• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

In the mirror universe, would evil races/peoples be good?

...although I just realized that the MU theme argues that individual choice is an illusion and we're all at the total mercy of our environment. We're all the Borg. :eek:
Mirror Spock: "One man cannot summon the future."
James T. Kirk: "But one man can change the present."
 
...although I just realized that the MU theme argues that individual choice is an illusion and we're all at the total mercy of our environment. We're all the Borg. :eek:
Mirror Spock: "One man cannot summon the future."
James T. Kirk: "But one man can change the present."

Sorta, kinda, not really in the way most people think when they ask this question. I think it's delusional to follow the thinking that "you can go out there into the world" (where exactly?) and change it (to suit your megalomania).

It's as much chance as skill. No stranger to megalomania, Napoleon said, "I am the instrument of providence, she will use me as long as I accomplish her designs, then she will break me like a glass."

If it were just a matter of skill, well, there are 6 billion people on the planet - many of whom are far more capable individuals than Napoleon Bonaparte - yet he was the last great emperor of France. He wasn't millions of times the human being his millions of subjects were. He just filled the role they needed of him that he was prepared to produce.

Movies, literature, they hyperbolize the extent to which individuals can and do change things to the nth degree. I think it's disrespectful of the complexity of the world and dehumanizing of the capacities of us all.

As for if the world needs changing...I think the aggregate of everybody's actions exposes what's at the core of the human heart. This moment in history (and nature too), this level of social and technological ascent out of the primordial pool, and it wouldn't matter who's at the helm - you'd get this world. I think I know better but heck, how much do I know myself really, let alone everyone else, let alone everything else, let a alone what next years crops will be like or market index numbers. I know a thing or two about how an office works, science fiction, and my family and friends and I try my best and hopefully what I throw out there helps.
 
If good people in the real universe are the opposite in the mirror universe (such as an evil mirror Kira, or an evil mirror Spock), then would evil people in the real universe be good persons in the mirror universe?

So, would persons such as Dukat, Seska or even Lore if he existed be good? What about the Founders, or even the Borg?

Not neccessarily. Remember that the Halkans in "Mirror, Mirror" were pretty much the same in both universes (Except they were a little more haggard-looking in the Mirror Universe).
 
USA practiced slavery for a long time. Was everyone who ever owned slaves evil?

Perhaps. Was anyone ever forced, against their will, to own slaves? Just because "everyone was doing it" doesn't make it any less evil. Everyone has a choice.

Yes, that's right. You have to remember the context of the time... you have people who were taken from their homeland, brought to a strange world where their language wasn't spoken, and then were expected to cope with it. They managed, without any formal education, to learn basic language. Beyond that... well, if they were set free then, they wouldn't know what to do. There were slave owners who cared well for their them, and there were plenty who didn't. I'd say the good/evil question would lie upon the treatment of the slaves at that point.

Once the slaves had begun to gain more education and improve their ability to fend for themselves, they had the opportunity to think for themselves more, see beyond the bondage. And eventually it started to become evident to their owners that they weren't "inferior" as previously thought. This led to enlightenment... until one day, they were eventually freed.


Anyway, I wouldn't say the "mirror" aspect meant good becomes evil and evil becomes good. It was a reflection in many respects, but of course not everything would be "reversed". This one particular parallel universe we've seen depicted in TOS, DS9, and ENT shows some species more aggressive/warlike while others a little less so.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top