

[B.J.]

Bit of a different direction, but I think Bruce Campbell could pull off the Q role rather well!

 

[Nardpuncher]

Bit of a different direction, but I think Bruce Campbell could pull off the Q role rather well!

Ooohh! I like that!

 

[Gary7]

I'd much rather Hugh Laurie (House) as Q.... he has the intelligence, the attitude and the dry humor.

John De Lancie nailed the Q perfectly and always was one of my favorite actors/characters through Star Trek..... but by his last appearance in Voyager, he was really looking old....

As long as Hugh doesn't do a House imitation, I think he'd be great for the role of "Q". House's intelligence and dry humor would work, but the role requires a bit of exuberant zany that De Lancie does so wonderfully. But Laurie is talented and could pull it off, IMHO. It's just too bad his acting rank is so high, as he'd likely not take a role like this.

De Lancie's only real problem right now is that he has put on too much weight... following in the footsteps of Shatner, Frakes, and Gore. If he shed about 15-20lbs, he'd be perfect.

 

[USS Triumphant]

I could see Tennant. Bruce Campbell would be an interesting choice, for sure. But I'm not sure if I feel him or Laurie as Q. They've been the wrong kind of zany - good, but wrong - in the stuff I have seen them in.

One thing that would be really cool if DeLancie could lose the weight and reprise his role is that they could imply or outright say that he, at least, is still the same Q. Fascinating.

 

[Jack Bauer]

John Noble. He can definitely play wacky and off kilter.

 

[Praxius]

I could see Tennant. Bruce Campbell would be an interesting choice, for sure. But I'm not sure if I feel him or Laurie as Q. They've been the wrong kind of zany - good, but wrong - in the stuff I have seen them in.

One thing that would be really cool if DeLancie could lose the weight and reprise his role is that they could imply or outright say that he, at least, is still the same Q. Fascinating.

The problem is that it'd end up as a Data Paradox.... Brent has issues continuing with the character due to Data (or Lore or B-4) supposing to be ageless..... Q is supposed to be as well... or at least not age as fast as a human.... of course if he decided he wanted to look older, sure, but I'd feel that'd be a poor argument for why he's older.

As for the weight thing.... it's like how boobs sag over time.... when you get in your 50's and 60's, it's not easy to keep the weight down.

 

[Nardpuncher]

I could see Tennant. Bruce Campbell would be an interesting choice, for sure. But I'm not sure if I feel him or Laurie as Q. They've been the wrong kind of zany - good, but wrong - in the stuff I have seen them in.

One thing that would be really cool if DeLancie could lose the weight and reprise his role is that they could imply or outright say that he, at least, is still the same Q. Fascinating.

You have a good point there too. Q would be a constant through all the many universes.

 

[The Wormhole]

Re-casting Q and making him the same character shouldn't be that hard to explain. Remember, Q as we see him is merely an image he projects to those of our realm. Maybe he wants to project a different image?

The problem is that it'd end up as a Data Paradox.... Brent has issues continuing with the character due to Data (or Lore or B-4) supposing to be ageless.....

It was established in TNG that Data has an ageing program, so he's not really "ageless."

 

[AstroSmurf]

How about Stephen Fry? He might be aging but he his cloy yet sarcastic delivery would be perfect.

If he doesn't work, I think a completely fresh face would be better.