• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Mr Robot is Coming.

Guy Gardener

Fleet Admiral
Admiral
Mr. Robot.

USA released online the pilot of Mr. Robot a month early.

Elliot is a computer security annalist, who has medium level social anxiety that manifests as contempt, a controllable drug habit, and is either involved in two competing plots to save or control the world unless he is suffering delusional paranoid hallucinations he should be taking medication for.

It's the classic dichotomousity that his day job (security expert) is at odds with his night time hobby (anarchist hacker), as the drama comes from how difficultly those two versions of Elliot grate against each other.

Enigmatic Christian Slater (Mr Robot) invites our hero to join an elite hacking group, simultaneously as the Princes of the Universe (The 10 richest men in America?) invite him to hunt down and destroy Mr Robot, but it all might not be real because Elliot could be in his room with the lights turned off rocking back and forth, dribbling.

USA has a ten episode commitment, and I'm intrigued to see where that takes us.
 
I enjoyed the pilot, too.

The lead is mesmerizing with his unique look and erratic narration. I remember him from 24 and the Pacific miniseries on HBO. He's finally found a role that really plays to his strengths here.

The pilot looked like it was filmed by David Fincher's cinematographer from Gone Girl or the Social Network. Hopefully the series can maintain this level of style for the entire run.

The main character's POV is quite interesting. He reminds me of an unreliable Chuck Palahniuk narrator. His inner diatribe on Steve Jobs and Corporate culture was loud and manic but the things he doesn't say are just as powerful. Hiding under his hoodie on the subway, the way he pulls from people touching him -- his physical performance speaks volumes.

If the rest of the series is like this, then consider me hooked.
 
I posted this review/promo in TNZ, but I'll post it here too.

I highly recommend the new series Mr. Robot that will premiere on USA Network Wednesday, June 24th. It sort of came out of nowhere to win the Audience Award at this year's SXSW and it's got quite a lot of buzz and good reviews from the pilot, which you can watch online here or here on YouTube.

Mr. Robot is an upcoming American drama psychological thriller television series created by Sam Esmail that follows Elliot, a young programmer (Malek), who works as a cyber security engineer by day and a vigilante hacker by night. Elliot finds himself at a crossroads when the mysterious leader of an underground hacker group recruits him to destroy the corporation he is paid to protect. Compelled by his personal beliefs, Elliot struggles to resist the chance to take down the multinational CEOs he believes are running (and ruining) the world. The pilot episode was written by Esmail and directed by Niels Arden Oplev.
If you prefer a preview first, you can watch a four-minute sneak peak here.

Here's a glowing Forbes review calling it "The Best New Show of the Summer and On-Track to be a Modern Classic" which is all the more remarkable because it's explicitly a show about taking down "the corrupt 1% that's ruining the country."

Some spoilers about the plot follow, so read at your own risk.


The show is noteworthy for being one of the few shows or movies that depicts hacking in a mostly realistic way (at least, from my limited layman's perspective). There are no ridiculously elaborate user interfaces and there's no godlike ability to get in anywhere in an instant, and you're expected to have a basic grasp of the tech involved with minimum explanation, or at least be able to look it up (though I did find it questionable that a senior supervisor of a cyber-security firm had to have what a rootkit is explained to her, but that was mostly for the audience's benefit, and the only time they did that). As the review on The Verge says:

So there I was, watching the pilot and making notes for what I fully expected to be a "7 ways Mr. Robot doesn’t understand computers" piece, when I suddenly found myself… impressed. Instead of the camera zooming through the innards of a laptop, there was Elliot, typing in a terminal window. Instead of using magical computer-god powers to find somebody’s phone number, he walked up to them and got it with some good old-fashioned social engineering. And when Elliot eventually did try to use a program to break into an account, he collected personal information about the subject to speed up the brute force attack — and then it didn’t even work.

A lot of that attention to detail comes courtesy of creator and executive producer Sam Esmail, who, it turns out, has similar feelings about the way computers have been portrayed in the past. "I’m sorry, but every movie and show about hacking is so fucking terrible!" he said in the post-screening Q&A. "And they feel like they have to do all these CGI graphics, and you’re like, ‘Hacking doesn’t look anything remotely like that.’ I’m sorry, Chris Hemsworth does not look like a hacker."
The show has a very unsettling atmosphere to it, a lot of which is delivered by an excellent, subdued, almost otherworldy turn by the lead, Rami Malek. He was great in The Pacific as well, and is basically responsible for carrying the show, at least in the pilot. Christian Slater is the titular Mr. Robot, head of the hacker group Malek's character Elliot reluctantly joins at the end of the pilot, so his role will likely grow, but so far as of the pilot, everything is told from Elliot's perspective. Christian Slater is great for snark, but he's kind of become the new Ted McGinley for killing off shows that I like, so hopefully that doesn't happen here as well.

