• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

How Would You Get The Band Back Together?

This was fun, didn't expect it to end up being quite so long, but here we go:

Picard retired from Starfleet shortly after the events of Nemesis - his encounter with Shinzon shook him on a very personal level and the loss of Data, who he regarded as a son, deeply upset him. He spent a few years indulging his love of archaeology before becoming Federation ambassador to Romulus, successfully negotiating a treaty to end hostilities and make the Romulan Empire a formal ally of the Federation. He then returned to Earth to enjoy his retirement at the old family vineyard in LaBarre.

Riker captained the Titan for several years, making first contact with many new species and becoming quite a successful diplomat in his own right, something he credits to all those years working under Picard. Although considered a competent captain and a safe pair of hands, he was no longer regarded as the dynamic maverick he was at the beginning of his tenure on the Enterprise, and as such never got a shot at the 'big chair' he coveted for so long. He always saw himself as a career captain but after a string of commands (including the USS Lollipop) he finally agrees to take a promotion to Admiral and a desk job at Starfleet Command at Troi's behest so that they can raise their children together and in safety. He yearns to be back out among the stars.

Data's memories were unable to be recovered from B4's brain without permanently damaging him. B4 remains his simple childlike self, though occasionally has moments of 'lucidity' and clarity when he is able to offer a surprisingly accurate comment, insight or analysis. If you didn't know any better, you could swear it was Data himself speaking. He now lives with Picard at his vineyard.

Geordi spent a few more years as chief engineer on the Enterprise-E before its destruction at the hands of an angry space baby. Deciding to pursue a command of his own, he served as Riker's XO on the Titan for a couple of years before finally gaining command of the Challenger (which he loved, as he cut his teeth on the 'old' Galaxy Class). He is now retired from Starfleet and has gone back to engineering in a civilian capacity, designing warp drive systems. He still can't talk to girls.

Troi served as Counselor on the Titan, but later gave that up in order to pursue her own private psychiatry practice on Betazed (a difficult job when everyone can hear each others' thoughts), taking her and Riker's children to live with her there. She later persuaded Riker to give up the life of a starship captain, and they moved back to Earth.

Beverly Crusher left the Enterprise at the same time as Picard, returning to Starfleet Medical. She wrote several papers based on her experiences as CMO of the Enterprise, and is considered one of the foremost experts on the treatment of liberated Borg drones. She now teaches classes on starship medicine at the Academy.

During his stint as Federation ambassador to Qo'noS, Worf found despite being part of Martok's family he was still ostracised by most Klingons as being 'tainted' by humans. Returning to Starfleet, the one place he felt truly accepted, he spent some time on DS9 as Kira's second officer and security chief before returning to starship life. Due to his actions during the Dominion War he never achieved a command of his own, though he had a distinguished career as a first officer, serving on many ships in this capacity (including for a brief time one of Riker's later commands). Due to Klingons' long lifespans, he is still in his prime, a mere 70 or so years old, and still out there serving on starships. He still craves one day to die in glorious battle and join Jadzia in Stovokor.

Miles O'Brien is still a grumpy engineering lecturer (with a heart of gold, though he doesn't like showing it) at the Academy. He dotes on his wife Keiko, his son and daughter and his five grandchildren. Once a year, he gets mysteriously abducted and subjected to unspeakable horrors which take several months of counseling to recover from. He regularly meets up with Julian Bashir to visit the Alamo.

Wesley Crusher returned from exploring other planes of existence to work as a Lieutenant (jg) on the engineering night shift on the Titan. While there, he single handedly saved the ship from destruction no less than seventeen times. When Riker got sick of him, he went to Jupiter station to study B4 and try to find a way to recover Data's personality. To aid him in this, he reactivated Lore's head, who, despite being evil, genuinely loved his brother and tried to assist Wesley, though he constantly told Wes to shut up, kept trying to trick him into putting his head back onto his body and once tried to kill him by using his neural interface to hack into the station's systems and blow out an airlock. Despite this, Lore has mellowed in his old age and he and Wes have become friends. Having determined there was no way to extract Data from B4, he sent B4 to live with Picard and stayed on at Jupiter station. Wes keeps Lore's head in his quarters, where they get into hilarious 'odd couple' arguments and occasional (and entirely 'accidental') near-death experiences.

