Hurt/Heal Game: Best TOS Episode: Season 3

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

So we have 20 episodes for the grand final:

SEASON ONE
01st: Where No Man Has Gone Before
02nd: The City on the Edge of Forever
03rd: The Devil in the Dark
04th: Balance of Terror
05th: Errand of Mercy
06th: The Corbomite Maneuver
07th: The Cage
08th: The Menagerie, Part I & II
09th: A Taste of Armageddon
10th: This Side of Paradise

SEASON TWO

01st: Journey to Babel
02nd: Amok Time
03rd: Mirror, Mirror
04th: The Trouble with Tribbles
05th: The Doomsday Machine
06th: Obsession
07th: The Ultimate Computer
08th: By Any Other Name
09th: Return to Tomorrow
10th: Metamorphosis

Possibly not totally unexpected results, however a few of my favourites didnt make it: (Miri, The Changeling for two)

So lets see what the next 10 will be:

OK its the final season

Rules:

Each episode starts on 10 points.

1 Vote every calander day per member.

On each vote you must both:

Heal your favourite story + 1

& Hurt your least favourite stoy -2

(You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)

Once a story reaches Zero its out

Stories are ranked in order of elimination

Please indicate which episoes you have voted for

Season 3:

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
And the Children Shall Lead 10
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 10
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 10
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 10
Requiem for Methuselah 10
The Savage Curtain 10
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[Michael]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
And the Children Shall Lead 8 -
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 10
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 10
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 10
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11 +
Requiem for Methuselah 10
The Savage Curtain 10
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[idreamedmusic]

And the fun continues, yay!

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
And the Children Shall Lead 8
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 10
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11 +
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 10
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 10
The Savage Curtain 8 -
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[Orac]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 10
And the Children Shall Lead 6 -
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 10
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 10
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11 +
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[Geck]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 11 +
And the Children Shall Lead 6
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 10
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 8 -
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 11
And the Children Shall Lead 4 -
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11 +
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[Defcon]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12 +
And the Children Shall Lead 2 -
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 10
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 10
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 10
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 11 +
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead -

 

[DevilintheDark]

This is the only season i dont have on DVD and i barely remember alot of these episodes...some i dont remember at all, so i may not have even seen them.Ill abstain from this round.

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 8-
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 11+
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 11
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 11
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead -

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 10
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 8
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 12+
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 10
The Mark of Gideon 11
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 9-
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Kagan]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 8-
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 8
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 12
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11+
The Mark of Gideon 11
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 9
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 10

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Mallory]

At least Spock's Brain gave us both pleasure and pain. Janice Lester gave us neither.

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 8
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 8
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 13 +
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 11
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 9
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8 -

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[c5maier]

I did not check back but was 62 mins from start to the first elimination a new record? Not that I mind. Then again ...
It's really a shame for the big rec room that it was only in this abysmal episode, I think it would otherwise get much more attention and treatment. It must have been designed almost exactly fourty years ago. I hope to see it in a re-animated "Time Trap" episode some day!

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 10
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 8
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9 +
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 13
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 10
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9 -
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 9
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Orac]

Spectre of the Gun 10
Elaan of Troyius 11 +
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 8
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 13
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8 -
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 9
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Outpost4]

Spectre of the Gun 11 +
Elaan of Troyius 11
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 12
Spock's Brain 8
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 13
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 7 -
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[EnsignJulka]

Spectre of the Gun 11
Elaan of Troyius 11
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 13+
Spock's Brain 6-
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 13
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 10
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 7
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Jackson_Roykirk]

Elaan of Troyius 11
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 13
Spock's Brain 6
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 14+
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 8-
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 8
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 7
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 8

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[Geck]

Elaan of Troyius 11
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 13
Spock's Brain 6
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 9
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 14+
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 8-
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 6 -
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 7
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 9 +

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead

 

[egonbeeblebrox]

Elaan of Troyius 11
The Paradise Syndrome 10
The Enterprise Incident 13
Spock's Brain 6
Is There in Truth no Beauty? 7-
The Empath 10
The Tholian Web 15+
For the World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky 8
Day of the Dove 10
Plato´s Stepchildren 10
Wink of an Eye 11
That Which Survives 8
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield 11
Whom Gods Destroy 11
The Mark of Gideon 9
The Lights of Zetar 6
The Cloud Minders 10
The Way to Eden 7
Requiem for Methuselah 11
The Savage Curtain 8
All Our Yesterdays 10
Turnabout Intruder 9

Eliminated:
24th: And the Children Shall Lead