• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

If TOS Was Made Today...

J

Jetfire

Guest
Would the ethnicity, religion, gender & sexual orientation of the crew be different?

Would Kirk be female...maybe lesbian?
Would There be no Scotty?
Uhura be Persian or Arab and Muslim?
Chekov...well no need to change to reflect the times.
Sulu...no need to change to reflect the times.
What about McCoy???

Would it be even more diverse?
 
It would likely be a mid 20's group of white people spending more time whining about their personal problems then exploring.

;)
 
The cast would be at least four times as large, there'd be at least one terrorist in the group, and we'd have a lot more time travel episodes. :p And either a smoke monster or a shape-shifter would live in the Jeffries tubes, and every alien would be some absurd CGI thing just because we can.
 
Would the ethnicity, religion, gender & sexual orientation of the crew be different?

Would Kirk be female...maybe lesbian?
Would There be no Scotty?
Uhura be Persian or Arab and Muslim?
Chekov...well no need to change to reflect the times.
Sulu...no need to change to reflect the times.
What about McCoy???

Would it be even more diverse?

Kirk would be a female and a lesbian.
Spock would be a CGI alien.
McCoy would be a stereotypical redneck and the show's comic relief.
Scotty would be the standard bookwormish nerd who is good with computers.
Chekov would be a 'roid-rage super jock hellbent on converting female-Kirk to heterosexuality.
Uhura would be female-Kirk's lover.
Sulu - no change
 
It was made today. Last year in fact. It was called Star Trek XI.

Of course, that was only one take.
 
^
Did J. J. Abrams base it on TOS or TOS source material? I haven't seen it...so I really can't say...but it looks like it may have been on the show and he added his own stuff.

What I mean is the original idea...no TOS to go buy...if that was made today...I am sure alot would be tweaked to fit the times.
 
A lot would depend on the general approach and intent. Of course one has to realize that much of contemporary sci-fi on TV is influenced in some measure by the existence of TOS. If TOS had not existed then who knows what sci-fi would be like on TV today.

But if we assume things could be pretty much as they are today yet without TOS ever having existed then I suspect Star Trek would be more like nuBSG or the shallowness of ST09. Or perhaps like Andromeda. :eek:

If TNG had been the first Trek and been made exactly as it had then things might have unfolded much as it has. In that event than a contemporary TOS might likely be no better than what VOY and ENT wrought. :rolleyes:

At best we could hope it could have sensibilities similar to Stargate: SG-1, Stargate: Atlantis or Babylon 5.
 
I just wonder based on, using TOS scripts...if it was made today would it be more like TOS or something totally different...characters changed to fit the times...etc.
 
I just wonder based on, using TOS scripts...if it was made today would it be more like TOS or something totally different...characters changed to fit the times...etc.
I think it's safe to say it wouldn't resemble the TOS we know much at all.
 
It was made today. Last year in fact. It was called Star Trek XI.

Exactly so.

Based on that but mainly on common sense there are a couple of obvious differences:

The age of most of the characters would be younger, with one or two (most likely McCoy or Scotty) older than on the original series.

Uhura would have a more substantial, important part on the series and at least one of the other regulars would be a woman - most likely Spock.
 
It was made today. Last year in fact. It was called Star Trek XI.

Exactly so.

Based on that but mainly on common sense there are a couple of obvious differences:

The age of most of the characters would be younger, with one or two (most likely McCoy or Scotty) older than on the original series.

Uhura would have a more substantial, important part on the series and at least one of the other regulars would be a woman - most likely Spock.
This is very sensible. One of the reason of TOS popularity it's because its characters are very archetypal.

Kirk won't be very different as the action hero: a white young man burdened with responsibilities beyond his age

Spock would be most likely a black or a woman, in the same vein many especially smart characters have been portrayed recently (even if I always thought that Nimoy's Jewishness worked very well for Spock). There will be sexual tension with Kirk (open if heterosexual, as "bromance" if homosexual).

McCoy would be probably older, a cranky old fellow and confindent to hero Kirk. It would have a secret and tragic past.

Scotty would be probably more nerdy/geeky and more of a computer genius than a "miracle worker": I can actually see his as being younger than his classical self. Not sure if he would actually be Scottish: even in that case, I would bet it would be very much downplayed.

Sulu would be actually from Asia and not just San Francisco: I would say he would be more serious and laconic. Another candidate for a tragic past. Another take would be making the character female: in that case I would say they will make her younger and shyer.

Chekov would be more or less as we saw him in the ST09: young, naive and comically Russian. In case Sulu were a girl, the two would be paired.

Uhura would be the one with the most apparent changes, as the role need to be expanded: my money would be that her African heritage would be downplayed or outright ignored, but there will be much emphasis in her ability to kick ass, making her a "tough girl".
 
^^ Nonsense. ST09 is the way it is because it was drawing on things already established than filtered through a Star Wars mindset. If TOS hadn't existed before (which seems to be the intent of the OP) then it would be creating things from scratch.

The series would be more like VOY, ENT or Andromeda. It might be something like nuBSG.

I seriously doubt it would have any more substance than that, which is to say little to none.

If a show like ENT or VOY or ST09 as a series were the first Trek then it likely wouldn't have any lasting notice with the viewing public. For one thing the times are different today. Something is noticed then forgotten as the "next thing" comes along.

ST09 was meant to evoke a sense of nostalgia and familiarity with something that existed before. Without that ST09 would have to stand on its own as the piece of mindless action fluff that it is.
 
For a female Spock, look not so much to T'Pol but to Temperance Brennan of Bones. Indeed, the relationship between Bones and Booth--true t'hy'las if there ever were--is almost exactly what the relationship between a male Kirk and female "Spock" would be.
 
Uhura would be the one with the most apparent changes, as the role need to be expanded: my money would be that her African heritage would be downplayed or outright ignored, but there will be much emphasis in her ability to kick ass, making her a "tough girl".

For a female Spock, look not so much to T'Pol but to Temperance Brennan of Bones.

Unfortunately I have to agree here. It's almost impossible to have a female character on television anymore who is a ball-busting "tough girl," at least on the shows I've seen recently.
 
^
Why can't a lead female character be delicate and feminine...I think a Vulcan female could be this way...but less subtle.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top