• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

John Stewart or Hal Jordan

Choose a Lantern


  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .
Fine. So I'll look forward to the Static Shock summer blockbuster. In the meantime, I'm black and I have absolutely no problem with Hal Jordan being the focus of the movie, given he's the most famous Green Lantern.

Which is fine. TBPH I'm a big Green Lantern fan; the movie could star a CG G'Nort or Jack Black as Kyle Rayner for I all care, I'll still shell out the $$ to see it and probably be disappointed if the current trailer is any indication.

There is a generation of kids out there who only know Jon Stewart as Green Lantern becuase of the Justice League animated series.

Besides, does Hal actually have a personality. I know it doesn't resemble Ryan Reynold's personality and he's incapable of playing any character other than Ryan Reynolds.

It is your second point that made me think of this, though we may have more comic readers than other sites. I wonder if there might have been more general audience connection using Stewart instead of Jordan as there may be more folks familiar with the franchise through TV than the book?

I wonder if they did any sort of polling, actually.

it's a good question.

And I think part of their reasoning, might have been fear of a black lead. Yep. I said it. When was the last time they put a few hundred million dollars into a movie with an African American lead?

This could've been an opportunity for the WB.

However, you don't risk this much money on the idea of racial diversity.

I think they could've done it with Stewart, though.
 
Comedy, courtesy of Cracked:

grn4.jpg
 
Which is fine. TBPH I'm a big Green Lantern fan; the movie could star a CG G'Nort or Jack Black as Kyle Rayner for I all care, I'll still shell out the $$ to see it and probably be disappointed if the current trailer is any indication.

There is a generation of kids out there who only know Jon Stewart as Green Lantern becuase of the Justice League animated series.

Besides, does Hal actually have a personality. I know it doesn't resemble Ryan Reynold's personality and he's incapable of playing any character other than Ryan Reynolds.

It is your second point that made me think of this, though we may have more comic readers than other sites. I wonder if there might have been more general audience connection using Stewart instead of Jordan as there may be more folks familiar with the franchise through TV than the book?

I wonder if they did any sort of polling, actually.

it's a good question.

And I think part of their reasoning, might have been fear of a black lead. Yep. I said it. When was the last time they put a few hundred million dollars into a movie with an African American lead?

This could've been an opportunity for the WB.

However, you don't risk this much money on the idea of racial diversity.

I think they could've done it with Stewart, though.
I believe Will Smith's film Hancock did pretty well. I enjoyed it and thought he'd make a great John Stewart when I was thinking of this thread.
 
I think outside of comic book fans, "the most famous Green Lantern" is pretty relative. He's a second-tier superhero who most people in the audience will be seeing for the first time in the new movie.
 
Ch'p.

I'm thinking that Will's style and cool hasn't changed since 1992.

The modern black man, gods forbid he modern black child, might think, will think that Will Smith is a Dinosaur.

Whitey is still learning how to talk jive.
 
I've always been on the fence about John Stewart ever since he was picked for the Justice League cartoon over Jordan. Are there any really good John Stewart stories in the comics that could help win me over?
 
I've always been on the fence about John Stewart ever since he was picked for the Justice League cartoon over Jordan. Are there any really good John Stewart stories in the comics that could help win me over?

7996.jpg


You of course know that Star Sapphire murdered his wife. So John is grieving over her grave and tells his magic ring to fuck off. This whole space police thing has fucked up his life (Lethal Weapon a little?). Twelve seconds later South African Commandos (not from actually South Africa, just white supremacists from the South of Africa. An allegory. It was the 80s.) jump him, bag him, and air mail John back to "the South of Africa" where he is imprisoned and tortured (literally tortured, we see the beatings and simulated drownings.) for the Crimes of Green Lantern committed in the 1960s (our time). That's right, until they legally could prove that there was more than one Green Lantern, John was being locked away for shit Hal Jordan did. he had to steal a big diamond to save the world. Hal actually shows up in John's prison (walking through walls skiting about how cool it to be above the law) offering the convict a new ring so that John can escape "Justice" and the word "nigger criminal" can be put on posters with his face on it for the next 50 years in Post Offices across the planet. John took his beatings every morning and evening waiting for his day in court to prove that he is a good man and that these crackers are complete bastards so that he can be righteously vindicated and maybe they'll try to extricate Jordan if they can be bothered putting a white guy in jail. Where's the irony in locking up a white guy for crimes he actually committed?