As for the incident that reunites them, I don't know - my brain is burned out from imagining where they all are 'now'. The usual Federation/galaxy threatening threat, I guess? Maybe one of the enemies/entities they all defeated back on the Enterprise-D has returned, bigger and stronger.

All that aside, there's also the question as to which Enterprise to use in the picture. The D is the sentimental favorite, though there may be bigger ones around as well by that time. The E I felt was an over-engined Hasbro toy or a stretched and emaciated plastic surgery nightmare of a flagship, but it is what it is. Dare we throw them on the F (would they command it or be passengers as on the Pasteur?) and at some point come across a D or a pair of E's, like contemporary Excelsiors?
If most (or all) of the gang have moved on from Starfleet and on with their lives, I think it'd be more fitting if they used a scrounged/borrowed/salvaged/stolen old rustbucket of a ship that they rechristen Enterprise for the purpose of their mission, maybe painting the name on the hull by hand as Kirk & co did with their stolen Klingon ship.

Maybe the real Enterprise (F? G even?) can make a cameo at some point, or join up with the heroes later, swooping in for the rescue when their old jalopy is about to bite the (space)dust. I'd like to see an all-new crew on it, no familiar faces. All clearly super competent. Bright, young, the best of the best - with a seasoned captain they all look up to, and a familiar cameraderie. The next Next Generation.
 
Last edited:
Can you say carbon copy of Star Trek 3!?

Geordi, now a civilian engineer is doing a scan of B4 when all of a sudden B4 says something only Data could know, he tells Both Crushers and Riker all still in Star Fleet but they either don't believe him or he can't replicate it to them. A year passes, it happens again, this time really validating that it's Data, even telling him about some MacGuffin on some planet needed to bring Data back. Geordi by now bit fanatical about it tries to get Captain Riker to get him there. Of course, its DEEP in Romulan/cardassian/Klingon/you name it - space. Finally Riker agrees to it, they steal the Titan going there, on the way they pick up Troi. Picard now an admiral sends Captain Worf to get them back.. lots fighting ensues, Titan blows up, they're all stranded on some planet, etc etc etc, Data is back!
 
And yes Brent Spiner can absolutely still play Data, just CGI old data's face on him.

CGI has come a LONG way and I'm sure if they use Brent Spiner, have him do all the scenes with Motion and performace capture to get all his movements and facial expressions, slap a CGI face on him and voila.
 
It's great reading through all your ideas. Some great stuff.

I thought about making the story The Return of Data, but 1) as you say, it's been done, and 2) Spiner is even older now, and the CG isn't fully there yet. How do we explain the return of a clearly further-aged android?

Plus, I feel the movies have done a disservice to Data, making him even younger (dumber) than on the series when Spiner is anything but. Maybe this will still be the story, but it'd have to be something else. I'm dissapinted they didn't do an in-between TNG-Present/AGT-Future Data in the movies to bridge the gap; there was a bit of worldly mystery to Future Data.

Geordie's a ladies man. He's a writer, doing Michael Crichton-like technical-heavy fiction at the moment, and fully someplace else in his romantic evolution.

If Riker's an admiral, there are plenty of them on Betazed. She's not packing up House Troi to stand by her man, bored at the office.
 
Last edited:
The all get kidnapped by an obsessive collector who forces them to act out his fantasies on a life-sized Enterprise replica.
 
Reunite the whole gang?! I'd have broken them up and mixed and matched after Generations, and I'd far prefer a solo Old Man Picard movie (with maybe a brief cameo or two from the D staff) to a full-fledged reunion. :p
 
I think I'm going to keep La Forge a writer or at most a engineering advisor in civilian life. There are too many captains and ambassadors already, and that was a problem for TOS too, let alone Jonathan Archer, President of the Federation.

