• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Interesting quirk: we're three for three on episode titles being spoken in dialogue.

I noticed it too. And the Butcher's Knife title sounds extremely grim. I expect much death.
 
I wish they'd come up with a better name for the battle than "Battle at the Binary Stars." At least a third of all star systems are binary or multiple, so calling something "the binary stars" does not even begin to narrow down a specific location. It's like calling something "the Battle of the Hill." Also, a two-star system is conventionally called a binary star rather than binary stars.

Ahhhhhhhh the life of a Trek fan...........
 
I figure it took place in a binary system, like the one Janeway flew her ship through in Scientific Method.

Well, yes, that was clearly stated in dialogue and shown in numerous VFX shots throughout the first two episodes. There's no mystery to that. It's just that binary star systems are so incredibly common that it's too vague a location designator.
 
It's very common these days for episode titles to be taken from a line of dialogue spoken in a key scene of the episode. Walking Dead and Fear the Walking Dead are especially guilty of this titling practice.
oh man, my favorite line of dialogue from DS9 was when Captain Sisko went all "inter arma enim silent leges" on Admiral Ross' ass
I think you mean Dr. Bashir.
 
I'm just floored by the fact that we're actually having episode titles which are COMPLETE SENTENCES. Have we ever had that since, I dunno, "For The World Is Hollow And I Have Touched The Sky"? :D

Speaking of... "For the world is hollow and I have touched the sky" was also spoken in that episode.
 
I noticed it too. And the Butcher's Knife title sounds extremely grim. I expect much death.

Saru, is that you?

Well, yes, that was clearly stated in dialogue and shown in numerous VFX shots throughout the first two episodes. There's no mystery to that. It's just that binary star systems are so incredibly common that it's too vague a location designator.

You would think that the star with a listening post would have a name, or at least an identifier, even if it was something like "J-25" (although how J-25 can identify a star system by itself is another question, assuming the numbers ony go up to say 10,000 that's still a mere 260,000 stars. There's about 80 million within 2000 light years of earth, and J-25 was 7kly away)
 
For what it's worth, I'm liking the titles of the eps so far (even if they don't actually appear on screen). I always found the more flowery TOS titles more memorable than the dull one-word titles that were so common on the latter-day shows: "Cathexis," "Divergence," "Descent," etc.
I think it was Starlog or one of the other magazines with Trek coverage that did a grid which had TOS episode titles, then what they would have been in TNG, DS9 and VOY. It was funny, because when you look at the VOY column, they were all one word titles.
 
At least Voyager titles weren't always one word. They had their share of longer titles, including three with 5 words ("The Q and the Gray," "Someone to Watch Over Me," and "The Haunting of Deck Twelve") and seven with 4 words ("Eye of the Needle," "Message in a Bottle," "Once Upon a Time," "Barge of the Dead," "Tinker, Tenor, Doctor, Spy," "Blink of an Eye," "Live Fast and Prosper" -- not counting 2-word titles followed by "Part I" or "Part II"), and a fair number with 2-3 words. The season with the shortest average title length was season 2, with only five very short 2-word titles ("The 37s," "Non Sequitur," "Cold Fire," "Death Wish," "The Thaw") and one 3-word title ("Persistence of Vision"). Season 7 was close, with eight 2-word titles and two 3-word titles. Seasons 2 and 7 were the only ones with no titles longer than 3 words.

What bugs me is something like Smallville, where every episode was required to have a one-word title. It got really labored and tedious after a while. The one exception was the season-9 two-parter that was promoted by the network as "Absolute Justice" and is apparently officially referred to that way on the DVDs and episode guides, but that was originally just a promotional label for a pair of episodes with one-word titles.
 
I still think the reference to lambs' cry and butcher's knife is an allusion to William Blake's "Auguries of Innocence." Perhaps the poem will figure into the episode somehow.

Kor
 
I still think the reference to lambs' cry and butcher's knife is an allusion to William Blake's "Auguries of Innocence." Perhaps the poem will figure into the episode somehow.

I dunno about that... the similarity is vague enough that they could just both be referencing some wider cultural metaphor. But on the other hand, the opening lines of the poem...
To see a World in a Grain of Sand
And a Heaven in a Wild Flower
Hold Infinity in the palm of your hand
And Eternity in an hour
...sound a lot like what Stamets was saying about the theory underlying the Spore Drive.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top