Elliot is almost certainly on the spectrum, and will often be off in his own thoughts while people are talking to him. He also has hallucinations that confuse him, which leads to some scenes that would be home in Fight Club or They Live (the corporation his cyber-security firm is protecting that Elliot plans to bring down is called E-Corp, but he's convinced himself in his mind that it's Evil Corp, and so the logos and signs around the office and the city start to actually say that). He's also a regular heroin user, so he has some issues to work out to say the least.

Elliot is an anti-hero with zero personal boundaries, despite not liking to be touched himself. He hacks his psychiatrist's computer because he's concerned about her. He knows it's wrong, but justifies it to himself in that he's trying to protect her from her douchebag boyfriend. He does the same with his childhood friend and coworker because he knows her boyfriend is cheating on her. There's an extra bit of squickiness there in that he obviously has feelings for her, though whether he's capable of dealing with relationships in that way remains to be seen. But they don't shy away from acknowledging that while this guy mostly does good and his heart's in the right place, he's got some real creepy stalkerish qualities to him as well that maybe a result of him not fully grasping social norms.

Anyway, I give the pilot an "A" and recommend it highly. If you like Halt and Catch Fire, Fight Club, or Person of Interest, I think you'd enjoy this.
 
This show feels a lot like Dexter for a few reasons:

-Elliot's narration of the world and the people he is involved with, is very much how it Dexter was narrating it.

-Elliot keeps a CD collection of his personal hacks in much the same way Dexter kept blood slides from his kills.

-Elliott works for a company that is trying to investigate hacks that is Elliot is involved with on a personal level somehow (Mr. Robots Group). Dexter works for the police department who investigates deaths that Dexter is some times involved with on a personal level.

-Elliott has socialization issues, Dexter has socialization issues.

It is pretty interesting so I will watch more.
 
Since a big deal was made about Elliott's condition, some people are already speculating that there is no Christian Slater and Elliott is Mr. Robot because Slater didn't interact with anyone else in the pilot, not even the hacking team. What do you think?
 
I love it when a show uses a lot of actual unix terminal commands such as sudo, chmod, ps, cat, grep and so on. The only command I don't recognize is astsu and astu. Does anyone know they do?
 
Since a big deal was made about Elliott's condition, some people are already speculating that there is no Christian Slater and Elliott is Mr. Robot because Slater didn't interact with anyone else in the pilot, not even the hacking team. What do you think?

Hmmm, that would be interesting, but perhaps a little too on the nose with the Fight Club comparisons, when it's already alluded to pretty heavily between the anti-consumerist rebels, hallucinations, and tone? I guess I could see it as the manifestation of his more confident, outgoing, and snarky self, which Slater fits perfectly.
 
Elliot is only 50/50 on what he is seeing, so it's now funny that he doesn't believe real things that are happening because he has that much faith in his imagination to out think himself. :)

He's probably seen Fight club as often as the worst of us have.

And isn't Portia Doubleday fantastic in every ting that she does?

She was hilarious as a bunny boiler on Mr. Sunshine.
 
Caught the pilot yesterday. There's a lot to admire. It's well-written and well-made, feeling more like a movie than a TV show. I like its emphatic anti-one-percenter stance, even if it puts it in the mouth of an unreliable narrator. I respect that it portrays hacking realistically, although that puts me in the somewhat unfamiliar position of being the viewer who's bewildered and occasionally bored by the technobabble. I love it that it has an Arab-American lead actor instead of just another white dude. (And he's a Legend of Korra veteran! Rami Malek played the obnoxious pro-bender Tahno.) I felt it was sensitive to diverse outlooks, including the bit where the female lead got angry at the male lead for trying to defend her rather than letting her succeed or fail on her own. And it's nice to see Gloria Reuben again; I still remember her from her recurring role in the 1990 The Flash.