The Enterprise D was a pretty legendary ship in-universe, like the original 1701 of its time, so it's not unreasonable that a lot of the senior staff would go on to become captains.
 
This would be like if they did an original crew TOS movie in the mid-late 90's. It's not going to happen. I know most of this is just fan-fic stuff though.

Can you say carbon copy of Star Trek 3!?

Geordi, now a civilian engineer is doing a scan of B4 when all of a sudden B4 says something only Data could know, he tells Both Crushers and Riker all still in Star Fleet but they either don't believe him or he can't replicate it to them. A year passes, it happens again, this time really validating that it's Data, even telling him about some MacGuffin on some planet needed to bring Data back. Geordi by now bit fanatical about it tries to get Captain Riker to get him there. Of course, its DEEP in Romulan/cardassian/Klingon/you name it - space. Finally Riker agrees to it, they steal the Titan going there, on the way they pick up Troi. Picard now an admiral sends Captain Worf to get them back.. lots fighting ensues, Titan blows up, they're all stranded on some planet, etc etc etc, Data is back!

If they had done Nemesis instead of Insurrection for the third film this would have been great for the finale in 02.
 
And yes Brent Spiner can absolutely still play Data, just CGI old data's face on him.

CGI has come a LONG way and I'm sure if they use Brent Spiner, have him do all the scenes with Motion and performace capture to get all his movements and facial expressions, slap a CGI face on him and voila.

A few months back I was watching an episode of TNG (I think it was the one where Data's mother comes aboard and turns out she is an android). There was a throw away line about Data having an aging program that would allow him to age in appearance....I always felt this was put in to explain why Data might look older in the future.
 
Last edited:
The Enterprise D was a pretty legendary ship in-universe, like the original 1701 of its time, so it's not unreasonable that a lot of the senior staff would go on to become captains.
Not everyone wants to be a captain. Then admiral. Then ambassador. Then President of the Federation. It's cheese. Happens in fiction, but mostly not reality.

I don't know if I like Worf as a Klingon statesman. He should never have been ambassador, frankly. I'm imagining him as kind of a lackluster one, but who furthered Klingon-Federation unity. He was initially an orphan and warrior lieutenant. Then he becomes of noble birth, one of the most important ambassadors in the galaxy, and a member of the Klingon High Council? Who supersized this #4?

Beverly too. A medical ship? I can maybe just buy it (she was already a commander; in the Anti-Timeline she was looking to prove herself to her ex or herself; she'd come back to starship life after a year at Medical), but really, it's too TOS-like where you have three captains, an admiral, and a bunch of full commanders doing everything from treating the flu to answering phone calls.
 
Then President of the Federation. It's cheese. Happens in fiction, but mostly not reality.

That was Enterprise, though.

I don't know if I like Worf as a Klingon statesman. He should never have been ambassador, frankly. I'm imagining him as kind of a lackluster one, but who furthered Klingon-Federation unity. He was initially an orphan and warrior lieutenant. Then he becomes of noble birth, one of the most important ambassadors in the galaxy, and a member of the Klingon High Council? Who supersized this #4?

Yeah, that was on Ds9 so I sort of view it as separate from TNG even though it's the same character. Worf doesn't really seem like he has the temperament to be an ambassador. You'd want someone with a firm personality that the Klingons would respect, but it seems like another Klingon being ambassador would actually be a bad idea considering how they're always feeling honor bound to start blood feuds with each other and so forth.

Beverly too. A medical ship? I can maybe just buy it (she was already a commander; in the Anti-Timeline she was looking to prove herself to her ex or herself; she'd come back to starship life after a year at Medical), but really, it's too TOS-like where you have three captains, an admiral, and a bunch of full commanders doing everything from treating the flu to answering phone calls.

