• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

My own reading Marathon, Fall through Coda

And it looks like you're missing #3 and #4 for the Rihanssu books. My Enemy, My Ally is #1, The Romulan Way is #2, and The Empty Chair is #5, you're missing Swordhunt (#3) and Honor Blade (#4).

Although those are really a single book, Swordhunt, that was hastily split into two volumes (not even renumbering the chapters) when the real second half, The Empty Chair, was delayed but they still had to fill the contracted two slots in the schedule. And in between, Swordhunt (along with MEMA & TRW) was rewritten in The Bloodwing Voyages to take place post-TMP when the original 2-volume release was set in the 5-year mission.

Not to mention that the Rihannsu books are part of a continuity that also incorporates two non-Rihannsu books, so the real sequence is The Wounded Sky, My Enemy, My Ally, The Romulan Way, Spock's World, and Swordhunt/The Empty Chair.
 
Strangers from the Sky is one of my favorites of the 80's novels (my other favorite of the era was the aforementioned Uhura's Song). It has been thoroguhly debunked by subsequent established canon about 60 times from Tueday, but it is still an absolutely fascinating and thorougly enjoyable look at an alternate take on Trek history!

Serpents Among the Ruins is, IMO, the best of the Lost Era books and is one of my all-time favorite Trek novels. I mean, any book that could redeem Captain Harriman already has a leg up, but this goes so far beyond that!

Final Frontier is better than Best Destiny, IMO. But, they both are great books!

A lot of other gems (and some no-so-gems) in that haul! You've got some great reading ahead of you!
 
Last edited:
I've now finished "Sight Unseeen" by James Swallow.

I enjoyed this one, which follows up on the extremely creepy Solanae from TNG's "Schisms". While that episode was pure horror, this one is a more trek-y mystery and then has some good inter-species politics.

Riker gives command fully over to Vale here, and promotes her to captain. Riker then has some difficulty giving up control to her, as he has some PTSD from his kidnapping. Exploring the dynamics between all these characters is well done. Admittedly, there's a lot of characters in this book, and so the screentime between them is not as much as it could be, but I still enjoyed the dynamics.

White-Blue writes himself out of the story at this point. I enjoyed his earlier appearances, but not so much as a hologram.

It did sound like the Solanae may be an active threat again, if other books have room to follow up on them. Based on the wording used here, I'm wondering if the "Prey" in the prey trilogy could be the federation, and the predator could be the Solanae. Probably not, given the devil on the cover, but who knows.

Next up for me will be the Prometheus Trilogy. After so many books focusing on screen or established litverse characters, it'll be interesting to have something new. I've read "New frontier", which also does that, but it's not as serious as a lot of other trek. I need to, at some point, go back and finish New Frontier.

After that will be Prey, where I can disprove my Solanae theory.
 
Prometheus: Fire with Fire by Bernd Perplies and Christian Humberg
This book starts with TOS-era prologue, that reveals some sort of mysterious artifact that makes people angry. Unlike other prologues, it doesn't feel to me like it overstood it's welcome.

Then we meet the crew of the Prometheus, before cutting away to a starbase. We get a short chapter of life aboard starbase 91, before it is attacked and completely destroyed. Back to prometheus, where they are dispatched to figure out what's happened. A terrorist group takes credit for this, who is made of members of an insular species known as the Renao. The only Renao officer, Jassat ak Namur, happens to server on the Prometheus, a potential asset to the crew in helping to interact with the species.

Soon, there's a similar attack on a klingon mining colony, and so the Klingons demand action and send a ship of their own, with Ambassador Alexander Rozhenko dispatched (via the Aventine) to accompany them by Martok. One thing I really liked about this book is how well it does each of these chapters of other ships or the worlds we see get destroyed. Every character we see have a scene feels very alive and the world feels very flushed out. The scene on the Klingon mining planet, I felt it was quite good despite having the hunch that everyone was going to die. There's even a scene with a Renao pilot who doesn't feel sympathy for the federation but is sent to accompany them, and I feel like this is done quite well, and ties into the main theme of the book, which is prejudice and radicalism, and how it can fester and can be enabled by others.

The one complaint I have, is that by the time I got to the end of the book, I had forgotten that the start of the book set up that there is a supernatural cause of radicalism. As the prometheus investigates, there are microagressions (and macroaggressions) against ak Namur from both Renao, who see him as someone who's left their culture (and violated the natural order), and from some Starfleet crew members, who treat him with suspicion or outright hostility.

The climax of the book starts when ak Renao reports some of his childhood friends as distributing fliers for the terrorist group. The joint away team sent to investigate, the starfleet officers deliberately decide to defer to the klingons, who will be more brutal with their interrogations (and end up killing the civilians).
Meanwhile, main bridge crew members of the prometheus who are sent to investigate get kidnapped and used as hostages by a terrorist cell.

The information the Klingons extracted from the civilians is used to pinpoint the location of the cell, and an extraction team is sent. They escape on black market shuttles with experimental propulsion technology, and nearly escape with the hostages, but during the space battle the starfleet officers free themselves by fighting and get beamed back just before their ship explodes.

Spock mind melds with one of the captured terrorists, and determines that their mind was influenced by some mysterious force which prevents them from seeing right from wrong. If only the troubles of the modern day could be so easily explained. I do think that the underlying cultural tension of the Renao's culture with the federation is still well done, and clearly not all Renao are affected by this force.

I am looking forward to starting the next one.
 
The climax of the book starts when ak Renao reports some of his childhood friends as distributing fliers for the terrorist group. The joint away team sent to investigate, the starfleet officers deliberately decide to defer to the klingons, who will be more brutal with their interrogations (and end up killing the civilians).
Meanwhile, main bridge crew members of the prometheus who are sent to investigate get kidnapped and used as hostages by a terrorist cell.
Based on this paragraph...does the book then give the impression that torture works to get actionable intelligence?
 
Based on this paragraph...does the book then give the impression that torture works to get actionable intelligence?
That's a fair point. I think the intelligence could have theoretically been gotten by anyone, since it was essentially from a couple of just out of college young adults that weren't very high up in the organization. The cruelty of the klingons doing it is there mostly to show moral slippage of the starfleet officers, in my opinion.

In reality, these are the kinds of people that probably wouldn't have operational security to have access to the knowledge of the secret base, there probably would be a middle man.
 
Based on this paragraph...does the book then give the impression that torture works to get actionable intelligence?
It does. The books are pretty bad, and especially they totally fail to sell their new cast. Captain Adams is always telling the Klingons what they should not do, but very rarely seems to have any actual ideas for what anyone should be doing.
 
It does. The books are pretty bad, and especially they totally fail to sell their new cast. Captain Adams is always telling the Klingons what they should not do, but very rarely seems to have any actual ideas for what anyone should be doing.
Honestly, the "torture can be a good thing!" part bothers me more than the rest of it, especially in this day and age. :|
 
(I've also now read Stevil's review) These are all fair critiques, I definitely didn't feel really connected to Captain Adams, but thought Jenna Kirk and Lenissa zh'thiin at least had some characterization. I agree that rhozhenko doesn't get to do much either. Maybe I just have poor taste and liked that "something" was always happening.

I definitely felt upset about the Starfleet officers deferring/taking a blind eye to distasteful Klingon tactics, but I suppose I myself turned a blind eye to that part when thinking about the quality of the books.

There's two more books to go, we'll see if I sour on them or they get better.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top