Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 3

[Natural]

Defiant 6
Past Tense, Part One 3 +
Past Tense, Part Two 4
Destiny 3
Visionary 25
Improbable Cause 36
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 2 -

Eliminated:
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[boognish]

Defiant 7 +
Past Tense, Part One 1 -
Past Tense, Part Two 4
Destiny 3
Visionary 25
Improbable Cause 36
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 2

Eliminated:
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[erastus25]

Defiant 7
Past Tense, Part One 1
Past Tense, Part Two 2 -
Destiny 3
Visionary 25
Improbable Cause 36
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 3 +

Eliminated:
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[Geck]

Defiant 7
Past Tense, Part One 1
Destiny 4 +
Visionary 25
Improbable Cause 36
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 3

Eliminated:
8th: Past Tense, Part Two 2
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[RaymondJames]

Defiant 7
Past Tense, Part One 1
Destiny 4
Visionary 25
Improbable Cause 37 (+)
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 1 (-)

Eliminated:
8th: Past Tense, Part Two 2
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[BigFoot]

Defiant 8 +
Past Tense, Part One 1
Destiny 4
Visionary 23 -
Improbable Cause 37The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 1

Eliminated:
8th: Past Tense, Part Two 2
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[ZMistress]

Defiant 8
Past Tense, Part One 1
Destiny 5 +
Visionary 21 -
Improbable Cause 37
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 1

Eliminated:
8th: Past Tense, Part Two 2
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[c5maier]

Defiant 6 -
Past Tense, Part One 2 +
Destiny 5
Visionary 21
Improbable Cause 37
The Die is Cast 11
The Adversary 1

Eliminated:
8th: Past Tense, Part Two 2
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[naf9sd]

Defiant 6
Destiny 5
Visionary 21
Improbable Cause 37
The Die is Cast 12 +
The Adversary 1

Eliminated:
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[D'deridex]

Defiant 6
Destiny 3 -
Visionary 21
Improbable Cause 37
The Die is Cast 12
The Adversary 3 +

Eliminated:
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[Garth Rockett]

D'deridex gave The Adversary two instead of one, so I'm adjusting it's score.

Defiant 6
Destiny 1 -
Visionary 21
Improbable Cause 38 +
The Die is Cast 12
The Adversary 2

Eliminated:
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[Michael]

Destiny the sixth best? Never.

Defiant 6
Visionary 22 +
Improbable Cause 38
The Die is Cast 12
The Adversary 2

Eliminated:
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

Defiant 6
Visionary 22
Improbable Cause 39+
The Die is Cast 12

Eliminated:
5th: The Adversary -
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[Defcon]

Defiant 6
Visionary 20 -
Improbable Cause 39
The Die is Cast 13 +

Eliminated:
5th: The Adversary -
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[erastus25]

Defiant 6
Visionary 18 -
Improbable Cause 39
The Die is Cast 14 +

Eliminated:
5th: The Adversary -
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian[/quote]

 

[Geck]

Destiny the sixth best? Never.

Really? I find it incredibly powerful. It's probably one of my Top 10 DS9 eps.

 

[Michael]

Destiny the sixth best? Never.

Really? I find it incredibly powerful. It's probably one of my Top 10 DS9 eps.

Oh, don't get me wrong; I really like Destiny. I just think Past Tense, Second Skin and Explorers are much better.

 

[Geck]

Fair enough I would have had Second Skin in the Top 5 of the season as well. I do think Destiny is much better than either Defiant or The Adversary though.

That's the problem with DS9, it's all so damn good it's hard to rank.

 

[Natural]

Defiant 6
Visionary 19 +
Improbable Cause 39
The Die is Cast 12 -

Eliminated:
5th: The Adversary
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian

 

[Frenzy]

Defiant 7 +1
Visionary 18
Improbable Cause 39
The Die is Cast 12 -2

Eliminated:
5th: The Adversary -
6th: Destiny
7th: Past Tense, Part One
8th: Past Tense, Part Two
9th: Civil Defense
10th: Facets
11th: Second Skin
12th: The Search, Part One
13th: Through the Looking Glass
14th: The House of Quark
15th: Explorers
16th: Prophet Motive
17th: Distant Voices
18th: Equilibrium
19th: Family Business
20th: The Search, Part Two
21st: Life Support
22nd: Shakaar
23rd: The Abandoned
24th: Fascination
25th: Heart of Stone
26th: Meridian[/quote]