Onscreen evidence M'Ress is an alien?

[Orphalesion]

Still, offering no support for your idea, I see.

Ditto.

My argument: We have no evidence what M'Ress is. Why? Because there is no evidence in TAS.

Your argument: M'Press is clearly an alien. Why? Because I think so.[/QUOTE]


You quoted a novel to support your argument. If expanded universe material is accepted in this discussion (which you established by referring to Spock's World to support your argument), then M'Ress' biography (published by Lincoln Enterprises that names her as a Caitian from the planet Cait is valid as well.

 

[Marsden]

You know, I don't think Sonic Ranger has an argument to support or offer proof of, therefore he isn't offering proof or support.

And I can see the basis of his original query, someone else asked him where it said...
not prove to me it's.....
So everyone saying "your argument... " is really kind of off.

I think it's safe to say that M'ress started out as a 5 year old boy that when through the transporter with his favorite toy, a tiger named Hobbes, and this process turned him into her present form.

We all agree on this and the proof is in a small metal box buried under my basement marked Left Ears.

 

[Gov Kodos]

You know, I don't think Sonic Ranger has an argument to support or offer proof of, therefore he isn't offering proof or support.

That seems the case.

And I can see the basis of his original query, someone else asked him where it said...
not prove to me it's.....
So everyone saying "your argument... " is really kind of off.

But, not by much.

I think it's safe to say that M'ress started out as a 5 year old boy that when through the transporter with his favorite toy, a tiger named Hobbes, and this process turned him into her present form.

We all agree on this and the proof is in a small metal box buried under my basement marked Left Ears.

It seems so obvious, now.

 

[Redfern]

Between that and Schrodinger's M'Ress, you have kept me chuckling.

I will, however, take full credit (or the blame) for Schrodinger's M'Ress. Glad to entertain.

Sincerely,

Bill

 

[Therin of Andor]

Return of the Jedi had Admiral Ackbar and his crew, and on screen, no one needed to explain where they were from, nor were there any questions about their origin--they were assumed to be what they were: aliens.

The Mon Calamari. (And people complain about cat people from Cait in the Lynx constellation.)

Elevated seafood.

 

[Marsden]

Return of the Jedi had Admiral Ackbar and his crew, and on screen, no one needed to explain where they were from, nor were there any questions about their origin--they were assumed to be what they were: aliens.

The Mon Calamari. (And people complain about cat people from Cait in the Lynx constellation.)

Elevated seafood.

That's why the Emperor always wanted to have Admiral Ackbar over for dinner! It's all clear to me now!

 

[Silvercrest]

i'm telling youse guys! M'Ress is the reincarnation of JFK. why won't anyone listen to me

<blam>

Do not be alarmed. There was a security breach, but it has been neutralized. Saga will not be returning to this thread, having embarked on ... a long vacation. Yeah, that's it.

 

[USS Triumphant]

i'm telling youse guys! M'Ress is the reincarnation of JFK. why won't anyone listen to me

<blam>

Do not be alarmed. There was a security breach, but it has been neutralized. Saga will not be returning to this thread, having embarked on ... a long vacation. Yeah, that's it.

Aw! And here I was hoping they were making a comeback...

 

[Saga]

i have to go now. my planet needs me.