• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is the doctor a real person?

Is the doctor a real person

  • Yes

    Votes: 28 57.1%
  • No

    Votes: 19 38.8%
  • I don't know, I'm confused, error

    Votes: 2 4.1%

  • Total voters
    49
He may have carried around a bag of pig shit now and then, but the lawns were probably cut with phasers, and he had to look after hundreds of robots and thousands of drones to keep an eye on the campus for unsightliness.
 
He may have carried around a bag of pig shit now and then, but the lawns were probably cut with phasers, and he had to look after hundreds of robots and thousands of drones to keep an eye on the campus for unsightliness.

After he dies the replacement gardener, a Bio Park Engineer, will maintain the entire grounds from a control booth and never so much get his feet muddy.

The luddites will talk about how the real soul of gardening is gone now that there is no person of the soil.

Perhaps they will install a figurehead gardener to wander about with a little spade, as a bit of window dressing for visiting dignitaries.
 
I am assuming the real work is done by robots or machines or whatever. Given how efficient Boothby's (sp?) work is, it would take like a thousand like him to tend to the grounds.
 
I was more thinking Barbara Streisand.

But when women sit on Pinocchio's face so that he can tell lies, you can imagine resentment building that the local women only value him for his nose.

"You're not fat, and very, very beautiful and your ass acne is not turning me gay."
 
Once again, there are some who DIDN'T read the TOPIC on this thread.

Who?

What do you mean? You mean the conversation derailment?

Threads would get very dry if they didn't veer off in various unrelated directions (I always thought it was the OP's responsibility to bring it back on topic.....which I like to think I did rather successfully despite the three or four pages of food and marriage talk)

Because we're real people?

And we're people who need people (who are, in many ways the luckiest people in the world)
 
If you consider the doctor to be a real person every other topic of conversation can potentially relate to him.

How upsetting would it be to inhabit 7's body and eat all that food and also do who knows what during bathroom breaks and then BAM. Back to photons.

The doctor would like to be a wine snob, a cuisine connoisseur, but he can not. The best he can manage is to pump out factlets like the ship's computer and adjectives other people have come up with to describe taste. These limitations must surely drive him mad.
 
Humans are basically complex computers when you think about it.

Regardless of how he was created and who created him, he was sentient.
+1 well said.

Additionally, I think that average healthy specimens of lifeforms should be able to keep themselves alive. A human should be able to feed himself/herself. A hologram should be able to take care of its energy demand and holomatrix technoblahblah. I think the doc would do fine.
 
Yes, I believe we did see Captain Braxton picking through garbage cans for his next meal.

Mentally healthy Braxton at the end, after the end, do you think he volunteered to be integrated with banana pants old man Braxton, because it was probably his contractual duty, or was he held down while it was done to him?

More cooking/chemistry than meat-computer programming.
 
I was more thinking Barbara Streisand.

But when women sit on Pinocchio's face so that he can tell lies, you can imagine resentment building that the local women only value him for his nose.

"You're not fat, and very, very beautiful and your ass acne is not turning me gay."

Actually the real kick they get is by getting him to alternate lies and truths...
 
How upsetting would it be to inhabit 7's body and eat all that food and also do who knows what during bathroom breaks and then BAM. Back to photons. .

What exactly did he feel when he was in control of sevens body? He eats cheesecake then marvels at its taste but how would his programming interpret taste. Surely it could only go so far....unless he was in control of Seven's actual physical body (rather than just her mental presence through the Borg implants) the more I think about that episode, the more mind bendy it gets

Additionally, I think that average healthy specimens of lifeforms should be able to keep themselves alive. A human should be able to feed himself/herself. A hologram should be able to take care of its energy demand and holomatrix technoblahblah. I think the doc would do fine.

Program the doctor to think he's a shaved baboon called Keith and leave him on a planet and I suspect he'll only survive as long as he's got power. I'm amazed so many people want to see him as a genuine sapient life form. We all love the doctor but let's not let out hearts rule our heads people. He's a trick of the light

Having said that, I'm pleased to see the no vote is as high as it is

Actually the real kick they get is by getting him to alternate lies and truths...

You'd have to tell alternate lies and truths quite quickly to make it worth your while, surely
 
How upsetting would it be to inhabit 7's body and eat all that food and also do who knows what during bathroom breaks and then BAM. Back to photons. .

What exactly did he feel when he was in control of sevens body? He eats cheesecake then marvels at its taste but how would his programming interpret taste. Surely it could only go so far....unless he was in control of Seven's actual physical body (rather than just her mental presence through the Borg implants) the more I think about that episode, the more mind bendy it gets

Additionally, I think that average healthy specimens of lifeforms should be able to keep themselves alive. A human should be able to feed himself/herself. A hologram should be able to take care of its energy demand and holomatrix technoblahblah. I think the doc would do fine.

Program the doctor to think he's a shaved baboon called Keith and leave him on a planet and I suspect he'll only survive as long as he's got power. I'm amazed so many people want to see him as a genuine sapient life form. We all love the doctor but let's not let out hearts rule our heads people. He's a trick of the light

Having said that, I'm pleased to see the no vote is as high as it is

Actually the real kick they get is by getting him to alternate lies and truths...

You'd have to tell alternate lies and truths quite quickly to make it worth your while, surely

In the end it could be a series of yeses and noes answering the same yes or no question...
 
Create a thousand partitions. Copy the doctors program 999 times. Put each copy into into a different partition. Ask each identical copy a thousand identical questions, if they are not "real" they will all produce 1000 identical answers.
 
Create a thousand partitions. Copy the doctors program 999 times. Put each copy into into a different partition. Ask each identical copy a thousand identical questions, if they are not "real" they will all produce 1000 identical answers.

What if the doctor is equipped with a randomization function based on subspace noise or whatever?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top