• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers IDW Star Trek - New Visions - John Byrne

Some NEW VISIONS detractors had been complaining about the stories being too "wordy". I feel that that is unjustified; TOS was always heavy-dialog/character driven. Expository dialog was always part and parcel of Star Trek.
In "Swarm", Spock has quite a bit of exposition; I don't think it detracts from the story one bit.
But there will always be complainers, I suppose.
I noticed that the latest issue had quite a few larger panels, which worked very well for the more action-oriented story. I wonder if it's the start of a trend.
 
Just have to share this: Byrne created a page that answers how Khan "remembered" Chekov in TWOK when we know Walter Koenig hadn't yet been cast as Chekov.
tumblr_nnjeim6jRc1s0pt79o1_500.jpg

This didn't appear in any NEW VISIONS story (at least, not yet), but JB wanted to "scratch a thirty-odd year itch".
I think it's great!
 
I noticed that the latest issue had quite a few larger panels, which worked very well for the more action-oriented story. I wonder if it's the start of a trend.
JB has been playing with this since "Resistance", the Borg story. Also, some close-ups as well.
His issues feel like TOS, but are have comic pacing and "layout".
 
Just have to share this: Byrne created a page that answers how Khan "remembered" Chekov in TWOK when we know Walter Koenig hadn't yet been cast as Chekov.
tumblr_nnjeim6jRc1s0pt79o1_500.jpg

This didn't appear in any NEW VISIONS story (at least, not yet), but JB wanted to "scratch a thirty-odd year itch".
I think it's great!
It won't appear in New Visions, as Ricardo Montalban is not one of the actors whose likeness Byrne is allowed to use.
 
MCCOY: Spock, isn't it enough the commodore is famous for his hospitality? I, for one, could use a good non-reconstituted meal.
SPOCK: Doctor, you are a sensualist.
MCCOY: You bet your pointed ears I am.
-- from "Arena"
When on Mr. Byrne's Forum I pointed out that this scene and dialog was one of my favorites, he pointed out the "racism of Dr. McCoy". I argued that only McCoy, having worked with Spock long enough could get away with that line; Scotty, Sulu, Uhura, et al wouldn't dare try it.
Mr. Byrne disagreed strongly. In NEW VISIONS he has omitted those type of lines, removing some of the "charm", in my opinion, of McCoy's character.
I don't believe Dr. McCoy is a racist at all. He just enjoys his verbal sparring with Spock and Spock "tolerates" it a deference to the captain and McCoy's friendship.
I feel the same way, and always get a little annoyed when people call McCoy racist. I always assumed all of insults towards Spock were just him joking around and trying to get some kind of emotional reaction out of him.
 
Just got an email that my copy of the Humble Bundle mini-issue has shipped. I look forward to recieving it soon.
 
I feel the same way, and always get a little annoyed when people call McCoy racist. I always assumed all of insults towards Spock were just him joking around and trying to get some kind of emotional reaction out of him.

His intention was not to be racist. He just takes it for granted that Spock's ears are a prominent feature that he can use to tease/identify him with. In that way, it's almost moved beyond racism, where he doesn't regard it as a racial feature but just Spock's. It would be like if Spock called McCoy "Blue Eyes".
 
His intention was not to be racist.
Exactly. Which is what I was trying to get across to Mr. Byrne before he dismissed me.
McCoy and Spock had been working together long enough by the point of "Arena" that Spock "tolerated" McCoy's emotional outbursts.
Now, we have never "seen" McCoy's first meeting/introduction to Mr. Spock; how soon after they met did McCoy first "zing" Spock with a wisecrack. What did Spock say or do that exasperated McCoy enough to start the verbal sparring?
That would be a tale ... .
 
Or did McCoy start out as just another doctor on the Enterprise, only to be promoted when Piper left?
According to the Goodman Kirk autobiography, Piper retired, and Kirk asked McCoy (whom he had known for some time) to join the Enterprise.
For me, personally, I always felt McCoy was there at the beginning, and Dr. Piper filled in (during "Where No Man Has Gone Before") while McCoy attended daughter Joanna's graduation from med school.
 
How did Kirk know/meet him?
Again, according to Goodman's "autobiography", McCoy was the medical officer on the U. S. S. Hotspur, which Kirk was assigned to and they became friendly.
Later Kirk assumed command of the Hotspur, and asked for his Academy roommate Gary Mitchell. Therefore, Kirk, Mitchell and McCoy are established as friends/friendly.
 
Not really.
In the "turbolift" scenario, Spock may have given McCoy a dry, "pithy" reply like that. Or he may have ignored it at that point, waiting for a more face to face moment.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top