I don't really see anything implausible about that, like you said she was a full commander and had been chief medical officer on the flagship of the fleet, commanding a medical ship or having a cushy planet-side job seems like the logical next step in her career since she wasn't at retiring age.

Weren't Riker and Beverly the only ones we ever saw getting their own ships? In the case of Riker the implausible thing is that he stayed second banana to Picard for so long. After The Best of Both Worlds he would have been able to whatever command he wanted. I do think there's really anything over the top about how we saw their futures in All Good Things....
 
And yes Brent Spiner can absolutely still play Data, just CGI old data's face on him.

Do you mean young Data? ;)

CGI has come a LONG way and I'm sure if they use Brent Spiner, have him do all the scenes with Motion and performace capture to get all his movements and facial expressions, slap a CGI face on him and voila.

Good point. I was amazed to see a young Michael Douglas appear in Ant-Man's prologue. However, while doing it for one scene is probably negligible in dollar signs, can you imagine doing that for an entire movie? It's more likely that they'd do it for a couple of scenes early on. Then Riker would look at Data and say, "You look the same now as you did when I first met you at Farpoint. It must be great being an android. Not aging."

This comment would make Data think about the fact that his friends and colleagues are aging but constantly seeing a reminder of youth in him. With the help of Geordi, Bruce Maddox, Reg and anyone else they can rope in, they'd modify his appearance to make him appear older. Voila - Old Data.

A few months back I was watching an episode of TNG (I think it was the one where Data's mother comes aboard and turns out she is an android). There was a throw away line about Data having an aging problem that would allow him to age in appearance....I always felt this was put in to explain why Data might look older in the future.

.....or they could do this...

I'm a fan of Red Dwarf as well, and nothing is ever said about Rimmer's aging despite him being a hologram. It's sort of assumed that he's still being aged to fit in with the rest of the crew. Especially in the more recent Dave series when Chris Barrie is almost thirty years older than he first was in the first series.
 
Do you mean young Data? ;)

.....or they could do this...

I'm a fan of Red Dwarf as well, and nothing is ever said about Rimmer's aging despite him being a hologram. It's sort of assumed that he's still being aged to fit in with the rest of the crew. Especially in the more recent Dave series when Chris Barrie is almost thirty years older than he first was in the first series.

The episode of TNG I was thinking of was called Inheritance and there is a very blink and you'll miss it reference to Data having an aging program that allows him to gradually alter his appearance over time. This episode is in the 7th season so I often suspected that it was added to explain why Data looked different compared to first season.
 
Not everyone wants to be a captain. Then admiral. Then ambassador. Then President of the Federation. It's cheese. Happens in fiction, but mostly not reality.
Dwight Eisenhower was a general before he ran for president. And before he was a general he had to work his way through the ranks - i have no idea if he was politically connected or not; the fact is there is a strong precedent for former service members to enter politics; and in the US it was very common that the elected president had previously served. Granted, it's very rare for someone to start off as an ensign or lieutenant and eventually become President; but it's happened. Archer is simply that once-a-generation leader.
 
Dwight Eisenhower was a general before he ran for president. And before he was a general he had to work his way through the ranks - i have no idea if he was politically connected or not; the fact is there is a strong precedent for former service members to enter politics; and in the US it was very common that the elected president had previously served. Granted, it's very rare for someone to start off as an ensign or lieutenant and eventually become President; but it's happened. Archer is simply that once-a-generation leader.

Of course it's possible; many things are possible; Archer became president of the Federation, not King of the Mermen. But it's crazy unlikely, not the least of which because you'd think he'd get eaten alive in politics, and it was just so Horatio Hornblower fanwanky, in a series that was...the series went Captain Proton, right up to the evil Reptilians toasting with mice as they rolled the intro, muahahaha. Give the same writer another book deal and suddenly Archer's Imperator, Alpha Quadrantia. Napoleon started as a student at a military academy and ended one of the antichrists, but that story is significant in part because it's so farcically unusual. It's like writing Picard won the Powerball Lottery at the end of his life. Uh...okay? To me, Archer wasn't Eisenhower; he was Armstrong.
 
