• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is Amy even "real?" Possible Spoilers

I knew the Duck Pond was important! It doesn't even actually exist - it was put in by the show for some reason - which means it's important.

No, it means that Moffat wrote a joke about a duck pond in the script. It's not like it was any more effort than making all the signs say "Leadworth" or making sure they got a car with keyless entry for Amy to lock the Doctor's tie in, or stocking the refrigerator with custard and fishsticks. Everything in film is artificial. Someone put it there deliberately. Even the fake duck ponds. Even the inconsequential fake duckponds.
 
In The Eleventh Hour, the Doctor returned briefly to young Amelia Pond a second time, while she was waiting outside, but then he instantly (from our perspective) went back to the present, albeit two years out.

What did he do in the past the second time? I missed it, or tuned out, or something.
 
~shrug~ Let's really go all out and saw Amy might be a projection of the TARDIS's mind, an avatar for the ship created by all the pain it went through and is going through.
 
I knew the Duck Pond was important! It doesn't even actually exist - it was put in by the show for some reason - which means it's important.

No, it means that Moffat wrote a joke about a duck pond in the script. It's not like it was any more effort than making all the signs say "Leadworth" or making sure they got a car with keyless entry for Amy to lock the Doctor's tie in, or stocking the refrigerator with custard and fishsticks. Everything in film is artificial. Someone put it there deliberately. Even the fake duck ponds. Even the inconsequential fake duckponds.

we shall see... care for a wager?
 
~shrug~ Let's really go all out and saw Amy might be a projection of the TARDIS's mind, an avatar for the ship created by all the pain it went through and is going through.

Well it is ginger.

Maybe it picked up on his whining about not being ginger so it made him something ginger to play with.

Lucky git.
 
Oh - I also just caught Amy's "I never could resist a keep out sign." She easily picked a lock, as if she does that a lot.
She's a strippergram who dresses up as a police woman. It's sod's law that at some point a fat businessman's ended up handcuffed to a chair with his trousers down and the little key's gone missing.
 
In The Eleventh Hour, the Doctor returned briefly to young Amelia Pond a second time, while she was waiting outside, but then he instantly (from our perspective) went back to the present, albeit two years out.

What did he do in the past the second time? I missed it, or tuned out, or something.

Until proven otherwise, that was just adult Amy's dream.
 
Amelia Jessica Pond = "no maid escapes jail"

Now that's interesting. The main bit could refer to her impending wedding. Though didn't she also make a comment in The Eleventh Hour about having to decide between a police or maid costume? As for the jail bit, well that's obvious given the nature of the crack in her wall.
 
Anyone notice the blue lens flare that traveled across the screen when Amy had the Doctor's tie in the car door? He takes hold of her arm and says to her "trust him for 20 minutes. " Very strange place for a lens flare effect. Also, I REALLY like the music in The Eleventh Hour. best wishes, wws
 
Last edited:
I woke up with the thought that Amy is also a Time Lord, she just doesnt remember that she is. Don't know why now, but it made sense when i first thought it.

Maybe she came through the crack in the wall like Prisoner Zero.
 
I woke up with the thought that Amy is also a Time Lord, she just doesnt remember that she is. Don't know why now, but it made sense when i first thought it.

Maybe she came through the crack in the wall like Prisoner Zero.
Amy was a real a little girl. The crack is a fracture caused by Rassilon breaking the Time Lock on the Time War-- remember 10 said all of it was coming back if Gallifrey returned. Amy is a orphan of Gallifrey; a child of a Time Lord family, who used a Chamleon arch on her in order to hide her from the Dalek and Rassilon's followers.
 
Oh - I also just caught Amy's "I never could resist a keep out sign." She easily picked a lock, as if she does that a lot.
She's a strippergram who dresses up as a police woman. It's sod's law that at some point a fat businessman's ended up handcuffed to a chair with his trousers down and the little key's gone missing.

Talking from experience there then?

And she's a kissogram, not a strippergram.
 
Hasn't Moffat gone on record saying that he doesn't want the time lords?
It would be a bit odd for him to say that only to bring one in as a companion.
 
I really think they will give the whole Chamleon Arch a rest, most since it is an RTD plot device and not moffets
 
I really think they will give the whole Chamleon Arch a rest, most since it is an RTD plot device and not moffets

Yeah, it was a great idea but I really hope it isn't used again, or at least not for many years.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top