• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Nemesis crash at end

When the E-D rams the Schimitar where those forward decks evacuated first? it does not seem like there would have been alot of time. If not, how many people died?
Yeah, this was my big worry.
But then I thought that maybe Picard also sent an evacuation order while he was working the controls on his armrest.
 
I thought the crash scene was a bit errrrr.

BUT there would have been some sort of schematic as in Voyager whilst Tom and Tuvok where trapped in that holographic novel, Janeway was sending messages through to the hollow deck, I'd imagine Picard could do the same.
 
This also pretty much sums it up - A post from the Nemesis IMDB page.

Ok, let me get this straight, badly made movie aside...

If I have this right, this was Shinzon's timeline:

First, he was created, sent to die in the dilithium mines, but somehow managed to rise from despised human slave to leader of the Remans, discovered a theoretical kind of radiation that conveniently kills everything it touches, has an enormous and practically invincible ship built, manages to infiltrate and exterminate the Romulan senate (The ENTIRE Romulan senate) and somehow manages to take over as Praetor.

THEN...

He reprograms a heretofore unknown prototype of Data that he managed to aquire from somewhere, rips it into six different peices, drops all these bits onto a populated planet under the assumption that not only will the locals not find them, but the Enterprise will somehow manage to spot the tiny signal of a positronic signiture from lightyears away through an electrical storm (the same one that prevented them from using their transporters to simply beam up the peices)and come to investigate, rescue, and reassemble this trojan horse so it can download all the information Shinzon really didn't need anyway since he had a ship with an improved cloaking device and an ultimate weapon.

All this just to lure the Enterpise there to he can transplant Picard's DNA into himself. (Aperently cloning it woudn't be enough)

Hmmm... Believable so far...

He then invites Picard and team down to the surface and instead of taking him by force and blowing up the Enterprise when they had the chance (What with the Enterprise's sheilds being down and all) he invites him to dinner where he once again passes up the oportunity to simply snatch Picard and take his DNA. No, instead he beams him out of his own ship later on and leaves him under the watchful eye of a single gaurd for a few minutes instead of simply starting the procedure and acts surprised when he is rescued, forcing him to put off destroying the Enterprise again until he can recapture Picard which he then tries at when their communications are knocked out in the rift (God forbid they radio to Starfleet they were attacked, aperently kidnapping a Starfleet Captain isn't enough to be a diplomatic foux-pas) where the Romulans end up turning on him with only two ships.

Huh.

Did I miss anything?

Is this really the plot of the movie?

:rommie:

For me, it was the blatant TWOK ripoff that really turned me off, moreso than the massive unbelieveability of the plot.

Replace Khan with Shinzon, replace the Genesis device with Shinzon's doomsday weapon, replace Spock's sacrifice with Data's, replace the battle in the Mutara Nebula with a battle in a nebula-like space anomaly...

It's pretty disgusting. They really couldn't come up with ANY other ideas?

What's really awful about the ripping off is that none of the weight, themes, poetry, or symbolism carried over from TWOK. TWOK was about age and youth, intelligence versus experience, and how we face death. Several classic literary works were invoked - for example, 'Moby Dick' and 'A Tale of Two Cities' - to add weight and dimension to the actions of the characters. 'It's a far, far better thing I do now than I have ever done... a far better resting place I go to than I have ever known.' Spoken by Carton in 'A Tale of Two Cities', when he sacrifices his life so that others may live. The needs of the many...

'I never faced the Kobyashi Maru test until now. What do you think of my solution?'

Spock teaches Kirk the REAL way to beat the no-win scenario. Can't cheat in the real world; but his sacrifice saved the ship. Powerful stuff.

'Nemesis' was a blatant rip-off of most of the plot elements of Khan, without any of the intelligence, emotion, or drama. I really can't understand why somebody didn't speak up during the production process and point out what a sham it was.
 
This site does a fine job of pointing out the flaws in this movie:

http://stardestroyer.net/Nemesis/Pictorial-1.html

:lol: I've seen it before, but it's still a good laugh. I picked this bit at random:

DATA:The transporters conveniently failed after sending Picard, so I'm going to leap across space to get to Shinzon's ship. GEORDI:What about the transporters in the shuttles? DATA:Shut up. GEORDI:What about the Captain's Yacht? DATA:Shut up. GEORDI:Why didn't we just send a bomb instead of Picard? DATA:Shut up. GEORDI:What about the transporters in the cargo bays? They're independent units, remember? DATA:What part of "shut the fuck up" do you not understand? This is my big heroic exit, asshole. Don't fuck it up.
 
That movie is a bigger mess than Star Trek 5.

That is all.