Still, I respect it more than I enjoy it. It's probably a little too dark, humorless, and morally gray for me, and I'm tired of shows with drug-using protagonists, and just the whole trope of the lead character who's the most screwed-up, dysfunctional person in the show. It's also hard to assess what to make of the show's overall premise when the pilot ended on a cliffhanger like that. I think that's lazy, to rely on dangling questions to keep viewers coming back rather than giving answers that are interesting enough to make us want more. As of the end of the pilot, I'm not confident that I can say what this show is actually about. So I'm not sure how interested I'd be in seeing more.
 
Well here's something you don't hear every day. Mr. Robot has already been renewed for season 2. :beer:
 
Has it actually premiered on the air? My wife & I saw it On Demand. Ratings were that good?

My main concern is -- how LONG can this show go on? The premise just seems like it's a limited amount of story you can realistically tell.

Malek acts it very well.... now, if Mr. Robot turns out to be a real person -- wow...
 
Has it actually premiered on the air?

Last night, I believe.


My wife & I saw it On Demand. Ratings were that good?

Sometimes a show will be renewed before the premiere based on advance buzz, or if the network feels really good about it. In this case, given the subject matter of the show, it stands to reason that a lot of the audience would be online, so I expect USA is paying a lot of attention to online viewing figures.


My main concern is -- how LONG can this show go on? The premise just seems like it's a limited amount of story you can realistically tell.

I'm still not clear on what the premise is going to be, because of how the episode just abruptly ended. I suppose the continuation of that meeting scene will reveal a lot about where things go from here -- which is the sort of thing that should've come at the end of the pilot, not been put off until episode 2.
 
I'm still not clear on what the premise is going to be, because of how the episode just abruptly ended. I suppose the continuation of that meeting scene will reveal a lot about where things go from here -- which is the sort of thing that should've come at the end of the pilot, not been put off until episode 2.

It's going to be a continuation of what Elliot was already doing or considering doing but on a grander scale. The primary arc of taking down E(vil)-Corp from the inside, and standalone stories of lesser acts of helping people or taking down corrupt, criminal, and cruel One Percenters by using hacking and data mining.

If the preliminary speculation about Christian Slater turning out to be a hallucinatory figment of Elliot's mind (ala' Fight Club - whose themes and style were heavily mimicked in the pilot) meant to represent a more charismatic version of Elliot that he puts forward to recruit others, and Mr. Robot turning out to be Elliot's own hacker alias ends up being true, that would further explain why Mr. Robot's group's goals align so perfectly with Elliot's own.

We'll have to wait and see how Slater interacts with Elliot and others in the next episode to see if he's real or just imaginary. Like if he references recent events Elliot wasn't present for and can't know about.
 
It's going to be a continuation of what Elliot was already doing or considering doing but on a grander scale. The primary arc of taking down E(vil)-Corp from the inside, and standalone stories of lesser acts of helping people or taking down corrupt, criminal, and cruel One Percenters by using hacking and data mining.

It could be, but going just from the pilot alone, knowing nothing about what might've been said in interviews, I can't say for sure. I mean, bringing him in for a meeting with that young executive guy who noticed him before has got to go somewhere, but where? It won't end up with him getting exposed. So what will it be? What role will that executive guy end up playing? I'd like to think the show will be daring enough to stick to its anti-corporate guns, but given that the people who pay for the show to be made and aired are themselves corporate executives, I wouldn't be surprised if there were a note of ambiguity introduced. Maybe Elliot will be convinced that bringing on a corporate apocalypse would ultimately be harmful and will be recruited to work against Mr. Robot (if he exists). It's just hard to tell at this point. Cliffhangers are overused these days, and in this case it works against the purpose of a pilot, because at this point I don't really know where the show is going next or what role all the characters will play.
 
I started watching the pilot again last night. When Christian Slater makes his debut and hollers at Elliott from the other side of the subway car, no one pays any attention to him except the extra sitting beside him. Don't know if that was an accident or intentional, or just plain unimportant because Mr. Robot is real and people are just reading too much into it.
 
Looking at where the noise comes from on a subway, is a fine way to see two people pissing on each other again.
 
I started watching the pilot again last night. When Christian Slater makes his debut and hollers at Elliott from the other side of the subway car, no one pays any attention to him except the extra sitting beside him. Don't know if that was an accident or intentional, or just plain unimportant because Mr. Robot is real and people are just reading too much into it.

Yeah, that can either mean he's fake or it can just be indicative of the fact that people riding on subways often make it a habit of ignoring everyone around them lest they draw the attention of some creep.
 
Slater also did have that one scene where he harassed the alleged men in black who may or may not have been following Elliot.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top