Yeah, I could swallow a widescreen DS9, provided it really was protected for 16:9 at the time. I don't mind some cropping here and there if the overall experience is better. The X-Files generally looks incredibly good.
The concern would be the first couple of seasons, because I would presume Marvin Rush shot it exactly the same as TNG. I suppose the compromise might be 4:3 for the early seasons and switching to widescreen from Season 3 or 4.
Basically I'd be happy if the TNG Remaster team were doing it. I know they explored widescreen for TNG but discounted it.
But I fear Paramount would go for whichever hack said they'd do it for the lowest fee, and we'd get some compromised and butchered attempt to upscale the SD master tapes.
The concern would be the first couple of seasons, because I would presume Marvin Rush shot it exactly the same as TNG. I suppose the compromise might be 4:3 for the early seasons and switching to widescreen from Season 3 or 4.
Basically I'd be happy if the TNG Remaster team were doing it. I know they explored widescreen for TNG but discounted it.
But I fear Paramount would go for whichever hack said they'd do it for the lowest fee, and we'd get some compromised and butchered attempt to upscale the SD master tapes.