A little heavy handed?

Jordan could have surrendered himself at any moment and fixed everything. Selfish deushbag too arrogant to accept the consequences of his actions. (But how would that have pushed the story along.) but after a month of being treated like punching bag butt monkey, I think they started to torture (innocent) people in front of him, thinking that that would break John and they'd have their very own pet Green Lantern who would go on television every night and assure the world that white people are better than black people.

"Ring! get the fuck back here now!" He says and it Zang! It was back.

John pulls the prison to pieces in seconds.

Joins a peaceful group of political dissidents.

The absolute worst thing he did was stack a dozen government cars, limos one on top of one another.

Hal Jordan shows up, pomposity personified, and orders Stewart that he can't show up a sovereign nation, of course Hal didn't kill John, so the South African's get Superman in on the act as well claiming that John is a terrorist and they demand that he's removed form their borders as harshly as possible and they can trust Superman to do the right thing because he's the whitest person on the planet.

Then some more stuff happens.

This was an 80s comic.

Before Warren Ellis had America falling to his superhero junta.

Almost as provocative as it was blunt.

Green Lantern Special.

Good read.

Mosaic (Johns very own series) was fabulous.

18 issues I think.
 
Another favorite for Stewart would be Michael Clarke Duncan, a fine and under-appreciated actor. Also, a beautifully powerful speaking voice I could listen to all day.
 
It is your second point that made me think of this, though we may have more comic readers than other sites. I wonder if there might have been more general audience connection using Stewart instead of Jordan as there may be more folks familiar with the franchise through TV than the book?

I wonder if they did any sort of polling, actually.

it's a good question.

And I think part of their reasoning, might have been fear of a black lead. Yep. I said it. When was the last time they put a few hundred million dollars into a movie with an African American lead?

This could've been an opportunity for the WB.

However, you don't risk this much money on the idea of racial diversity.

I think they could've done it with Stewart, though.
I believe Will Smith's film Hancock did pretty well. I enjoyed it and thought he'd make a great John Stewart when I was thinking of this thread.

Yeah, I thought about Smith after I wrote that. But, then, he sorta makes my point. He's the ONLY one.


And I think part of their reasoning, might have been fear of a black lead. Yep. I said it. When was the last time they put a few hundred million dollars into a movie with an African American lead?

2008, actually.

Hancock ($150 million)


Also 2007: I Am Legend ($150 million)

And 2003: Bad Boys II ($130 million)

And 1999: Wild Wild West ($170 million)

They do have something else in common though (quality or lack thereof aside)...

Again, he's the only one. And it's been 3 years since Hancock... And then it's Will Smith staring at the Green Lantern... would the studio want that? I'm not sure... And Will Smith is expensive.

I don't know.

I remember when there was the rumor that Common was going to play Stewart in the Justice League movie, and I loved that. Would've liked to see him as Stewart.
 
I think outside of comic book fans, "the most famous Green Lantern" is pretty relative. He's a second-tier superhero who most people in the audience will be seeing for the first time in the new movie.

This is pretty much true.

If you're going to cast Stewart, you get Smith if he's available and you can afford him - every other option is inferior from a commercial standpoint.
 
Here's his wikipedia entry that gives a brief fictional biography and mentions some of the more important events that John has been involved with. I think Denzel Washington would be a great choice to play Stewart. I don't know if Denzel would be interested but he's the first person I think of when thinking of actors to play John.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stewart_(comics)#Early_years

There are other black actors out there, and to be a bit frank, Denzel is quite old to be playing John Stewart (and may not even want to.)

Now, if only I could think of anybody else in the same age group as Ryan Reynolds that could play John Stewart... could anybody help me out here?
 
I'd rather of had a Green Lantern Corps movie featuring:
-Guy Garner
-Kyle Rainer
-John Stewart
-Hal Jordan
-Kilowog
-etc.

Hopefully that's what we'll get in the sequel.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top