Of course it's possible; many things are possible; Archer became president of the Federation, not King of the Mermen. But it's crazy unlikely, not the least of which because you'd think he'd get eaten alive in politics, and it was just so Horatio Hornblower fanwanky, in a series that was...the series went Captain Proton, right up to the evil Reptilians toasting with mice as they rolled the intro, muahahaha. Give the same writer another book deal and suddenly Archer's Imperator, Alpha Quadrantia. Napoleon started as a student at a military academy and ended one of the antichrists, but that story is significant in part because it's so farcically unusual. It's like writing Picard won the Powerball Lottery at the end of his life. Uh...okay? To me, Archer wasn't Eisenhower; he was Armstrong.
It's not crazy unlikely at all for a gifted officer to eventually become president; considering the S1 political maneuvering he did to get Colonel Worf home in the pilot, and his constant clashing with the vulcans and starfleet command, he certainly knew how to play politics and stay in one piece.

And Wikipedia has an interesting article on Astronaut-Politicians; individuals who ran for public office after their NASA career. Your analogy to Armstrong is not that far off; again it's rare statistically speaking, but not beyond belief.
 
No, something else as well. There's a dehumanizing element to all the promotion-porn. I didn't like Kirk or Picard because I thought they'd become admiral or ambassador. Archer didn't seem the admiral or political type, positions overwhelmingly concerned with nuanced strategizing and opinion polling and schmoozing. Higher rank doesn't mean getting to do more of what you're brilliant at, as Kirk learned.

It's disrespectful and insulting to the characters and the viewers to make them these silly, unrealistic figures just to add some additional level of validation to, what, the viewer for liking them? I suppose, as Trump said of Romney or whomever, they're total losers because they didn't make president. Ok, okay.
 
No Data. He died. Have Brent Spiner write the movie or something.

Picard is still the Captain of the Enterprise-E (as he will be, forever...). But his crew has finally scattered to the winds.

Riker is Captain of the Titan. Troi is there too. Crusher is at Starfleet Medical. Geordi is Captain of the Challenger. And Worf just shows up with no explanation.

They all unite on the Enterprise for some anniversary/press junket or other, and then things go awry.
 
No Data. He died. Have Brent Spiner write the movie or something.

Picard is still the Captain of the Enterprise-E (as he will be, forever...). But his crew has finally scattered to the winds.

Riker is Captain of the Titan. Troi is there too. Crusher is at Starfleet Medical. Geordi is Captain of the Challenger. And Worf just shows up with no explanation.

They all unite on the Enterprise for some anniversary/press junket or other, and then things go awry.

You know what would be totally out there is to have Picard bringing in the E for its decommissioning and telling a young kid onboard the tales of each of that original crew he served with. It's decades later and they've all died or disappeared or are offscreen for one reason or another, and he, the oldest, the one you would expect to be ambassador or what have you (or dead!) is the last of them, telling the tale. There's something bittersweet about that.

Worf was assassinated, going down in combat, a rallying cry to complete Klingon Federation membership. Troi died on an away mission from Titan, and though Riker was more prepared for it than you might think (AGT stayed with him), he lost interest ultimately in career and retired early. Geordie disappeared beyond Federation space doing research for a book with Lenny, er, B4 (some think the Casanova was done in by a female spy). And Beverly's remarried on the Pasteur, helping out newly free subject species of the former Klingon Empire in disarray who didn't choose to join the Federation.

The movie ends with the boy's mother showing up as they're about to enter spacedock. "That's a heck of a story," Tasha says, and they smile at each other. On screen is the Enterprise-F, a long, gleaming, half transparent, living crystal of a ship. The entire original crew, including Data, are there for the ceremony.

...hehehe not the story, but a fun aside
 
Last edited:
Holy Jesus and J.K. Rowling, I may have the ending.

...now to come up with the epic to get to it.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top