The plot's messy in many spots and the characters are written "out of character" in so many places. Still, it will never stink as bad as TFF. Every now and then it's on cable so I watch a bit of it. That's all I can stand. It's a horrible, horrible movie. NEM, OTOH, actually has a few moments that are pretty good. Certainly not every scene, but some of the scenes (and some of the deleted scenes) are very good. While B4 was a waste of screen time, when Data shuts him down, there is some fine acting going on. Same with scenes such as Data and Picard in stellar cartography, Data's sacrificial death, Deana's and Geordi's reactions to the loss of Data, the toast by all to Data, and Riker's and Picard's good-byes. I thought this film stunk at first but with subsequent viewings, I've mellowed. However, GEN gets worse every time I watch it - too many plot holes. While NEM is the weakest of the four TNG films, it's nowhere near as bad as TFF, that steaming pile of Shat.
 
They forgot 1 gripe:

How was the Schimitar able to back away from the Enterprise, after the crash? There's no gravity to allow the ships to separate from each other. Furthermore, the crash itself should have sent both ships flying uncontrollably through space.
 
They forgot 1 gripe:

How was the Schimitar able to back away from the Enterprise, after the crash? There's no gravity to allow the ships to separate from each other. Furthermore, the crash itself should have sent both ships flying uncontrollably through space.

My guess was that the inertia of the motionless E-E was enough to overcome the binding force of the collision wreckage holding the two ships together.
 
What was the point of b-4 beyond allowing the actor the change to play a retarded version of his normal character.

Was it just the backdoor for the reappearance of Data in the next one?
 
Hey Data, do you remember your evil twin Lore? No? Me neither. Let's transfer your knowledge, much of which is sensitive military information, directly into the brain of this mystery Soong-type android we just found. Yeah, good idea.

:guffaw:
 
Better question, why didn't they just beam a bomb over or soemthing?

This site does a fine job of pointing out the flaws in this movie:

http://stardestroyer.net/Nemesis/Pictorial-1.html

"Yes, touch my bald head and use your telepathic powers. Even though I'm now literally hours from death, I think I'll delay kidnapping Picard so I can mind-rape Troi. This will show the audience just how villainous I am, in case they're totally retarded and don't get it yet. Dammit, I should have asked for more money up-front for this gig. A cut of the box-office won't be worth shit."

Haha, so true.
 
RIKER:Why did we abandon our posts on the bridge to come down here and fight these guys? Shouldn't we have a security detail? WORF:Because the audience expects main characters to be involved in every scene.
RIKER:And why are we the first ones to arrive, even though the Remans came in through the bottom of the ship and we had to come from the bridge at the top of the ship?
WORF:How the hell should I know? Maybe most of the crew is on vacation. And why are the lights so fucking dark?
RIKER:Dim red light makes everything look more foreboding.
WORF:But didn't they say that the Remans see really well in the dark and can't stand bright lights? Why don't we crank up the lights to fullbright and blind 'em?
RIKER:Shut up and just try to look dramatic.


Damn! I can't believe I missed a six foot tall purple-robed troll from 10 feet away. All those years of Starfleet training and holodeck marksmanship practice really paid off, didn't they? I guess that means I have to chase him into the bowels of the ship and have a heroic fistfight. Oooh boy, I get to be an action hero!
 
They forgot 1 gripe:

How was the Schimitar able to back away from the Enterprise, after the crash? There's no gravity to allow the ships to separate from each other. Furthermore, the crash itself should have sent both ships flying uncontrollably through space.

What, no takers?

Umm, that was discussed on Pages 2-3 of this thread already... ;)

RIKER:Why did we abandon our posts on the bridge to come down here and fight these guys? Shouldn't we have a security detail? WORF:Because the audience expects main characters to be involved in every scene.

That's a fair gripe, although one could argue that both Riker and Worf were assumed to be passengers on that flight, not real crew. However, the next one probably isn't:

RIKER:And why are we the first ones to arrive, even though the Remans came in through the bottom of the ship and we had to come from the bridge at the top of the ship?

Umm, the idea no doubt would be that the two meet halfway. Riker's team would have the benefit of internal sensor readings that would tell them where to intercept the baddies, and they would have access to turbolifts. The enemy probably would have to walk all the way, thus making slower progress and being more predictable. But they'd carry jammers (in their tricorder-equivalents, no doubt) so that Riker would not know exactly where they were.

Since the meeting would be halfway, and since the Viceroy would make every effort of continuing his climb towards the bridge, it then makes perfect sense that the two could fight on the perilious catwalk of a bottomless shaft, like all good villain-hero pairings.

Timo Saloniemi
 
I think the best one, that made the most sence, was that Remans are sesative to light, but they fight in a dark corridor.

Just crank up the lighting and shoot some Reman ass.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top